Common Sense Note
Parents need to know that there's not much to worry about here -- one evil bandit falls off a cliff after making threats. All in all, there is lots of girl-empowerment and learning about looking past the masks people wear.
Families who read this book could discuss all of the characters who turn out not to be the way they seem. Why did each one act the way he or she did? Why do people hide their feelings behind anger and meanness? How does Miri learn to see past these personas? Also, why is Miri's home, which is a hard place, so important to her? Why does the tutor treat the girls the way she does? And, perhaps most interesting of all, could we apply the rules of diplomacy that are taught to the girls in our own lives?
Common Sense Review
Reviewed By: Matt Berman
Despite the title, from which a bookstore browser might assume that this is another one of those goopy, middle-grade, princess-and-tea-party series books, this book actually deserves the Newbery Honor it has won.
This surprisingly moving novel conveys a depth of understanding of people, and their often confusing and misleading ways of behaving. It's a coming-of-age novel of the best sort.
Although there are hints of fantasy in the vaguely telepathic "quarry-speak" that the mountain-dwelling villagers take for granted, Miri is as real as can be, a down-to-earth heroine who succeeds despite insecurity and misunderstanding, through guts and hard work.
The story is filled with moments of great satisfaction: the girls finally stand up to their tutor who, it turns out, was just hoping for them to do so; Miri convinces the village elders to use the principles of commerce and diplomacy she has learned to improve their lot; and every time Miri sees past someone's facade and into their hearts.
It's a lovely story, full of gentle wisdom and the joy of family and community.
From The Book
Miri's first thought was bandits, but why would they attack Mount Eskel? Every villager knew the story of the last bandit attack before Miri was born, when the exhausted outlaws had finally reached the village at the top of the mountain only to find little worth stealing and a horde of men and women made strong by years in the quarry. The bandits had run off with empty hands and a few more bruises, and had never returned.
"What is it, Pa?" asked Miri.
"Soldiers."
Plot Summary:
Miri lives with her father and older sister in their high mountain village, where they quarry linder, a marble-like stone used for palaces in the lowlands. Unlike the other girls in the village, Miri has never been allowed in the quarry. She believes it is because she is too small and weak, and that the rest of the village must resent and despise her. But all of the foundations of her life are shaken when it is announced that the prince will choose a wife from among the girls of her village, and that all of the girls between ages 12 and 18 must leave their homes to be trained for a year before meeting the prince. They must go to a "Princess Academy" to be established three hours down the mountain.
At the Academy, though their tutor is strict and rather mean, Miri discovers that she enjoys learning, which comes in handy when the other girls ostracize her for getting them all punished. But she also begins learning things her tutor never intended: how to see beyond people's facades to their true characters, how to enable her village to rise from poverty, and how to develop the mysterious "quarry-speak" into a means of wordless communication. What she can't figure out, though, is whether or not she hopes to be chosen as the next princess.
Related Books:
Also by Shannon Hale:
The Goose Girl
Enna Burning
Another Princess in Training
The Princess Diaries by Meg Cabot
| Content | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CS | adults | kids | ||
Sexual Content |
 |
|
|
|
ViolenceFighting between bandits and villagers, threats of murder, one death. |
 |
|
|
|
Language |
|
|
|
|
Message |
|
|
|
|
Social BehaviorMiri is brave and learns to understand others. |
 |
 |
 |
|
Commercialism |
|
|
|
|
Drug/Alcohol/Tobacco |
|
|
|
|
