Book Reviews

Book Reviews -
A Season of Comebacks: Navigation

A Season of Comebacks

Rate It!
On 9+
3 stars

Girls in sports have been waiting for this book.

Author: Kathy Mackel Illustrator: none Pages: 116 Publisher: Penguin Putnam Inc. Published Date: 01/01/1997 Genre: Fiction - Sports HC Price: $12.70 Publisher's Recommended Reading Level: Ages 9-12 Read Aloud: 8-9 Read Alone: 9+

It's quick and easy to pass on
this great info!

Common Sense Note

Girls who love softball will love this book, which portrays them as important players. Some exciting softball action, and sprightly writing, but problems are resolved too easily.

Rate It!

Common Sense Review

Reviewed By: Monica Wyatt

Plenty of girls have become just as involved in sports as boys. They will cheer a book that portrays girls in sports as completely normal. Everyone in this story treats girls' softball as though it were the only game in town. The local newspaper interviews Allie and prints her pitching statistics as a regular feature. Crowds attend the games.

It's just as though girls never had trouble getting into sports. The girls in this book show no differences at all from boys. If the book were written about boys, only the names would have to be changed. Mackel touches upon none of the difficulties still experienced by girls in sports.

However, the writing sparkles. Her dialogue sounds like real kids, and she peppers the book with humor, such as Molly's wild throws into the stands. Kids will love this book, never noticing the impossibilities that so neatly tie the story together.

Mackel solves Molly's problems instantly. Molly says to her father, "You don't love me at all." Instantly, he transforms his character. Not only does he show love to both girls, but also he suddenly doesn't mind if the team loses. Instantly, we discover that Molly is as talented a catcher as Allie is a pitcher. And instantly, we learn that the team will play in the nationals. Fun, but all too easy.

For a realistic books about girls in sports, see the biography, Babe Didrikson Zaharias, by Russel Freedman. For humor that treats girls in sports honorably, try Jerry Spinelli's There's a Girl In My Hammerlock.

From The Book

Dad was grim. "I need a catcher." He looked at Jeni, Amanda, Laura. They all shook their heads no. He raised his eyebrows at Kelly, Lauren, Alyssa, Erin. More no's. He looked at Rhianna. A big chance for a bench warmer. She was quick to answer. "No way." He never even asked me.

Plot Summary:

Molly envies her big sister Allie, the best softball pitcher in California. Molly also loves softball and plays well, but their father only cares about Allie. Can the two sisters and their father reconcile? Girls in sports have been waiting for this book, which cheers them on all the way, but boys who give it a chance like it too.

Rate It! Send to a Friend

It's quick and easy to pass on
this great info!

Content
CS adults kids

Sexual Content

Violence

Language

Message

 

Social Behavior

The main character's father ignores everyone but his star daughter.

 

Commercialism

 

Drug/Alcohol/Tobacco

Rate It Now

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

OR

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

It only takes a minute to get great benefits! Sign up now and get a FREE Internet Survival Guide!