The Secret World of Hildegard

 Review

Common Sense Media says

Gorgeous artwork, but too ethereal for many kids.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Not yet rated

Kids say

Not yet rated

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that this biography only gives part of the story of Hildegard and creates a strange, somewhat terrifying, mystical world that might disturb some kids. The book is quite religious in nature and a better fit for those with a specific appreciation for or interest in Christian mysticism.


What's the story?

Hildegard von Bingen was a real woman who lived in the Middle Ages and, as a mystic visionary, did amazing things, especially for a woman in those times. This is an attempt to tell the story of her struggle to accept the mysterious power she was given and have the courage to share the visions she saw. It begins with the disturbing visions that terrify her as a child, and then moves with her to the monastery where she is taught as a young girl. There she learns to accept that her visions come from God, and she becomes headmistress as well as a scientist, composer, author, preacher, and more.


Is it any good?

 

Another collaboration by the mother/son team of Jeanette and Jonah Winter, THE SECRET WORLD OF HILDEGARD has a beautiful, vibrant cover and is filled with amazing, almost folksy, artwork of the kind found in their earlier book Diego. However, the subject matter here is way too ethereal for most picture book readers, and speaks more to those with specific appreciation for or interest in Christian mysticism, losing the rest of readers.

Of course, the story of Hildegard is a complicated one to tell. But, in an attempt to capture the mystical tone of her life, this telling slips into myth bordering on historical inaccuracy. The language seems as if it comes straight from a Nativity play; while it's supposed to convey Hildegard's religious significance, most kids won't understand it, nor will they make sense of the chant that repeats throughout the book or the language that describes the visions, even though both are presented in different fonts meant to set them apart. All in all, this was a courageous and artistic attempt to write about an unusual woman, but while tweens may be intrigued, The Secret World of Hildegard falls short of its aim. To its credit, however, it includes a bibliography at the end for those who want to do further study.


Sign Up Message
Sign up for our weekly newsletter
Each week we send a customized newsletter to our parent and teen subscribers. Parents can customize their settings to receive recommendations and parent tips based on their kids’ ages. Teens receive a version just for them with the latest reviews and top picks for movies, video games, apps, music, books, and more.
Please enter an email address.
Please check your email address for possible typos.
Sorry, you must be 13 or older to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.
Sign me up!

What families can talk about

Families can talk about the Middle Ages and what they might have been like. The author says that the men and the towns they ruled were gray -- what do you think he meant by that? What do you think it would be like to live in a world where you had to keep quiet and learn to serve and obey?


This review was written by Patricia Tauzer

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title below.


This review was written by Patricia Tauzer
Author:Jonah Winter
Illustrator:Jeanette Winter
Book type:Non-Fiction
Genre:History
Publisher:Arthur A. Levine
Publication date:September 1, 2007
Number of pages:64
Hardcover price:$16.99
Publisher's recommended age(s):9 - 12

This review was written by Patricia Tauzer
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.

Register now to save reviews and advice articles to your personal lists!


About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors

 

vote now

Will you read The Secret World of Hildegard?


Already read it? What do you think?

 

Been There? Tell us about it