This is such a timeless story that kids who miss the context clues--horses used for transportation, a gallows in the town square--might be surprised to discover at the end of the book that it's set in the 1880s. This eternal quality of the novel's setting and, literally, of its characters has helped the novel endure for twenty-five years.

In many ways, the story is a fairy tale, with a magical spring, a kidnapped heroine, an enchanted handsome prince, and even a bittersweet ending. Babbitt's eloquent descriptions of woods, ponds, and animals, though, elevate the novel from mere story to a lyrical meditation on the natural order. The dog days of summer, when the earth cracks and lighting flashes without thunder, are described with exquisite clarity. Cows, fish, and even one of the most memorable toads in children's literature are given personality and respect.

This is a wonderful book to read with children who have experienced the death of an older relative. Winnie's conversation with Angus Tuck about life, death, and the circle of life is a natural jumping-off point for family discussions. Children will also be eager to discuss Winnie's life-or-death decision. One ten-year-old said the book made her cry, but also made her think about her grandfather's death in a different way.

From the Book
If it's really elves, she thought, "I can have a look at them." And, though her instinct was to turn and run, she was pleased to discover that her curiosity was stronger. She began to creep forward. She would go just close enough, she told herself. Just close enough to see. And then she would turn and run.