The Cabinet of Earths

Review

Common Sense Media says

American kids find magical, creepy adventure in Paris.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Not yet rated

Kids say

Not yet rated

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that this debut from Anne Nesbet, UC Berkeley professor of Russian literature and the history of film (a follow-up is due in 2013), is a great adventure with an imaginative premise, engaging characters, Parisian local color, and an intelligent, nuanced look at family relationships and moral issues. But a few scenes -- particularly one involving convoluted antique machinery that extracts the life force from a child -- are creepy enough to induce nightmares in more sensitive young readers. Also, a good deal of historical, philosophical, and magical information relevant to the plot can become overwhelming. 

  • Educational value4
    Readers will pick up a bit of French as Maya does and experience the sights of Paris along with her (including the attraction her brother, James, enthusiastically dubs the "Evil Tower"). They'll also learn something about the French Revolution, and one of its particularly tragic victims, the scientist Antoine-Laurent Lavoisier, whose theory of the conservation of matter figures in the plot.
  • Positive messages5
    Maya discovers she has access to her ancestors' magical powers, but also learns the great good and great harm these powers can cause, not all of which are immediately obvious. She attains a good deal of wisdom, guided strongly by her love for her family.
  • Positive role models5
    Maya is a positive and believable figure; she is often angry, bewildered, and confused in her new and strange circumstances, but is smart, resourceful, and guided by good values. Her mother is both wise and appealing. Her classmate Valko, who is Bulgarian by birth but as the child of diplomats has been uprooted all his life, understands her feelings and offers her friendship and support.
  • Violence2
    The villains in The Cabinet of Earths are definitely up to no good. While there is no gore, there is much fiendish machinery, sometimes explicitly used on small children to their great detriment, and a frequent sense of creepiness. There is also past history of one brother betraying another to the Nazis, a scientist betraying another to the French Revolution, and other mortal treachery.
  • Sex0
    Not applicable.
  • Language0
    Not applicable.
  • Consumerism0
    Not applicable.
  • Drinking, drugs, & smoking0
    A key element of the plot involves a mysterious substance called anbar, which causes euphoria in its users and makes them act like drug addicts to obtain more of it.
CloseExpand to see more details

What's the story?

Thirteen-year-old Maya and her little brother, James, are reluctantly uprooted and moved to Paris -- where their mother, who's just beaten cancer, has always wanted to live, and their father has just found a dream job. Once there, Maya begins to suspect there's something more sinister going on than the homesickness and culture clash she feels, as she runs across spooky buildings, mysterious strangers, long-lost relatives, and unexplained events. With the help of her classmate Valko, she soon plunges into a life-changing adventure, and discovers a troubled family history dating back to the French Revolution.

Is it any good?

 

THE CABINET OF EARTHS gets top marks for navigating complex emotional territory -- the feelings of a girl who has been dealing with her beloved mother's cancer for several years, recognizes that she has no choice but to be a "good sport" and move to Paris because that's what her mom, now healthy, wants, and is still utterly miserable because she misses her dog so much. It also scores for an ingenious, thought-provoking premise and a plot with quite a few surprises. Its weakness lies in the fact that it has to convey a significant amount of newly invented cosmology, as well as historical and scientific information, for the plot to make sense. It all comes together by the end, but it may be confusing for some readers along the way.

Sign Up Message
Sign up for our weekly newsletter
Each week we send a customized newsletter to our parent and teen subscribers. Parents can customize their settings to receive recommendations and parent tips based on their kids’ ages. Teens receive a version just for them with the latest reviews and top picks for movies, video games, apps, music, books, and more.
Please enter an email address.
Please check your email address for possible typos.
Sorry, you must be 13 or older to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.
Sign me up!

What families can talk about

  • Families can talk about how even in the world of magic, everything has a cost, although the person who gets the benefit may not be the one who pays the price. Just because you can do something or have something, should you? 

  • Families can also talk about what it feels like to be the kid when one of the parents is going through cancer treatments, as Maya was for several years.

  • If you had the chance to go live in Paris, all expenses paid, for a year, would you go, or would you rather stay at home with your friends? Why?

This review was written by Mary Eisenhart

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title below.
This review was written by Mary Eisenhart
Topics:adventures
Author:Anne Nesbet
Book type:Non-Fiction
Genre:Fantasy
Publisher:HarperCollins Children's Books
Publication date:January 3, 2012
Number of pages:272
Hardcover price:$16.99
Publisher's recommended age(s):10
This review was written by Mary Eisenhart
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.
Our child development rating guidelines

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors

Magical classics
For kids who love fantasy
Browse more books
 

vote now

Will you read The Cabinet of Earths?

Won't miss it
On the fence
No way

Already read it? What do you think?

I recommend it
It's a pass
 
More from Common Sense Media
Age-appropriate reviews
Top advice and articles

Been There? Tell us about it