The Clique Summer Collection: Massie (by Lisi Harrison)

common sense media says

Rich-girl series is so materialistic it hurts.


parents & educators say
  • 33% say there are positive role models
  • 33% say there are positive messages

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that if they're on the fence about whether to let tweens read this book series, the best test is whether you think reality shows about out-of-touch rich girls are out of line or harmless fun (think My Super Sweet 16). This is the book equivalent. There's no real sex, drug-related, or violent content like in the Gossip Girl series. The main character is in middle school and focused on shopping, winning, and telling other girls that they're ugly so she can sell makeup at her summer job. When there's a lesson to be learned (winning isn't everything, beauty is on the inside), part of the humor is supposed to be that Massie will never change. This is a quick beach read and the first in the Clique summer series; each girl in Massie's "Pretty Committee" will get her own book -- one a month from April to August 2008.

Positive messages: Massie has to win no matter what and cheats to do it. She also tells other girls how "ugly" they are in a number of ways in order to sell makeup. When there's a lesson to be learned, the author puts it out there, and part of the humor is supposed to be that Massie will never change her ways and will always be a rich girl out of touch with reality.
Violence: Not applicable.
Sex: Not applicable.
Language: "Gawd" instead of "God" may put some off.
Consumerism: Nonstop onslaught of name brands -- to the point that the writing sounds like marketing-speak. Both the author and Massie seem obsessed with what everyone's wearing and whether it's good enough or pretty enough. Massie's many credit cards are taken away from her as punishment and given back quickly.
Drinking, drugs, & smoking: Massie's dad smokes a cigar. Adults drink at a party.

More on The Clique Summer Collection: Massie

What to talk about

Talk to your kids
Families can talk about whether they think characters like Massie are fun to read about or not. What other shows have you seen or books have you read that showcase lifestyles like Massie's? Would you rather be friends with someone like Massie or one of the girls she makes over? Would you like all her clothes and credit cards? Moms may also want to talk about all the makeup the middle school girls buy. What are your family's rules about makeup, credit cards, and shopping?

What's the story?

What's the story?
Massie Block starts the summer before eighth grade at riding camp, only to be kicked out when she gets caught pulling a stunt to try to win a competition. When her parents tell her she has to pay them back for the money they lost on the camp, she takes a job as a makeup rep for a new cosmetics company with a "beauty's on the inside" philosophy. Ignoring her training DVDs, Massie finds she's a lot more successful when she tells girls they're ugly and need to fix themselves. Suddenly business is booming. It's all going well until the company's president drops in to see Massie's selling techniques first-hand.

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 
This series releases one book a month during the summer of 2008; the first one -- MASSIE -- hit the top of the bestseller list right away. Kids who love reality shows and news about celebs like Paris Hilton will dive right in. The author tries to add humor in the fact that girls like Massie will never change, but it's not clever enough or scathing enough to be truly funny. And wouldn't it be nicer if she really learned from her mistakes? Then you could actually root for Massie in the end instead of wishing she'd suffer some crueler fate.

The worst part of the book is the way it's written. If you stripped out all mentions of designer brands, the book would be half the length (and that's barely an exaggeration). What's left is a bunch of text-messaging slang, catty comments stepped up with pop culture references, and a description of a very improbable summer job for an eighth grader. Oh, and she earns enough to pay back her parents for a summer of riding camp in just one week. Right. This book is $6.99 -- real girls should save their hard-earned babysitting money for a better beachy read.

Book themes & details

Book Details
Author: Lisi Harrison
Publisher: Poppy
Publication date: April 1, 2008
Number of pages: 123
Paperback price: $6.99
Read Aloud: 12
Read Alone: 12

This review was written by Carrie R. Wheadon
 
 

Review It

 

Review The Clique Summer Collection: Massie





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

What parents & educators say

12
Based on 6 parent & educator reviews:
  • 33% say there are positive role models
  • 33% say there are positive messages

Most useful reviews by all members

lovealwayskelly
kid, 13 years old
 
Common Sense is angering me with these reviews on The Clique books.
The whole point of the Clique books is that the girls are rich and materialistic. Massie tells girls the solid truth about themselves because that's the way she takes it;; beauty is truth. I would've taken it that way too. In all honesty it is pretty educational. Massie's dad smokes a cigar? big deal.

hyhyee
kid, 12 years old
 
ages 11 and up
great book, 11+

Squid Kid
kid, 13 years old
 
Massie is Annoying, She's Too Vain!
I hate how this girl, Massie, is so materialistic. She believes that you have to be appearance-obsessed and have the latest stuff to be happy. She's so haughty, and all the girly makeup and clothes references made me barf, As you may know, I'm 100% tomboy, and the main character was a spoiled brat who told the girls who didn't wear makeup or brand-name clothes that they were hideous. I don't wear makeup at all, and I usually wear jeans and a T-shirt. I LOVE to catch bugs outside, shoot hoops, and swim in my pool, and if Massie Block(head) were a real person, she'd be yapping about me how I'm chasing spiders and ladybugs (I'm getting a bit dirty) and swimming in a pool when I'm supposed to tan next to it. Seriously, Massie? She'd tell me to wear makeup and change my plain clothes out for designer stuff more than a bit often, and that I should be shopping at expensive boutiques and all that stupid stuff. She also avoids candy like the plague for some reason, and I eat candy like, once every two weeks. I'm into science, and something tells me she hates that. Don't use her as a role model, people.

royshan
parent of 18 year old
 
massie block is so mean

aquaprincess
teen, 15 years old
 
It depends
Massie tells girls how bad they look and how she can improve them. She also "steals fame", and only cares about whether she's the best or not. This book was definitely not written to educate. It was poorly written, but unless your child is so insecure she questions every decision she makes, go ahead and let them read it.

sojay
teen, 14 years old
 
Not approprite for kids under 11
This is a good book, but you have to understand where Massie Block (the main character) is coming from, you kind of have to understand how she looks at life and stuff.

Akademiks
parent of 11 year old
 
Perfect for anyone who reads at a six grade level
Oh ppl be quiet. What do you expect Tweens and teens to read? Fairtales about the princess who got saved by a prince and was bullies becuz she was poor and worked for an evil person. Hmmm. That sounds KIND of superficial to!! Besides, some kids dnt wanna read eragon or the notebook or stuff like that so u ahuldnt criticize their reading. It's just a little book and some of u ppl critisizing it sound dumb getting mad at a piece of paper and the successful author who wrote on it!!

toria575
teen, 16 years old
 
Great For Tweens Of All Ages!
I feel that some parents were overreacting, maybe your kids should learn and not be kept away from this so called "iffy stuff"

Massiekur61
teen, 13 years old
 
Massie is just insecure, that's why she acts like she does.
I love The Clique, though the characters never learn anything. For example, when Anastacia Breeze decided not to give her the purple streak because she insulted the costumers, Massie stole the pen to give herself the streak. But Massie does all the bad things she does because she is insecure. Sooner or later she'll become a better person.

thebookfreak
teen, 13 years old
 
not a good role model.. not a good book
I read the first chapter and threw the book across the room, there is no message except an obvious, "Massie learns to be nice!" great whoo hoo, all she cares about is "how you dress, or how you look" Massie is mean, rude, and not a good role model- save yourself and don't read this book

SavvySavannah
kid, 12 years old
 
Massie is not a good role model.
Massie loves to shop and shop and shop but the brands never stop.

earthgurl
teen, 15 years old
 
Great for 11+!
This was a good book, but you should read all of The Clique books before you read this. You will probably get confused if you do. Massie tells girls that they are ugly, but the books still great!

jennyhumphery
teen, 15 years old
 
Massie , Massie,Massie
I liked it but it was shallow and superfisial Massie isn't someone you should look up to but everyone wants to be her. It's the only book in the clique series i didn't like because its all about Massie.

 
Excellent, well-written read for 3rd grade and up
The Clique Summer Collection: Massie is a well-written guilty pleasure novel that is an enjoyable and entertaining read for 3rd grade and up. Kids will enjoy the tongue-in-cheek comebacks and the fun details of the wealthy and privileged. Your children should be smart enough to realize that this is guilty pleasure fiction and should not be taken seriously. A+

explosivetoaster
teen, 15 years old
 
Massie -- A Woman of Mystery
So maybe Massie is shallow, but there are girls who are that way. There are also girls who have their parent's credit card and such. At the end of the day, she doesn't seem to learn her lesson, but that's one of the points of the book. In the near end of the Clique series, that's what changes about her. She's "elastic" instead of "Lycra," meaning that she ends up loosening up and learning her lesson. She may not be the best role model because she lies, deceives, and looks down at others, but it just so happens that it gives the series a more realistic take on things. People don't always change -- they might, but not always.

TLfrvr101
teen, 14 years old
 
i really liked this clique book! but, you should read all of the other clique books before you read this one, because it won't make any sense if you don't.

itsprivate1
teen, 14 years old
 
I think this book was fine. Not saying some parents should love it and just give it to their children but if your kids are mature enough maybe discuss it with them. But I believe it was great and interesting with some iffy parts.

helenxoxo
teen, 15 years old
 
perfect for tweens but not teens
this book is gud 4 11 to 13 tear olds...im 14 and i thought it was boring

Moxy12
teen, 14 years old
 
AWSOME
Well this is the best book but the characters arn't the best role modles.I would still suggest this series they r one of my favorite books,Besides of couse TWILIGHT!

groovyrrr
teen, 15 years old
 
EVEN THO THIS GIRL MAY NOT BE THE BEST ROMEDEL ITS STILL A GOOD BOOK IT BETTER THAN ALL THOSE OTHER BOOKS THAT ARE (ON) INSTEAD OF IFFY WEN THEY HAVE A LOT OF VIOLENCE, CUSSING, AND SEX, IN THEM. I GIVE THIS BOOK AN ON!!!!!!!!!!!!

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you read The Clique Summer Collection: Massie?


Already read it? What do you think?

 

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors


About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age