My Brother Sam Is Dead

 Review

Common Sense Media says

Great novel about the Revolution for older kids.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Kids say

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that well-written prose conveys the excitement of growing up. Violence includes the death of a teen and the execution of an innocent main character.

  • A historical novel based on the Revolutionary War offers a realistic look at growing up during this tumultuous time in American history.
  • One soldier denigrates a slave, a Native American is not allowed in a tavern because of his race. A main character defies his father.
  • References to a beheading, a hanging, and shootings. A main character is shot at and catches fire. A teenage boy is taken prisoner and dies. Although he's innocent, a main character is condemned to die and is executed.
  • Not applicable.

What's the story?

Tim's life turns upside down when his older brother, Sam, defies their father and goes off to fight in the Revolutionary War and then his father disappears. Amid the cyclone of war, Tim helps his mother run the family tavern. Full of excitement and hard truths, this is a great historical novel about the Revolution.

 


Is it any good?

 

At a distance, war looks glorious to 10-year-old Tim, but as it intrudes on his own life, it forces him to grow up. Tim witnesses the capture of his father, and patriots falsely accuse his brother of stealing his own family's cattle -- and Tim can do nothing to help them. By the time he is 14 years old, he knows, as his mother says, that "war turns men into animals."

The realistic action that pervades this fact-based book mesmerizes kids, who enjoy this title often required for school. Young readers get a glimpse into 18th-century America and begin to understand the realities of the Revolution. The authors -- one a well-known children's writer and the other a professor of American history -- include an afterword explaining how much of the book is true and telling readers where they can go to see the Meeker tavern, which still exists, as well as other sites in the book.


Sign Up Message
Sign up for our weekly newsletter
Each week we send a customized newsletter to our parent and teen subscribers. Parents can customize their settings to receive recommendations and parent tips based on their kids’ ages. Teens receive a version just for them with the latest reviews and top picks for movies, video games, apps, music, books, and more.
Please enter an email address.
Please check your email address for possible typos.
Sorry, you must be 13 or older to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.
Sign me up!

What families can talk about

  • Families can talk about coping with danger.

  • How would you feel in Tim's shoes?

  • Have you ever been in a dangerous situation?


This review was written by Monica Wyatt
Teen, 15 years old
December 21, 2010
 
Wanted, by middle-grade students!
A quick read, pace, and hook keeps this acclaimed book glued to curious readers eyes, searching for the truth advertised in its tell-tale and revealing, title "My Brother Sam Is Dead". I give this book as a ready recommendation for teachers to give to their middle-grade students and a factual novel for historical fiction-obsessed bookworms. Told from the point of view of the Timmy, the brother of the obviously deceased, Sam, this tale gives a detailed, and sometimes harrowing, description of the bloody American Revolution in the experience of innocent eyes. The confusion of "what is the side I should be on" and the suffering inflicted upon the people, whether Patriot of Torry, is written well into the plot and ideas of the young Timmy. Teenage boys would especially find the violence realistic to their taste and appealing. To watch out for, language, infrequent but often strong; violence, occasional though a bit iffy; negative messages, the authors often give just the bad sides of the British and Patriot causes; and bad role models, Sam puts fighting before his family, even when his father is dead. A bit to keep your eye on, but I don't think it will faze the real messages of the story. This book is widely used in literature within middle schools and makes a memorable read for your young students and history-ground minds. Personally, the book was a bit too quick for my taste and I didn't like the depressing themes too much. The characters are nothing spectacular and I wouldn't recommend your kids act like a lot of them. But they will probably open up some interesting conversations about the Revolutionary War and the two sides of this war, the Americans and the British, the Patriots and the Torries, even the Torry Timmy and the Continental Sam. Be prepared for some mind-opening conversations and a new view of America's fight for independence.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
August 14, 2009
 
A must read for anyone with even the slightest interest in history
I read the book when I was nine years old, and have read it several times since. Though an American by birth, my mother is British, and I was raised to see both sides of the American Revolution, not the whitewashed version presented by most modern history textbooks and films. My Brother Sam is Dead presents a side of the American Revolution not often seen today. The Meeker Family, though Loyalists, are shown as real people having real concerns. Especially poignant is the tension between the eldest brother Sam Meeker, the rebel, and his father. Throughout the book, Tim Meeker, the protaganist, is exposed to the best and worst of both sides of the war. Any kid with even a slight interest in history should read this book. There are a couple of "naughty words" mostly just the word "hell" and the D-word, but that might concern most parents. Also a concern to parents might be the fact that there is no happy ending.

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 14 years old
July 19, 2009
 
Good Book for ages 11 and Up!
I think that this movie is a pretty good book, an is a fun read, but it does swear, and have a very violent story with an even more violent ending. I would recomend it to kids 11 and up.

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 13 years old
January 11, 2011
 
It is OK. I am in 7th grade and we are reading it in class. A couple of characters die and there is a lot of bad language(like on every other page)!

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 15 years old
May 9, 2009
 
One of the best books ever!
I would say this is one of the best books I've ever read. I would reccomend this book. It was completely sad, it talks about the Meeker family falling apart. First,Tim's father gets thrown in jail for being a loyalist and not a patriot and get's thrown on a BRITISH prison ship and DIES from cholera. Then, Tim's mom starts to drink rum. Then,Tim's best friend Jerry Sanford gets killed by the British.Lastly, Sam get's framed for stealing cattle and gets executed. Sam's shirt catches on fire wile the execution. See, the Meekers fall apart. But not all is bad Tim survives the war and moves to Pennsylvania

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 17 years old
April 9, 2008
 
wow
this book is truly amazing !rad it last year in 5th grad cryed

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 12 years old
September 14, 2011
 
Great book
I LOVE THIS BOOK! My teacher assigned this for me when I was in 5th grade but it's not for your 8 year old

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 11 year old
March 8, 2010
 
not that interesting, and not suitable for elementary children!!!
My 10 year old fifth grader was required to read it. I think the language is appalling, and that the beheading and violence and gore are completely inappropriate for a child this young. We do not use this kind of language in our home, and we do not attend media events where it is used or allow our child to do so. Why then, do we choose "newberry award winning novels" for 10 year olds (their teachers do) that slam them with this stuff? What happened to the classics?

Flag as inappropriate 
Educator
July 31, 2009
 

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 16 years old
February 21, 2009
 
This book is awesome!!!
The book is about the meeker family, who run the meeker tavern in redding, connecticut. Tim, Sam, Father, and Mother are in a time around the Revolutionary War. Sam, the oldest child, is a patriot in the war and Father doesn't like that. He doesn't even want Sam fighting in the war because of the danger. Sam fights anyway. Fast foward about five years and Sam gets executed because he was found guilty for stealing cattle, even though he didn't do it. Two cattle theives did it, but they blamed it on Sam. Sam is executed by getting shot.

Flag as inappropriate 

This review was written by Monica Wyatt
Author:James Lincoln Collier
Book type:Fiction
Genre:Historical Fiction
Publisher:Simon & Schuster
Publication date:January 1, 1974
Number of pages:216
Paperback price:$5.99
Publisher's recommended age(s):12 - 14

This review was written by Monica Wyatt
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.

Register now to save reviews and advice articles to your personal lists!


About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors

 

vote now

Will you read My Brother Sam Is Dead?


Already read it? What do you think?

 

Been There? Tell us about it