Revolution Is Not a Dinner Party (by Ying Chang Compestine)

common sense media says

Gripping story, great intro to China's Cultural Revolution.


parents & educators say

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that this novel is a fictionalized memoir of the author's own experience and a gritty portrayal of everyday life in China during Mao's Cultural Revolution, where the population was terrorized by the government, Red Guards, and lived in constant fear amid deprivation. In the novel, children and adults are beaten, bullied, and menaced, and two adults attempt suicide, one successfully.

Educational value: Readers learn what it was like growing up in China during the Cultural Revolution under strict Communist rule during the years 1972 through 1975. It's quite an eye-opener for American kids used to representative democracy, abundant products available in stores and homes, and freedom of thought, speech, and choice.
Positive messages:
Kids can survive, even in adversity, when they have strong values and the love of their family. Ling stands up to bullies, looks out for her neighbors, stays true to herself, and never gives up hope of realizing her dreams.
 
Positive role models: Young Ling (a stand-in for the author herself) shows incredible strength as she suffers bullies at school -- who taunt her for having educated parents (they are both doctors) and wearing flowery clothes deemed "bourgeois" -- and the trauma of seeing her neighbors and family members dragged out of their apartment building and arrested for alleged transgressions. Ling is smart and works hard at her studies and around the house, helping her mother. She chafes at her mother's control, like any tween (the novel covers Ling's experiences from age 9 through 12), but loves and respects her parents. He father, a surgeon, is kind, forward-thinking, and full of integrity, and secretly gives Ling English lessons in their living room, under a painting of the Golden Gate Bridge, which she dreams of seeing one day. (The author herself realized that dream and now lives with her American husband and their son in the San Francisco Bay Area.)
Violence: Several people, including children, are severely beaten; a boy is stabbed. There are two suicide attempts, one successful.
Sex: Not applicable.
Language: Not applicable.
Consumerism: Not applicable.
Drinking, drugs, & smoking: Adults smoke, one gets drunk.

More on Revolution Is Not a Dinner Party

What to talk about

Talk to your kids
  • Families can talk about the Cultural Revolution. Why was the government so harsh to its people? Why would neighbors turn each other in to be arrested? Why didn't the citizens fight back?

  • What are the main differences between communism and democracy as a system of government?

  • What do you think of Ling? Do you think you could be as strong as she is under such challenging circumstances? Can you imagine the government telling you that you have to accept a political officer moving into your home?

What's the story?

What's the story?

Ling is a child in China during the waning years of Mao's Cultural Revolution. She and her mother struggle to survive as food grows scarce and is rationed, electricity is interrupted, her doctor parents lose their jobs, and a political officer moves into their apartment, with the family getting no say in the matter. Ling's father is taken away to jail, she is targeted by bullies at school, and the family is persecuted by the Red Guards.

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 

To a Western child growing up in comfort and privilege, stories of the Chinese Cultural Revolution can be hard to understand as history. It can seem more like a tale of an insane asylum where the inmates have taken over, and the lack of sense and logic can be almost as frightening as the violence. Compestine's decision to fictionalize her memoir was a good one; it makes the history far more approachable than, say, a book such as Red Scarf Girl: A Memoir of the Cultural Revolution by Ji-li Jiang, which is more realistic but, by the same token, harder to relate to. REVOLUTION IS NOT A DINNER PARTY won many awards, including the California Book Award for Young Adult Fiction, made the 2007 Publisher's Weekly Best Children's Fiction list, and was named one of the American Library Association's Best Books for Young Adults in 2008, and was nominated for the California Young Readers Medal in 2012.

As storybook heroine Ling is very relatable. Her determined defiance of the bullies and Red Guards is admirable, exciting, and satisfying. The events of the book, carefully described so as not to be too overwhelming to the younger reader, often seem like escapades or adventures. Her growth in maturity and inner strength makes this as much a coming-of-age novel as an historical one. All of these features make it an excellent introduction for upper elementary and middle school readers to this frightening period in Chinese history.

Book themes & details

Themes
Book Details
Author: Ying Chang Compestine
Publisher: Henry Holt & Company, Inc.
Publication date: August 1, 2007
Number of pages: 248
Hardcover price: $16.95
Read Aloud: 10
Read Alone: 11

This review was written by Matt Berman
 
 

Review It

 

Review Revolution Is Not a Dinner Party





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

Most useful reviews by all members

mychemchar
teen, 16 years old
 
really great book
I usually don't like historical fiction but this was really good! It's about the Chinese cultural revolution and it's well written and easy to understand. Plus, the girl on the cover is actually the author at a young age. How cool is that?!

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you read Revolution Is Not a Dinner Party?


Already read it? What do you think?

 

About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age