The Amityville Horror (R)

Intensely violent and scary -- and a poor remake.

(Flash is loading. If this text does not disappear you need to install the latest flash version)

Common Sense rates it
1
Seen the movie? Review it
2975_orig.jpg
Movie details
  • Studio: MGM/UA, MGM/UA
  • Directed By: Andrew Douglas
  • Cast: Ryan Reynolds, Melissa George
  • Running Time: 100 minutes
  • Release Date: 04/15/2005
  • Video/DVD Release Date: 10/04/2005
  • Genre: Horror
  • MPAA Rating: R
  • MPAA Explanation: violence and terror, sexuality, language and brief drug use

Parents need to know

Parents need to know that this movie contains a first sequence where a young man shoots his sleeping family in their beds; a mild drinking scene at a restaurant; a sex scene between married couple George and Kathy (her nude back is shown); repeated scenes of George turning increasingly mean, violent, and scary-looking; his axe-attack on the family dog; and a last sequence where he chases Kathy and her three kids with a shotgun and axe. George and Kathy use strong language (repeated uses of "f--k").

Families can talk about haunted houses. How do these stories address fears of relocating, old houses, and seemingly inexplicable mass murders? How does this version reinforce the children's concern about accepting a new father and feeling disloyal to the dead father? Families might also discuss the movie's representations of troubling extended family relationships (stepfather who turns abusive and then murderous), ineffective religious agents (a priest is frightened by the house and abandons the family), and the mother's confusion at her husband's erratic behavior (afraid of him herself, she allows him to threaten her children).

Message

Social Behavior:

Consumerism:

Drugs/Alcohol/Tobacco:

Mild drinking scene.

Violence

Graphic violence.

Sex

Sex scene between a married couple.

Language

Very strong language.

Common Sense says

What's the story?

Reviewed by Cynthia Fuchs

THE AMITYVILLE HORROR begins with a prologue about the first bloody murders. Cut to one year later, when George (Ryan Reynolds) and wife Kathy (Melissa George) move in with her kids Billy (Jesse James), Michael (Jimmy Bennett), and Chelsea (Chloë Grace Moretz). As soon as they move in, menacing voices tell George to kill his family. Chelsea communes with the ghost of the dead daughter, who talks her into a dangerous rooftop climb. Complaining that the house is always cold, George moves into the basement to be near the furnace. He starts yelling at the children and punishing them excessively. George's personality changes are evident, but he returns to his old, pleasant self whenever he leaves the house. Kathy calls in a priest (Philip Baker Hall) with holy water, but he flees in fear, leaving her to cope with the demons and her raging husband.

Is it any good?

1
Though Ryan Reynolds turns in a convincingly ominous performance, edged with dark humor, this remake is erratic and intensely violent, especially against children. The updated scary effects -- stormy nights, stalker cameras, and jump-editing -- create a chilling atmosphere that surpasses the original film's notorious cheesiness.

But nonsensical plot holes overwhelm any scene-by-scene effectiveness, as the characters make frequent bad decisions (leaving the children alone in the house, or with a babysitter they don't know), and fall victim to shoddy transitions between scenes. It's also implausible (and annoying) that Kathy puts up with George’s growing viciousness at home, considering he’s as nice as can be when he’s away from the house.

Other choices

Parents and kids say

All Reviews

There are 18 reviews.

0


Posted on 02/07/08 by Angela33 Adult contributor

This movie stupid

WOW! I glad my daugter don't like this show.
0


Posted on 02/07/08 by Xela9 Kid contributor, age 9

this show sucks assballs! do not watch this show.
3


Posted on 11/24/07 by drymarc67 Adult contributor
5


Posted on 08/28/07 by sportkid98 Kid contributor, age 9

It was scary but the remakre was alot scarier.

It is basically about a family that moves into a new house. Another family was murdered in that house a few years ago. A priest comes to the house to bless it and has a bunch of flies fly on to him. The little girl has an imaginary friend that really is the one that haunts the house. There is a long sex scene but you can't actually see them. (My dad fast fowarded through that scene) I enjoyed watching my brother, and my sister, freak out and cry while me and my cousin sat on my cousin's bed and watch the boring movie. I think it is not appropriate for kids my age unless it is daytime, because all four of us got nightmares (mostly because of the scene where the mom sees those red eyes in the dark) If you're in for a scare, watch the remake.
5


Posted on 05/04/07 by dklink Kid contributor, age 12
3


Posted on 08/21/06 by mikeyski Kid contributor, age 11
5


Posted on 04/16/06 by a_rayment Adult contributor

Super scary (in a way) and VERY bloody! Excellent!

Wow! This was an excellent movie. It wasn't like other horror movies which are 100% unbelievable, this one could come true if you think about it. There is only about 6 F-Words and 10 other words which was extremely mild, and the sex scene only shows a man wearing boxers and a woman wearing underwear showing their backs for about 10 seconds (mild moaning and panting) but the violence is quite strong depending on how well your stomach takes violence. A lot of the violence is just blood splattering on the wall, but you do see a dog that was cut up by an axe plenty of times, and you see a man cut his head off (you see the knnife slice his skin) Basically 13 and up! NOT R material!
2


Posted on 04/12/06 by crazy4movies Kid contributor, age 15
0


Posted on 11/19/05 by sunshine29831 Kid contributor, age 17
0

Posted on 10/10/05 by Anonymous Adult contributor

Should Have NEVER Been Remade

This remake is absolutely HORRIBLE!!! It has maybe one or two scares and thats it, the rest made me sick to watch. Not because of gore, there is a strong lacking on that, but it just plain sucks, it is nothing like the original. I admire Ryan Reynolds & he is a great actor, but why is he wasting his time in this sorry excuse for a movie and a remake for one of the greatest horror movies of all time. Save yourself the rental fees on this one & get yourself the discounted or free rental of the original Amityville Horror. You wont be disappointed with the original, unlike this sorry remake.

See all 18 reviews >

Adult Reviews

There are 6 reviews.

0


Posted on 02/07/08 by Angela33 Adult contributor

This movie stupid

WOW! I glad my daugter don't like this show.
3


Posted on 11/24/07 by drymarc67 Adult contributor
5


Posted on 04/16/06 by a_rayment Adult contributor

Super scary (in a way) and VERY bloody! Excellent!

Wow! This was an excellent movie. It wasn't like other horror movies which are 100% unbelievable, this one could come true if you think about it. There is only about 6 F-Words and 10 other words which was extremely mild, and the sex scene only shows a man wearing boxers and a woman wearing underwear showing their backs for about 10 seconds (mild moaning and panting) but the violence is quite strong depending on how well your stomach takes violence. A lot of the violence is just blood splattering on the wall, but you do see a dog that was cut up by an axe plenty of times, and you see a man cut his head off (you see the knnife slice his skin) Basically 13 and up! NOT R material!
0

Posted on 10/10/05 by Anonymous Adult contributor

Should Have NEVER Been Remade

This remake is absolutely HORRIBLE!!! It has maybe one or two scares and thats it, the rest made me sick to watch. Not because of gore, there is a strong lacking on that, but it just plain sucks, it is nothing like the original. I admire Ryan Reynolds & he is a great actor, but why is he wasting his time in this sorry excuse for a movie and a remake for one of the greatest horror movies of all time. Save yourself the rental fees on this one & get yourself the discounted or free rental of the original Amityville Horror. You wont be disappointed with the original, unlike this sorry remake.
3


Posted on 04/18/05 by mpcorvette Adult contributor

Better than I Expected (I didn't expect much though)

This movie is not for kids. It contains a lot of disturbing images that are typical of most horror films. Overall, if you like movies in the horror genre, you might be surprised by this film. Most horror films don't scare me personally, but Ryan Reynolds does a great job of playing his part in this film. The transformation from loving caregiver to insane killer is evident as the downfall of George Lutz (Reynolds) is played out. ***/5
3


Posted on 04/16/05 by moviewatcher Adult contributor

Kids Reviews

There are 12 reviews.

0


Posted on 02/07/08 by Xela9 Kid contributor, age 9

this show sucks assballs! do not watch this show.
5


Posted on 08/28/07 by sportkid98 Kid contributor, age 9

It was scary but the remakre was alot scarier.

It is basically about a family that moves into a new house. Another family was murdered in that house a few years ago. A priest comes to the house to bless it and has a bunch of flies fly on to him. The little girl has an imaginary friend that really is the one that haunts the house. There is a long sex scene but you can't actually see them. (My dad fast fowarded through that scene) I enjoyed watching my brother, and my sister, freak out and cry while me and my cousin sat on my cousin's bed and watch the boring movie. I think it is not appropriate for kids my age unless it is daytime, because all four of us got nightmares (mostly because of the scene where the mom sees those red eyes in the dark) If you're in for a scare, watch the remake.
5


Posted on 05/04/07 by dklink Kid contributor, age 12
3


Posted on 08/21/06 by mikeyski Kid contributor, age 11
2


Posted on 04/12/06 by crazy4movies Kid contributor, age 15
0


Posted on 11/19/05 by sunshine29831 Kid contributor, age 17
3


Posted on 06/06/05 by princesspr12 Kid contributor, age 13
1


Posted on 05/28/05 by dudeman123 Kid contributor, age 13

so dumb

well,this movie wasnt scary at all darkness boogeyman and the ring were much scarier than this 1 and those were all rated pg-13.there is a sex scene but u bearly even see thier backs..and to top it all off this was probably the stupidest horror movie ever made....and that is sayin alot!!!!
4


Posted on 05/22/05 by godspuppet Kid contributor, age 15

Awesome movie...wasn't exactly scary, but well made. The movie definitely did not earn it's R rating. The sex scene showed about three seconds of a bare back, and I've heard worse language in an elementary school than it had. I guess the violence could be an issue for some people.
3

Posted on 05/19/05 by Anonymous Kid contributor, age 13

WAS SOOOOOOOOO SCARY

All the time was suspense. the hole movie was horrible violence and terrifying faces. I had to sleep that nigth with my parents and wake em up every hour because I keep thinking of the parts of the movie that shoked me.
See all 12 kids reviews >
Review It

Great Fantasy Books for Harry Potter Fans

Great Fantasy Books for Harry Potter Fans
Which fantasy book creature has the best name?
Fluffy (3-headed dog, Harry Potter)
43%
Mister Grin (giant crocodile, Peter and the Starcatchers)
29%
Vermicious Knid (shapeshifting monster, Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator)
0%
The Incredibly Deadly Viper (harmless snake, Series of Unfortunate Events)
0%
Bunnicula (vampire bunny, Bunnicula series)
29%
7 votes