Disney's A Christmas Carol (PG, 2009)

common sense media says

3-D adaptation of classic holiday tale may scare young kids.


parents & educators say
  • 85% say violence is an issue
  • 39% say there are positive messages

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that, unlike The Polar Express, this Robert Zemeckis adaptation of a classic holiday tale is too intense both visually and in content for families with very young children. At its heart, Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol is a ghost story, and not only are the many spirits very creepy at times, but the 3-D technology makes certain scenes -- as when the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come's red-eyed black stallions jump out at the audience -- all the scarier. And the realistic nature of the motion capture technology often makes the movie seem more like live action (and thus more intense) than animation. But on the other hand, the language is mild (British slang like "bugger" and "blast") and the drinking limited to Christmas toasts. And the messages are all quite positive, as Ebenezer Scrooge's (Jim Carrey) transformation is one of literature's ultimate stories of redemption and hope, even in the bleakest of times.

Educational value: The movie educates younger viewers (in a "scared straight" kind of way) on the importance of being kind and selfless, rather than greedy and selfish like Scrooge.
Positive messages: Dickens' classic tale is full of important, relevant messages: Even in economically difficult times, there is hope and happiness; money isn't the most necessary ingredient to live a happy, successful life; those lucky enough to have money should be generous toward those who are less fortunate; everyone should be kind and charitable, no matter how rich they are; and family and friendship are far more fulfilling than work.
Positive role models: Although Ebenezer Scrooge is clearly a negative role model at first, he redeems himself and becomes a positive one. By abandoning his greedy ways, he realizes the importance of generosity, selflessness, altruism, family, and the spirit of Christmas. Secondary characters like Scrooge's nephew Fred, Bob Cratchit, and Tiny Tim are all admirable for their exemplary loyalty, faith, and sincerity.
Violence & scariness: Several frightening images of skeletons, corpses, and ghosts, from the very first scene of a dead Jacob Marley lying in a coffin to an open grave in scenes from Christmas future. The ghost of Marley -- along with the three spirits of Christmas, especially the Grim Reaper-esque Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come (and his stampeding, red-eyed horses) -- can be disturbing, as can the hissing, threatening figures of Ignorance and Want. Some of the 3-D scenes are also intense and startling, and there are several sad scenes, particularly one in which a family mourns a young child.
Sexy stuff: A young Ebenezer dances and exchanges longing looks with a woman, and it's later clear that they were engaged.
Language: Some British slang like "bugger" and "blast." The words "hell" and "ass" are used, too, but not as curses. One character says "oh my God."
Consumerism: Not applicable.
Drinking, drugs, & smoking: Adults make Christmas toasts with what is presumably wine.

More on Disney's A Christmas Carol

What to talk about

Talk to your kids
  • Families can talk about the lessons that Scrooge learns. How does he change throughout the movie? What is the story trying to teach us about not just Christmas, but about human behavior in general?

  • How are the themes of A Christmas Carol still relevant more than 200 years after it was originally written? Kids: How can you act generously during the holidays and year round?

  • Do you think the 3-D technology enhances the movie, or would it have been as good/better without it?

What's the story?

What's the story?

Charles Dickens' 19th-century classic comes to life again in this 3-D adaptation, which faithfully follows the original tale. Seven Christmas Eves after the death of his business partner, Jacob Marley (voiced by Gary Oldman), miserly money lender Ebenezer Scrooge (Jim Carrey) spends the day complaining about the town's holiday cheer ("Bah, humbug!"), terrorizing his put-upon clerk Bob Cratchit (also Oldman), and refusing his nephew Fred's (Colin Firth) invitation to Christmas supper. That night, Scrooge is visited by Marley's ghost, who informs him that three spirits will appear to him to offer one last chance to change his life before it's too late. Scrooge is then summoned by the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Christmas Present, and Christmas Yet to Come (all played by Carrey), each of whom gives the crotchety old man a peek at defining moments in his life and possible future -- as well as the life of poor-but-happy Cratchit, whose crippled son Tiny Tim (Oldman again) is sickly but still filled with holiday cheer.

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 

Director Robert Zemeckis continues to perfect the motion-capture animation he revolutionized with The Polar Express, and the result is quite breathtaking in A CHRISTMAS CAROL. From the pimples on an adolescent's face to the coins on a corpse's eyes, the technology accounts for a remarkable degree of detail. The 3-D, in particular, is fantastic -- albeit occasionally frightening (a few shots may cause audiences to jump from their seats). With a rubber-faced actor like Carrey as the star, it's no wonder that the characters' expressions and gestures are so startlingly realistic. Of course, the downside to all of the realism is that the ghost scenes are actually quite frightening -- not Beowulf terrifying, but downright scary nonetheless. The spook factor is unfortunate for parents who will naturally assume that animation plus holiday classic equals cinematic fun for the whole family.

For those with harder-to-rattle clans, this is a touching and haunting adaptation of a story most of us know by heart in one form or the other. Carrey's genius at physical comedy is evident throughout the film in small moments like when Scrooge does a jig, sings along with carolers, or slides down a railing. While there aren't many huge laughs, there's enough levity to break through the otherwise somber nature of Scrooge's time-traveling, life-changing visits to Christmases past, present, and future. Oldman and Firth are, as always, fine supporting players, and Robin Wright Penn (a Beowulf alum) adds a wistful, feminine vulnerability to the only woman Scrooge ever loved. With the current economic doom and gloom, this is a well-timed holiday narrative about hope, redemption, and love.

Movie themes & details

Movie Details
Studio: Walt Disney Pictures
Director: Robert Zemeckis
Cast: Colin Firth, Gary Oldman, Jim Carrey, Robin Wright Penn
Genre: Family and Kids
Run time: 96 minutes
Theatrical release: November 6, 2009
DVD release: November 16, 2010
MPAA Rating: PG
MPAA explanation: scary sequences and images
Watch our review

This review was written by Sandie Angulo Chen
 
 

Review It

 

Review Disney's A Christmas Carol





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

What parents & educators say

9
Based on 94 parent & educator reviews:
  • 85% say violence is an issue
  • 39% say there are positive messages

Most useful reviews by all members

 
relentless disturbing and terriffying scenes. my kids ( 9 and 6) begged to leave after about 50 mins. lots of disturbing supernatural images

rohjomom
parent of and 7 , 10 , 13 year old
 
While I watched it with my three boys, I kept thinking: "This is a horror movie for children!" There were several grotesque scenes! These include: when Marley's face on the door knocker "explodes" with teeth flying everywhere, When Marley's jaw separates from his face in a horrifying way while confronting Scrooge in his bedroom, and when the Ghost of Christmas Present laughs, disintegrating into an old grey man -- and then a skeleton at the end of that scene. For what it's worth, my boys said that they liked it (6, 9 & 11).

TotalGamerMania
kid, 12 years old
 
Although the movie was good, I found it to be a little scary...
I found the movie okay, but some things in it were extremely creepy to me. It really isn't the best movie for little kids.

bigharrypotterfan8
kid, 10 years old
 
bad
I hate it so much it's an awful movie! it is a little scary in 3D.

Metropolisforever
teen, 16 years old
 
Non-Stop Terror; Atmosphere of Dread
Many parents will take their young children to see this film over the Christmas vacation. After all, it's Disney, it's Charles Dickens, and it's animated. Most people are probably expecting a light, sweet piece of fluff for the wee ones to enjoy. Those parents will be horrified once they actually start watching this joyless adaptation of Dickens' beloved novel. The film has a constant atmosphere of dread. The most frightening aspects of the original story are magnified heavily. Not only are the ghosts themselves incredibly frightening, but the overall atmosphere of the film is one of terror and dread. Children were crying in the theater; I could see an ADULT getting nightmares after seeing this. Don't get me wrong; this is no "Cannibal Holocaust" by any means, but it's still far too scary for its target audience. If your children enjoy horror films, they may enjoy this joyless, harrowing version of A Christmas Carol. Otherwise... be warned. This is NOT the Christmas Carol you grew up with.

 
Too Horrifying for Kids; Too Horrible for Adults
I am appalled; Jim Carrey, I hope you were tricked into doing this movie. I am an avid fan of Mr. Carrey's work, but this is just disastorous. It's too terrifying for children (I saw kids leave with their parents crying their eyes out) and too unfunny for adults (like myself), and still a bit creepy for some adults. PARENTS: This is incredibly scary for children and even some tweens. Beware. Also, why did they have to show those images? It's not aproppriate in a children's movie or a christmas movie, not to mention a children's CHRISTMAS movie! Well, thanks for reading - Movie Man

Red_83
adult
 
Disappointed...
Visually, this movie was outstanding. The 3D animation was some of the best we've seen to date. At times it felt as if you could feel the snow, or reach out and touch any one of the characters. So, in that, Disney succeeded. However, in what seems to be the new tradition in the remaking of classics, this one failed miserably. Unfortunately, Disney has lost the deep meaning in this movie to innuendos and downright evil thematic material. Had they rated this movie properly, I don't believe people would be outraged. But the audience was disrespected, when after months of promotion for this movie beforehand, they were deceived into thinking they were going to enjoy a lighthearted familiar story of Christmas. This was not the case. The movie is saturated with dark images that completely lose site of what the original story intended readers/viewers to walk away with – a change of heart; a new perspective that makes people want to be better people. Don’t take your young children to see this film. Stick to the classic story book or older remakes of the movie.

BaileyElizabeth
teen, 16 years old
 
Very frightening- should be rated PG-13.
I am 14, and I was scared during the whole movie. At one point I was literally shaking, and started crying. There were many pop out scenes, and scenes that were just frightening. I can't believe this wasn't PG-13 because that's what it should have been. The part that was most frightening for me was the black horses that were chasing Scroodge. Another part that was scary, was the face on the door. It jumps out with a frightening expression when you aren't expecting it. There were little kids that were crying during the movie because they were scared. Overall it was a good movie, but the whole thing was very intense and stressful. I only reccomend this for pre-teens and up. It's just too scary for little kids!

meals
teen, 14 years old
 
Miss-Rated, but good.
I am 11 years old and I saw this movie. I really enjoyed it, I thought the message was good, but there were some scenes where I had to cover my eyes. I like scary and violent, but this movie genuinely scared me. And if my seven year old sister were to see this movie, she would've been scared out of her wits. It is very miss-rated. It definitely should be PG-13. I also don't thing Scrooge is not a very good role model because he is always cranky and concerned about money and workhouses. I am so glad I did not see it in 3-D. If you are going to see this movie with your kids, you watch it first because some of the images are truly scary and disturbing.

Tracy JA
parent of 9 and 12 year old
 
Terrible movie for children!!
Absolutely the worst Disney Movie that has ever been made. Though the story and the graphics are good, this movie is not suited at all for children under 12. It should NOT have been rated PG. I HAVE A 7 and 10 year old girls that were scared to death. Both are worried about nightmares tonight. I cannot believe Disney would mis-lead the public the way they did on this one. I am beyond disappointed, Im actually mad about it. And I spent $40.00 on scaring my girls to death!! Thanks Disney. Unbelievable.

 
Definitely not for under 15, not enjoyable for those who can withstand the mature presentation
I was really disappointed in the movie. I'm used to the many other versions of this tale that really balance the dramatic hauntings with the fun of scrooge's past and the very happy ending. The movie is 96 minutes long and mostly scary and sad. The opening of the movie is Marley's death...Marley is in a casket in what looks like a garage...Scrooge takes the gold coins off his eyes to pay for the burial. The entrance of Marley as a ghost really got scary...there's a part where Marley's fabric around his head loosens and his jaw almost falls off while trying to talk and his tongue hangs out-really REALLY scary...then he talks using his hands to move his jaw. The Ghost of Christmas Past is a flaming candle with a face and he talks really scary and breathy as a ghost is usually portrayed in adult media. The flashbacks were predominately showing sad stories of scrooge's past ex: young school flashback: he was sad & alone in the school because his friend's ditched him...older school flashback: his younger sister runs in to say that Dad has invited him home again and she makes a point to imply how their Dad is changed and not abusive anymore...shortly after the ghost makes a point to say that his sweet sister died after giving birth to his nephew. Short happy flashback to Fezziwig's ball, but soon is the longer argument between he and the young woman he was romantic with that ends in their break-up. Ghost of Christmas Present seems pleasant but at the end of the sequence he has 2 demon-looking kids under his robe come out and age into adults instantly...one (Ignorance) a guy with a knife and jail bars fall on him and the other (Want) a female prostitute who nastily dances behind scrooge...the ghost then has a dramatic painful death as you watch his entire body age and decompose all the way to dust. The last ghost is really creepy and there's a long chase scene where black horses with red-glowing eyes chase scrooge. There's a scene where scrooge is hanging on as not to fall further into his grave as the casket opens and flames below. The ending/happy sequence is short and doesn't show scrooge going to the home of Cratchet, only his nephew's dinner party. The scene with cratchet doesn't include cratchet's family, only he and scrooge at the office the day after Christmas. Anyhow, a very scary adaption to me. My husband and I were scared and the kids in the theatre were crying. Too scary. The whole message of goodwill, peace, and hope is lost with the majority of depressing/sad/scary overtones the movie portrays for character building. I say, two thumbs way, way down.

julietsuz@aol.com
parent of 6 and 9 year old
 
A children's classic turned into extremely frightening movie
My children and I were looking forward to seeing this film. We love the Scrooge story, but in the first ten minutes my children were SCARED!!! Their eyes were closed a lot of the time, and even I found the images disturbing. This is definitely NOT a PG movie, and I don't know how it was rated as such. The animation is spectacular, but don't take your children unless they are unaffected by loud screaming, faces that turn into skeletons and other frightful images that are enough to give adults nightmares....

Candyvava
parent of 8 and 10 year old
 
This is the 1st time common sense media has let me down! This movie is NOT appropriate for 8 year olds. My husband and I saw it with 6 and 8 year old boys and they both were terrified. I had a knot in my stomach the whole time because it was so scary for them. We think it might be appropriate for kids ages 12 and up.

sandchild13
teen, 16 years old
 
I thought it was a bit funny. But it's not like some of the "bad" things mentioned above are really all that "bad". Dancing isn't all that sexy, and the violence and scariness....all right, I admit that might be a bit scary for my sisters (6 and 8), but they aren't going to wake up screaming. Even if I have trained them well (hehheh), it wasn't all that bad. I've seen a LOT worse in childrens movies (cough Wild Things cough). And the small wine scene won't turn them into alcoholics. I guess it just depends on your point of view. Over-protective or realistic? The line is very thin, and a bit vague, but if your child is REALLY easily scared, not taking them is realistic. If they like a good scare, or aren't easily scared, than not taking them is over-protective. Find that line and use it.

SpartyMom
parent of 8 and 8 year old
 
Definitely not for 6 year olds
I probably wouldn't have taken my kids except this was for a birthday party for a classmate. The mom didn't realize it would be so scary. My son hid his face and my daughter had to leave the theater. We did bring her back in to see the "happy" ending so she could at least see that Scrooge turned nice, etc. But this is definitely a scary movie and we only caught the regular version! Other classmates were frightened too & had bad dreams.

kbfrank
parent of 12 and 20 year old
 
Visually, the movie is impressive, but the overdoing of 3D effects and overall bombardment of sound is just too much. I'm sure teenagers, who are used to sensory overload, might like it, but I was just plain uncomfortable for a lot of it and was looking forward to it being over. I don't recommend this for young children.

TJStamper
parent of 8 and 11 year old
 
Pretty Scary!
A Christmas Carol is a bit of a scary ghost story and the movie left NO part of that out. The beginning, according to the three 7 and under kids we took, was the scariest part with the ghost of Jacob Marley (Scrooge's partner) appearing to Scrooge and warning of the 3 spirits to come. The only ghost that wasn't "that scary" was the ghost of Christmas Past. Scrooge himself is kind of creepy too! The end of the movie, of course, shows a changed Ebenezer Scrooge as he spreads cheer and goodwill to all and is welcomed into the homes and lives of those around him. If I had to do it over again, I would not take my kids to this movie. I'm worried they will all have nightmares!

chakathu
parent of 9 and 11 year old
 
Too scary for young kids. Too scary for 10 year olds.
Let me first say that I am not puritanical when it comes to movies and whether or not they are or are not too scary for my kids. I am not one of those mythical moms whose kids have never watched television. My kids eat cereal. My kids sometimes stay up like savages on non school night. I will also add that my kids are very comfortable, normally, with Disney movies and their requisite Disney villains. There's no other way to put it. I was pissed while watching this movie in the theater. Are they kidding? This is showing at El Capitan with snow machines and the whole "Holiday" celebration theme luring you in. Both my 7 year old son and my 10 year old daughter were hiding under my pashmina throughout the movie. My daughter took off her 3D glasses, hoping that it would be less scary with them off. Honestly, I couldn't believe the level of "scary" & startling in this movie. Ghosts with their jaws dropping off (and NOT in a funny "ha ha" Jim Carey way). . . really?! Do YOU think this has been related in Disney's advertising for this movie? Bait & Switch at the expense of the kids and my pocketbook. I'm just plain pissed. And my kids have already asked to sleep in my bed for awhile. Thanks Disney.

 
I liked it but I can't help thinking that other Christmas Carol movies brought out the true spirit of the story better because there was less distraction. Way to scary for the little ones!

dolphins66
parent of 6 and 10 year old
 
Great for adults and maybe 11 and up.
I was so looking forward to taking our 8 and 4 year old daughters to this movie after my husband told me about it AND after we went to see the train that came to town with previews of the film. During the preview my 4-year old was frightened by the loudness and the visuals so I checked out the movie with a friend. Unfortunately, it was even a bit frightening and disturbing for me to watch during some scenes. I knew that not only would this movie be frightening for the 4-year old but also our 8-year old. The 3D was excellent and I cannot argue that point but not really a feel good Disney film. The Polar Express is more our speed. My kids have a great imagination and can frighten themselves at night all by themselves. They don't need the help of this "Christmas Haunting". Really, this is too bad. I wonder if Walt Disney is turning in his grave. Disney is not producing the caliber of movies like their classics and it's disappointing for this parent. I will keep hoping, however, that things will change. It's more about making money now than making magical truly kid-friendly movies. Kids are too often "forced" to grow up too quickly and their innocence vanishes.

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you see Disney's A Christmas Carol?


Already seen it? What do you think?

 

About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age