The Illusionist

  • Review Date: December 21, 2010
  • PG
  • Genre: Comedy
  • 2010
 Review

Common Sense Media says

Touching, beautiful drama about the magic of friendship.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Kids say

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that although this film is animated and rated PG, it's not aimed at very young children. From the same French filmmaker who made the award-winning The Triplets of Belleville, this melancholy look at the touching, platonic friendship between an older French magician and a younger Scottish barmaid has grown-up themes that are best appreciated by adults. In several scenes, characters drink and in certain cases are drunk. A key sequence in the movie takes place in a pub. The language is limited to a "dang it"; in fact, the story is nearly wordless -- which may mean that children will have a hard time understanding it.

  • The idea that you should commit random acts of kindness for others is encouraged in the movie. Both Tatischeff and Alice are empathetic and generous, even with the little they have themselves. Tatischeff is especially selfless, working other jobs on top of his magician work in order to feed and clothe Alice.
  • Tatischeff is a kind and loving man who just wants to do his sleight-of-hand shows for as many people as possible. Even in the face of commercial failure, he never succumbs to despair, and he manages to maintain his dignity. Alice is sweet and generous, but she's also overcome with longing for material gifts, like new shoes, coats, dresses, and expensive meals.
  • There are a couple of upsetting scenes involving stage performers. In one case, a mime is kicked and shoved by schoolboy bullies. Later, he's about to commit suicide by hanging himself, but he's stopped by an act of kindness. Young children will not understand the sense of sadness that surrounds many of the characters in the movie.
  • A couple walks arm-in-arm and seems to have feelings for each other. A random couple is shown kissing in the park. A man and a woman see each other from afar, grow infatuated with each other, and end up in a romantic relationship -- hugging, holding hands, and sharing a brief kiss.
  • Most of the movie is wordless, but there's a use of "dang it."
  • Not applicable.
  • A character is shown getting drunk at a party -- he can't walk straight, bumps into things, and ends up causing a minor catastrophe at the reception. There are also valets passing out champagne. In Scotland, the magician works at a pub, where most of the patrons are in various stages of drunkenness. Adults also drink at restaurants; on one occasion, a ventriloquist is shown passing out at a table. One character is melancholy after a personal loss, and he drowns his sorrows at the pub.

What's the story?

In 1959 Paris, aging magician Tatischeff (voiced by Jean-Claude Donda) struggles to find paying gigs as audiences dwindle in favor of rock-and-roll acts. After a humiliating reception, THE ILLUSIONIST takes up a Scotsman's offer to perform at his pub in the U.K. During his stint at the small village pub, Tatischeff befriends wide-eyed young barmaid Alice (Elidh Rankin), who's so enchanted with his routine that she actually believes he has magical powers. The two travel together to Scotland's bigger cities, where they live in a rooming house full of other hard-on-their-luck performers -- mimes, acrobats, and ventriloquists. With Tatischeff having become Alice's provider (he spends his pay buying her presents), the two develop a bond that, while not explicitly romantic, is more intimate than a regular friendship. But without a suitable venue for his talents, Tatischeff could lose everything -- including Alice.


Is it any good?

 

In The Illusionist, French director Sylvain Chomet proves once again that impressive animation isn't solely the domain of Pixar. His tender tale about Tatischeff and Alice isn't going to draw in hordes of kiddies, but it will compel adults who yearn for quality storytelling and nuanced animation. Tatischeff, who's based on the real French illusionist Jacques Tati (and if you pay attention, you'll see Tati in a brief movie-theater scene), is so patient, loving, and kind that you almost hope that his May-December friendship will blossom into romance.

A Pygmalion-esque story that makes you wonder about all of the old-school performers without a stage, this is an excellent film. It's not a fast-paced Pixar dazzler or a high-stakes Miyazaki adventure, but it's fantastically depicted and so touching that it's sure to make you shed a tear (or more!) for the kind of magic that transcends age and language -- true friendship.


Sign Up Message
Sign up for our weekly newsletter
Each week we send a customized newsletter to our parent and teen subscribers. Parents can customize their settings to receive recommendations and parent tips based on their kids’ ages. Teens receive a version just for them with the latest reviews and top picks for movies, video games, apps, music, books, and more.
Please enter an email address.
Please check your email address for possible typos.
Sorry, you must be 13 or older to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.
Sign me up!

What families can talk about

  • Families can talk about what the movie is saying about modern entertainment. How has the fate of illusionists and other performers changed throughout the years? Are magicians as nonexistent as the movie suggests?

  • How does this movie compare to most of the animated films you've seen? What sets it apart from the crowd? Who do you think it's intended to appeal to?

  • Discuss the relationship between Tatischeff and Alice. What kind of relationship did they have? Were you surprised at how the movie ended?


This review was written by Sandie Angulo Chen
Parent of 8 year old
February 2, 2011
 
Quietly beautiful, be prepared if going with the under 10 crowd.
This is a very unusual but beautifully made film with many subtly heart-stopping images. Thanks to the review here I was able to prepare my 8 y/o about the lack of dialogue and the drinking. We were well prepared for its themes and melancholy mood. It held his attention throughout, which means it is a very good movie. I'm glad we saw it with one exception: I was very surprised the capsule here did not mention that one of the characters is about to hang himself but doesn't because of an encounter with Alice.

Flag as inappropriate 
Educator and Parent of 9 and 9 year old
March 13, 2011
 
My kids (9yr old twins) and I are used to seeing off-the-mainstream films at our local independent theater. However, this movie was extremely depressing and left one with no hope or faith in people. The young woman comes across as greedy. All the down-on-their-luck performers get further down-on-their-luck - to the point of ending up as a drunken homeless person nodding in an alley. The note the illusionist leaves the young woman at the end of the movie shows his ultimate bitterness. (This was the turning point that made one of my daughters burst into tears). Not a feel good movie! While the animation is lovely, the story is one of hopelessness and despair, and shows that while sometimes people can be kind to one another, it is ultimately every man for himself.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
February 16, 2011
 
Classic.
4.5/5 The Illusionist is one of a dying breed of stage entertainers. With emerging rock stars stealing his thunder in the late 1950s, he is forced to accept increasingly obscure assignments in fringe theatres, at garden parties and in bars and cafés. Then, while performing in a village pub off the west coast of Scotland, he encounters Alice, an innocent young girl, who will change his life forever. Watching his performance for the excited villagers who are celebrating the arrival of electricity on their remote island, Alice is awestruck by his show and believes his tricks are real magic. Though they don?t speak the same language, the two lonely strangers quickly bond through small kindnesses. Fascinated by The Illusionist, Alice stows away on his departing ship and follows him to Edinburgh. There, they quickly fall into a father - daughter relationship, with Alice keeping their home at a boarding house for vaudevillians, while he goes to work in a small local theatre. Enchanted by her enthusiasm for his act, The Illusionist rewards Alice with increasingly lavish gifts he has 'conjured' into existence. Desperate not to disappoint her, he cannot bring himself to reveal that magic does not exist and that he?s driving himself to ruin working all night jobs to buy her gifts. As The Illusionist grows older, Alice grows up. She falls in love with a young man and is no longer so enchanted by The Illusionist?s conjuring. She moves on with her life, and The Illusionist no longer has to pretend. Untangled from his own web of deceit, he resumes his life as a much wiser man. well this movie was something i was waiting to watch from the very beginning, when i saw its trailer, i knew exactly how this movie was gonna be not like anyother ordinary animated movie. and also it is foreign movie. and i also predicted its nomination for Oscars in the Best animated category. i saw this movie with very high hopes and very huge expectations. and it surpassed my expectations. this movie is one of the best animated movie ever made. i mean a wonderful and magnificent piece of art. this movie is very slow moving, it has very long scenes and not much actually happens in it but that is the beauty of this movie, i am so shocked and very amazed by how good the movie is and how well they made it. people will find it very boring and will not swallow or digest the movie. but if they concentrate on the beauty of the movie they will like me, fall in love with it. well i really can't talk about the acting performances because it is a animated movie. but this movie is directed by Sylvain Chomet. talking but actors remind me of their voice acting but um, wait a minute, this doesn't have voices. this is a silent movie, well not completely. you will find some isolated one word talks like thank you or hi but not full sentences or dialoges. still you can understand and feel exactly what is happening in it. i mean you can even feel what is going on in the characters mind and what they are feeling. the movie has been made in a very brilliantly masterful way, excellent direction. screenplay is well written in a very intelligent and genius way. the movie is very simple and also heartbreaking. its really emotional and depressing. i got really emotional watching it. as i said it is a silent movie but it has great sound effects and background score is so good. it is a remarkable movie, visually stunning. watercolors, amazing charming movie. such a magical experience. visuals are so good. the scenery and cities are shown in such a good way with hand drawn animations that i think are good than the real. a classic movie, classical way. brilliantly written. i loved it. MUST WATCH.

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 12 years old
April 2, 2011
 
Very good. However most kids will not like it as it is not light or fluffy. There is scene where you see a man about to commit suicide though he does not actually do it. Several charcters get VERY drunk.

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent of 6 year old
March 6, 2011
 
Magical movie
This movie is beautifully done. We took our 5 year old and talked to him beforehand about how quiet this movie would be. Very little dialogue or action scenes. It's more about the scenery and watching the characters. He liked it but got very antsy towards the end. I was impressed he sat through that much of it. I read about the hanging scene and distracted him with sour patch kids while that was going on. So glad I read the review here at CSM. I'm so thankful for movies like this. I love to take my son to the movies and it's nice to have something that's not full of shouting and screaming and cars blowing up. This would also be a great date night movie - leave the kids at home.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
September 27, 2011
 
depressing but good
Its sad i honestly could cry right know. you need to be older to understand it cuz imma kid and i don't understand it. (ignore the adult beside me) THE BUNNNNNNNY D: WAHHHHHHHHH it cant live out in the wild!!!!!!!! its a pet!!!!!

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent
August 20, 2011
 
Emotional Art-house Noir
The quality of the animation and the depiction of the characters is the real winner here. Wonderful expression and artful animation however do not help sell the spiral of despair encountered in the film. While the movie is beautifully made and the characters standout the message is a rather morbid one. Alice is enchanted or enamoured but it quickly becomes apparent she is also selfish and expectant. The clown whose life is anything but cheerful, the ventriloquist whose most treasured possession is lost and the other sorry soles are a contrast to Alice’s evolving life and disregard for her benefactor. The film is worth watching however do not expect to walk away thinking and feeling light, uplifted and secure. Your thoughts may return to the clown and the sad reality that for people we encounter in our days, life sometimes is not all fun and games...........

Flag as inappropriate 
Teen, 18 years old
November 18, 2011
 
An animated masterpiece...
Few movies touch the soul like this one. The story was compelling and in a word, heartbreaking, but also sweet. The animation was brilliant and the backgrounds were, well, brilliant. I've never seen art quite as good as this in other animated movies (well, of course, I'm exaggerating a bit, but nonetheless, it was still very well done). I would even call it a "gem" or a "masterpiece". My only complaint would be the lack of a happy ending. I literally cried. But hey, who says everything has to end happily? The movie had no dialogue (well, a little, but not that much), so younger kids may not find it entertaining, they'll probably be bored. Older children and up will probably find this movie appealing. Not a lot of violence, but one man contemplates suicide by preparing to hang himself, but is interrupted (phew). He is later seen kicked by children, while drunk on the sidewalk. One use of "dammit". A few scantily-clad women, but not too much. Some characters smoke and one guy in particular appears throughout the movie drunk, bumping into things, acting sluggish, etc. In the end, the movie was somewhat disappointing, but was still very enjoyable. The music was great. I applaud whoever made this film. I look forward to more from him in the future.

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 10 years old
September 5, 2011
 
animaition drama
great russian movie

Flag as inappropriate 
Kid, 10 years old
October 3, 2011
 
great movie
its really good,i really liked the characters but they got a bit carried away with the drinking.

Flag as inappropriate 

This review was written by Sandie Angulo Chen
Topics:magic and fantasy, friendship
Studio:Sony Pictures Classics
Director:Sylvain Chomet
Cast:Elidh Rankin, Jean-Paul Donda
Genre:Comedy
Run time:90 minutes
Theatrical release date:December 25, 2010
DVD release date:May 10, 2011
MPAA rating:PG
MPAA explanation:thematic elements and smoking

This review was written by Sandie Angulo Chen
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

 

vote now

Will you see The Illusionist?


Already seen it? What do you think?

 

Been There? Tell us about it