Wilson -- who's pitch-perfect as kooky Dwight on
The Office -- is a talented comedian, but he's not as hilariously manic (or musical) as
Jack Black, so THE ROCKER pales in comparison to
School of Rock. Singer-songwriter Geiger naturally knows how to be ADD's handsome, brooding teen frontman (he looks like a young, longer-haired
James Franco), but when he's not in musician mode, his acting feels forced. On the plus side, as Amelia, the band's beautiful-but-insecure guitarist, Emma Stone (
Superbad) proves she's ready to take her place as one of young Hollywood's talented go-to actresses.
Supporting actors like Jeff Garlin and Jane Lynch (who play Matt's parents), Applegate, and Jason Sudeikis as the band's greedy manager, lend their considerable comedic chops to their roles. The result is an amusing -- if not memorable -- musical comedy.