About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All member reviews for Sin City

 
Masterful work of art, but not for the squeamish
This is another instance in which the movie for itself is fantastic, but there is definitely a certain age range that can deal with the images projected. True to its name, Sin City is riddled with all kinds of sin as listed by Common Sense. Even when I first saw the movie as a high school student I was not prepared at all, and kind of wish I had been. I still cringe at certain scenes. Strictly speaking, I would not recommend this for anyone under the age of 18, but that might be unreasonable. Upper high school, for sure. And if your child is particularly squeamish, this might not be a movie for them ever.

Farva
adult
 
I loved this film, a great masterpiece. I have the unrated, directors cut, 2 disc DVD set preordered & I cannot wait for the sequel in summer 2006!!!

JessicaBurton1980
parent of and 5 , 9 , 10 year old
 

 
Good for mature persons common sense is overrating again!
Well this is a pretty comic action film with Film Noir inspiration. The film contains bloody violence yes but its not very sadistic and its more of a dark comedy. Just don't take it seriously and it should be fine. The sex scenes are infrequent and language is not bad either. Parents! you should watch this film before you let anyone under 15 watch it!

YBNormal
parent of 8 and 10 year old
 

SuperParent
parent of 12 and 15 year old
 
RR Rules!
we love this film, it is very stylized so the violence is very graphic and gory, there are a few boobs and a girl dancing, but this film is great if you are a comic book fan!

 
Extremely Violent, Extremely Dark, Extremely Excellent
This is a fantastic, visually-stunning masterpiece. I highly reccommend it. Parents: Although a lot of the violence is obviously fake, a lot of it isn't: heads are cut off, bodies are chewed upon, the main villains are cannibals and child molestors. More dismemberments than Saving Private Ryan. A man's genitals are blown off and at tyhe end of the film, after they've grown back, they're hideouslty ripped off. Beatings (to death), shootings,stabbings, drowings, and dumping in tar pits. but despite all of the gratuituous, over-the-top graphic and pitch-black dark tone and scenes, this is a beautiful film. It is a masterpiece, simply and mildly put. The acting is brilliant, the dialogue is stylish and entertaining, the background is indescribable, and the action is just pure awesome. I give the highest reccommendation that I can.

4Spice
adult
 
good killing action movie
i loved the movie but PARENTS LISEN UP DONT LET YOUR KIDS SEE THIS 16 AND OVER lots of blood and nudity and language if you like crazy killing movies see this one

doodle321
teen, 16 years old
 
i really don't know... if it's good for tweens
i can't really seem to fins any thing good or bad about this movie but i know i love it, really it all depends on the person. no i wouldn't let my kids whatch this lit they are about 12 but i find it to be grate. i'dd have to go with the other guy SuperParent it'd a cool comic book movie

 
I saw the film when I was 13, then again everybody's different. It is very violent and has plenty of sexual content. I guess most 13 year olds would understand the material featured, though it is a bit disturbing.

thejokerspencil
parent of and 3 , 11 , 12 , 17 year old
 
This Will Appeal to Teens
I think this is a film mid-teens should watch to get a feel for some flicks.

 
not for me
i saw it liked it but to much action for me i think for teens 16+ would be okay

Cyonnara
teen, 17 years old
 
NOT for kids but for older teens
What is wrong with the parents and educators? this movie was NOT okay for children who are 10 years old there is nothing in here that isn't R rated, don't let your younger kids watch this, wait until you know they can handle it.

Yangy
teen, 15 years old
 
Great for the fans of the comic. Obviosly overated but done well. Black and white suited the stories, and the narration was entertaining.

Mr. Boxbox
parent of 16 year old
 
e.g. You should think twice before going with a tween!
It's beautifully shot and very stylish but its also incredibly violent and over the top. Violence: Extreme raw brutal over the top Sexual Content: Very mild Language: A few s-words. Overall its an excellent film and should be ok for 15+.

FamGuy
adult
 
Great movie... for adults
Incredible images and great movie. Excellent movie to educate older teens about stylized movie making. Way too harsh for young teens.