• CSM Reviews <--
• Adult Reviews
• Kid Reviews

Common Sense Note

Parents need to know that this CD is full of sappy risk-free love songs.

Families can talk about what it means to be an idol. Ask your kids what goes into becoming a "superstar" or being "discovered." It's a common fantasy that sometimes needs a reality check. Also, many of the songs are covers of original classics -- this might be a great way for you to introduce the music you know and love to your kids.

Rate It!

Common Sense Review

Reviewed By: Common Sense Media

There's no doubt that the young contestants on American Idol are talented. There's also no doubt that these vibrant performers deserve to be working with some material that lets them express their unique personalities.

While a few of the singers breathe new life into their songs (Julia Demato's jaunty interpretation of Etta James' soulful "At Last" is refreshing, as is Trenyce's spirited take on Al Green's "Let's Stay Together"), most play it safe and stick with tried-and-true arrangements. For example, Ruben Stoddard's rendition of "Superstar" impressively showcases his velvety voice, but it doesn't allow his loveable personality to shine through. The song sounds like it could have been performed by any number of Luther Vandross wannabes instead of the huggable singer that inspired millions to vote him the second American Idol.

And unless your kids are diehard fans of the TV show, it's unlikely that they'll voluntarily sit through schmaltzy ballads and Muzak favorites such as "Open Arms," "Three Times A Lady" and "On The Wings of Love". Also, for an album of love songs, there are some odd choices. "Over the Rainbow" isn't a particularly romantic song, nor is the bonus track of "God Bless the U.S.A. (Proud to Be An American)".

Bottom line: American Idol addicts will enjoy, but there's not much for everyone else.

If your kids enjoy this CD, they might also like, American Idol: Season 4: The Showstoppers, and American Idol: Season 5: Encores.

Rate It Now

OR