Music Reviews

Music Reviews -
Small Town Girl: Navigation

Small Town Girl

Rate It!
On 10+
3 stars

Idol gets down with a good-natured country chirp.

Artist: Kellie Pickler
Genre: Country Label: BNA Entertainment Parental Advisory: No Edited Version Available: No Release Date: 10/31/2006

It's quick and easy to pass on
this great info!

Common Sense Note

Parents need to know that Kellie Pickler's lyrics are as clean-cut as she appears to be. This small-town girl delivers gentle messages of empowerment and also knows how to have a little fun. "Wild Ponies" addresses the issue of relationship abuse, and "I Wonder" expresses heartbreak over an absentee dad.

Families can talk about the ways in which Kellie uses her voice on this album. Should she stick to the kind of songs she performs well, or is it brave and cool that she tries her hand at ballads that are currently beyond her vocal and dramatic abilities?

Rate It!

Common Sense Review

Reviewed By: Kathi Kamen Goldmark

Kellie Pickler rushes out of the gate with "Red High Heels," declaring to a deadbeat boyfriend "You thought I'd wait around forever but baby get real ... I'm about to show you just how missin' me feels/in my red high heels." The strong country-rock beat and sassy tone are suited to the American Idol runner-up's perky country chirp; the track succeeds on the basis of its good-natured attitude more than anything close to brilliant songwriting or performance.

Pickler continues to charm her fans on several subsequent tracks: "One of the Guys" (though implausible based on the lovely CD insert photos) expresses longing for the simple pleasures of guy-hood with lyrics like "Something 'bout old blue jeans and a baseball cap ... chicken wings, NASCAR, and football Monday nights/Sometimes it's fun to be one of the guys." Again, the songwriting isn't brilliant, but the sum of the song's parts, along with Pickler's energetic delivery, pull it off. The one bright light in her songwriting is from "Things That Never Cross a Man's Mind" ("that joke is too dirty, this steak is too thin, that car is too fast, this beer is too cold"). It's clever and funny, and shows Pickler at her best.

Unfortunately, though, Ms. Pickler doesn't stick to material that allows her to strut her best stuff. Several cloying, overly slick ballads are several too many. "Didn't You Know How Much I Loved You" is pointless and whiny and only serves to emphasize vocal weaknesses. "Wild Ponies" delivers a poignant story about a woman's emancipation from an abusive relationship, but the lyrics are so banal and corny that the message loses potency. The same goes for "I Wonder," the most successful of the ballads, a song that addresses a girl's longing for her absentee mom. Pickler and her producers might do well to consider the fact that you don't have to hit your audience over the head to get a point across.

KPickler fans will also enjoy American Idol contestant Katharine McPhee and the CD, American Idol: Season 5: Encores. For some classic "small-town-girl" singing, check out Tammy Wynette and Loretta Lynn.

Rate It! Send to a Friend

It's quick and easy to pass on
this great info!

Content
CS adults kids

Sexual Content

Only the subtlest of innuendo.

Violence

One song addresses violence in a relationship, but not graphically.

Language

Message

 

Social Behavior

Some strong, clear, but gentle messages about caring for oursleves and one another.

 

Commercialism

 

Drug/Alcohol/Tobacco

Rate It Now

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

OR

Tell others what you think!
Write a review or post a comment.

It only takes a minute to get great benefits! Sign up now and get a FREE Internet Survival Guide!