The concerns I have selected go as follows:
-Violence – The song Mama is centered around a (pretty mentally unstable) soldier feeling guilty for what he has done in the army. The song climaxes with the line “But the s**t that I’ve done with this f**k of a gun, you would cry out your eyes all along.” This is by far the darkest line in the darkest song on this album. Also, the song Teenagers describes someone who brings a gun to school. While this song was actually written from the perspective of disdaining this behavior, it would be easy to misread the message. This is my only other big concern with this album.
-Drinking – Mentions being drunk, but not excessively. Again, the song teenagers mentions drugs, but it is meant in disdain.
-Language – As I mentioned, the line from Mama is really the worst on the album. The f-word is used once more, in the hidden track Blood, and also in the word motherf***er in the song Dead!. There might be a few more profanities scattered in there but I didn’t feel that it was a major point or theme. (Oh, and I don’t feel that Hell is a profanity.)
-Negative Messages – There are some dark themes (the album is about a man who died of cancer; that’s some pretty dark stuff.) The songs Cancer and Sleep especially deal with the intensity of this disease. However, I feel that the positives outweigh the negative messages overall. Also, the intensity of the aforementioned songs, while it can be depressing, actually helped me personally deal with my own experiences with cancer.
(Ok, 3 stars for consumerism? Really?! There was one flyer in the packaging if you buy the actual album and the coupons already expired. This does not warrant 3 stars.)
My highlights:
-Role Model – While not exactly explicit on the album, the lead singer of this band, Gerard Way, has the potential to be a great role model. He went through a very dark period dealing with drinking, drugs, and depression, but overcame it all to be the man he is today: a strong, sober, and secure adult.
-Positive Messages – I think that the positive messages present on this album can be summed up by the chorus from the final song (not including the hidden track) Famous Last Words, “I am not afraid to keep on living, I am not afraid to walk this world alone, Honey if you stay you’ll be forgiven, Nothing you can say can stop me going home.”
Overall, this is the story of a man who is looking back on his life, dealing with some of his demons, and finally coming to grips with the past. While I find this message uplifting and inspirational, some may become stuck on the dark side of some of their imagery. This is my main concern with younger, or “weaker”, listeners, especially on tracks such as Mama, Teenagers, or even The End.
This album was, and still is, monumental for me. It is still one of my favorite albums and I am certainly not suicidal, depressed, addicted to any substances, or some kind of social outcast so don’t assume that we all are. I bought this album when I was 15 but I feel that it is mostly appropriate for all of the teenage years.