I bought the album at Target the day it came out and listened through it twice. It was pretty good. After many many more listens through, I liked it much more, but it still was missing just a slight something that kept it from being as good as their previous three CDs. FOB has completely abandoned their instrumental variety and skills that were on "Evening Out With Your Girlfriend", and they lost the somewhat punk roots from "Take This to Your Grave." Their third CD which was the one to push them into mainstreamity, still at least was pop-punk without too much pop in that mix. However, with "Infinity On High", FOB has become basically pop-rock and embraced mainstream. And I HAVE to say, anyone who thinks that they were ever real punk or emo, please, go learn how wrong those statements are. They were POP-punk, and there was never any emo songs, just angst in the lyircs. If angst made songs emo, then even people like Beyonce could be called emo for some songs. If you want good punk, I agree with the person below, Anti-Flag is a very good band, as are Dropkick Murphys (though with an Irish twist). Emo bands would be more like Hawthorne Heights and the last few AFI CDs. But for a poppier outlook on rock, without being just revoltingly mainstream and pop like All-American Rejects, than "Infinity On High" is still a very good album, I am just sorry to say not quite as good as their previous three.