Find schools using Common Sense programs

Educators

Playdate Media Protocols: To Play or Not to Play

by Sandie Angulo Chen


My 4-year-old daughter is pretty princess-obsessed at the moment -- with all princesses, including the ubiquitous Disney Princesses. This usually isn't a big issue. (Although she does demand to wear a dress. Every. Single. Day.) But one of my friends doesn't allow her daughter to watch any Disney movies. I know and respect my friend's decision, and she knows that if our girls play, chances are my daughter will want to dress up and pretend she's a princess, which means Cinderella or Aurora or Ariel will likely be mentioned (although I would never put any of the movies on while she's over). If that's a deal-breaker, well, then our girls just couldn't play together anymore.

This issue -- how different families manage media for their kids -- has caused me to think more deeply about how to negotiate the rules around what kids watch, do, and play at playdates.

In my home, I've done everything from facilitate no-media, Waldorf-approved afternoons featuring silk scarves, crafts, and wooden blocks to permitting a Star Wars mini-marathon on both the Wii and DVD. My children have friends whose parents don't allow them to watch any television, much less movies, and they have friends (usually the ones with older siblings) who've seen or played movies and games that I wouldn't consider age-appropriate for my kids.

Turns out, everyone has different rules. Call me crazy, but I think media rules should be handled like allergies. Just as I'd expect a parent to tell me that their child can’t have nuts before a playdate, I expect a parent to tell me they're a "no-TV" or "no-X-Box Live" or "no-Disney" family.

Take my 14-year-old niece and soon-to-be 12-year-old nephew. Until recently, they weren't allowed to play T-rated video games -- so when we all got together for holidays, my brother's same-aged kids would shelve their T-rated collections. If my sister had kept her preference to herself, my brother's kids wouldn't have known to only bring E-rated games to our Thanksgiving or Christmas reunions.

Luckily, so far, I haven't had to deal with any serious, deal-breaking playdate situations, just a couple of awkward-but-livable "you watched what again?" moments. I've learned that the best thing is to be up front before and after the playdate.

You can’t expect another parent to be as hands-on or hands-off as you, even if they're your friends. If you're OK with video games but not unsupervised Internet surfing, say so! We're parents, not mind-readers. Otherwise, don't be overly surprised if your pre-teen comes home talking about the latest YouTube sensation: "Mom, you won't believe what Christian Bale said on the set of Terminator!"

How do you negotiate media rules with your kids’ friends? What are the gray areas, and what’s a deal-breaker?

Sandie Angulo Chen has been an entertainment writer and editor for her entire professional career and is the mother of three. Her work has appeared in Variety, Moviefone.com, EW.com, Entertainment Weekly, and InStyle. The opinions in this article reflect the views of the author and not necessarily those of Common Sense Media.

 

 

Our Community Says

How do you negotiate media rules with your kids’ friends? What are the gray areas and what’s a deal-breaker?

There are 20 community opinions on this topic

Join in on the discussion

Login or register to post comments

Selbe
Posted by Selbe on 10/26/2009 (kid contributor, age 12)

For those of you who haven't recently gone over the Disney movies, there are many innuendos and sexualized characters. An example would be in 'Aladdin' when Genie is singing his intro. He snaps his fingers and for a few seconds kids get to see some bare-bellied girls rubbing their hind-sides against our protagonist. I could also talk about 'The Little Mermaid' scandel along with 'The Lion King'. My parents don't always come right out and tell my friends parents what's not allowed, so I normally tell my friends that and we do something else instead.

Posted by csmonfire on 10/7/2009 (teen contributor, age 13)

Why dont you allow disney?

Posted by lilmissfrankie on 09/9/2009 (kid contributor, age 10)

your friend im srry but she is acting ridicoulus why doesnt she let her kids watch disney movies is she mad at the company or sumthin gimme a break i know yr not gonna listen to my opinion bcuz im 10 and of course alot of parents DONT but im still gonna post

Posted by csmonfire on 08/17/2009 (teen contributor, age 13)

ERROR CODE 405: UNRELATED TOPIC

What they're trying to cover:

Playdate media protocols

What they're covering instead:

Negotiating media rules with your kid's friend

Another reason why CSM lacks common sense, from Be the Otter, an Anti-CSM agency.

Posted by saracarrol on 08/8/2009 (adult contributor)

I also personally prefer and encourage children to play outside rather than watching cartoon on TV or playing games over computer. Playing games develop children mental and physical ability. But unfortunately most of the children of this generation pass hours after hours by sitting before the stupid box. But I think not allowing watching TV strictly may make the kids more curious and interested, so it’s better to divert their mind subconsciously.
Dogs

Posted by shmulik98 on 07/2/2009 (kid contributor, age 11)

IDK

Posted by Kamil Jain on 06/1/2009 (parent contributor)

Try this cooking games, young kids would really love it because the graphics are rather appealing for young children and its basically fun to play.

http://www.dressup247.com/category/Cooking/1.html

Posted by theidiotspot on 05/27/2009 (adult contributor)

I limit my child's viewing by making sure she doesn't see any Adult Films or any movies rated "R". No, just kidding. Disney is a big "no-no" in our house, but if she goes out to another home, it's ok. T.V. is like sugar, it's addictive but it's all junk, so we try to temper the junk as much as possible and get in a lot of reading. But no video games. T.V. and computers and such should only be used to promote our involvement as citizens and for education. Good luck.

Posted by Geralyn Bywater McLaughlin on 06/26/2009 (adult contributor)

It is a great question, and one that many parents are asking these days. In fact, I just answered a similar question on my blog. Check it out at http://www.empoweredbyplay.org/
My goal is to help parents and teachers protect imaginitve play.

Posted by dilavida on 05/25/2009 (parent contributor)

I have a daughter who is a young teen and a son who is a tween, so they don't do "playdates" anymore and to be honest, when they were younger, I rarely let them go to anyone's house that I didn't know pretty well. I preferred to have their friends come to our house.

I agree with several of the other comments that when they had friends over, I expected them to play, not watch TV or movies. Since I did limit their TV and movie watching a bit when they were younger, they tended to playact with their friends, play games, or even ask us to act out stories with them. One time I remember they all spent a long time drawing several pictures and then created an art gallery/museum and my husband and I had to view the paintings and drawings at the museum. I miss those days. :-)

Now if they have a friend or two over, they will opt to get out the camcorder and film movies, or they write their own books or screenplays (I might have a budding Steven Spielberg or Tina Fey in my midst). I'm not going to say that they don't get out the Wii or the computer with their friends, but they also do other things as well.

All this to say, I never worried too much when they were at my house and if they did go to a friends's house, I just mentioned to the parents that my kids didn't watch PG movies (or PG 13 when they were a little bit older). Later on, I had to add comments about video games as well.

When my daughter has had sleepovers, I always let the parents know what movie they would be watching that evening and I made sure it was okay with all the parents. (yes, for a sleepover you definitely need a movie).

I guess now I just make sure there're no R rated movies at their friends' houses. it's not a problem with my daughter because she doesn't care to see any R rated movies, but my son is another story.

I know that pretty soon I will have to talk to other parents and find out if there will be adult supervision and if there will be any alchohol at the other home. That's why I still would rather have everyone come to my house.

Posted by Nash_mami on 05/24/2009 (adult contributor)

I think it's easy for us to assume that other parents are going to have similar ideas to ours as to what type/ length of media viewing is acceptable. However, we all know what happens when you assume... It would be helpful if the parents of your child's play date would inform you if they have any specific objections to certain types of media, but just in case, it might be best to take the initiative and ask up front in order to avoid any unintended offense. If you and the other parents can't seem to come to a reasonable compromise, then maybe the next play date should be at the park!

Posted by Wife and Mommy on 05/24/2009 (adult contributor)

You know, it's not something I've ever thought about, nor have had to deal with. The kids my children play with all have parents who have the same media rules...I've been lucky like that! I certainly think it's something I will have to deal with as my children get older and develop friendships with kids and families I don't know as well.

Posted by luckyday on 05/24/2009 (parent contributor)

My son spends Monday - Friday at pre-school, so the weekends are family time. Not many "playdates" here. The only play dates he has had are with his cousin. I do expect them to PLAY when they are together and not watch TV. This summer he will be attending some playdates with school friends, so I will have to address that with the other parents. :)

Posted by jddaddy on 05/24/2009 (adult contributor)

I think parents trust that other parents with similar educational and class backgrounds will have similar tastes and rules when it comes to exposing children to media. I think this is one reason that parents tend to socialize with other parents with similar backgrounds. I'm not trying to say that a certain class of parent is more judicious than another -- but let's admit that entertainment products can be clearly divided by the class of their consumers.

Posted by Rob79 on 05/23/2009 (parent contributor)

I'm pretty middle-of-the-road on permissiveness with my 10 year old daughter. We own no video game players, I preview or research movies, music and TV shows first, and allow only limited computer access. We still have a no-screen-time-during-playdates rule at our house, so other people don't have to worry about what their kids see here. I'm well aware that she sometimes watches things or plays games at other people's houses. I haven't let her go over to people's houses where I don't know them at least fairly well and I trust her instincts and honesty (so far!) about what she does there. So far, I've been restrictive about whose house she goes to more because of fear of unlocked guns than video exposure!

Posted by lachpach on 05/23/2009 (adult contributor)

Thanks for this. I have never even thought about the option of saying something before hand, although I feel really stupid admitting that. I am leary of my kids going over and playing with people anyway because we have sticter standards than most around us.
Our kids at 4 and 2 don't do computer at all and are allowed only very few movie series (VeggieTales or Signing Times).

Posted by bre_sarah on 05/22/2009 (adult contributor)

We're more restrictive about media consumption than most of our 4 year old's friends are, but so far it hasn't been much of an issue during playdates (she's only done drop off playdates with a few friends whose parents I know very well). She didn't watch any TV or movies until age 3, and then it was very sporadic, like one 30 minute show a week or a movie when she was sick until 4 months ago. Then we started having a weekly video night, but we've been picking the videos and we don't do the Disney princess stuff.

My policy at this age is no screen time during a playdate at our house- they get together to play not to sit and watch TV together. And sharing a laptop to play on literactive or something just doesn't work that well with 4 year olds! Her friends parents seem to have the same policies, and they all know we limit her media consumption. As she gets older and has dates with friends we don't know so well, I think we'll just need to be upfront about it like you describe.

fatherof2
Posted by fatherof2 on 05/22/2009 (parent contributor)

I have rules for playdates but I'm flexible about it. When friends come over, I spare them a bit more fun with WII and movies, dressing up, make-up whatever they want as long it is appropriate (i.e.movies and games out of age range is a no-no). When they are at their friends' houses, I assume the rules are there so they have to comply with their house rules. It's one way for my kids to learn how others live, behave. This is a good way to learn about accepting what is different and what tolerance is... one step away from learning and accepting other culture and language difference. So if this parent doesn't allow Disney (which my kids love) there are other ways to be entertained and kids always come up with fun ways of doing it. But it's up to the kids to determine if they want to come back or not (I'm bored, no Disney). Chances are, friends just being together will be more entertaining than the platform the fun is based on.

gothqueen CC
Posted by gothqueen CC on 05/21/2009 (teen contributor, age 15)

How can you not watch disney movies?! I was like raised on them

Give Us a Minute, Get a Lot of Common Sense!
  • Age-appropriate best bets for your kids
  • Weekly email alert with the latest picks, reviews & advice
  • Post your own reviews and share them with friends

This will never be displayed to others.
Your email will never be displayed to others.
Your password should be 6-10 characters long.
A screen name protects your privacy
To post a review or comment you must become a Common Sense Member. It's easy!

Set-up your account
This will never be displayed to others.
Your email will never be displayed to others.
Your password should be 6-10 characters long.

Choose a screen name
It will appear when you post your own reviews and recommendations.
A screen name protects your privacy

Tell us your children's ages
You'll see the movies, games, books, shows, music, and sites our editors select just for them. As your children get older, our picks will grow with them!Why we ask for this
We never display your children's names, (or nicknames) to anyone, but you. Providing your children's ages allows us to personalize information on our site, so you get better information, faster.
is
until
(optional)
is
until
is
until
is
until
is
until
is
until
Add another child

We can make Common Sense just right for you. With a little info about you and your family, you'll get the most out of our site.

Set-up your account
This will never be displayed to others.
Your email will never be displayed to others.
Your password should be 6-10 characters long.

Tell us your children's ages
You'll see the movies, games, books, shows, music, and sites our editors select just for them. As your children get older, our picks will grow with them!
Why we ask for this
We never display your children's names, (or nicknames) to anyone, but you. Providing your children's ages allows us to personalize information on our site, so you get better information, faster.
is
until
is
until
is
until
is
until
is
until
is
until
Add another child

Choose a screen name
It will appear when you post your own reviews and recommendations
A screen name protects your privacy
Register to add this school to your profile. You'll be able to see and share reviews from parents, teachers, and kids at your child's school.
I'm already a Common Sense member.
Kids under 13 must use a screen name