Common Sense Note
Parents should know that the show includes some fairly strong language (the worst is bleeped out) and obvious commercialism. But sexual content is limited to flirting and kissing, and Ashlee's age (she's 19) and the consistent presence of her parents means virtually no drugs or alcohol.
Families can discuss Ashlee's non-realistic reality. Here's someone who was raised by parent-managers who have brought their daughters to the center stage at a young age. How realistic is having a camera running throughout the day, filming everyone in the family? How can Ashlee cope with her sister's fame and her own image issues? What happens if she fails?
Common Sense Review
Reviewed By: Joly Herman
You have to give Ashlee Simpson some credit. Even though she is trapped in a shallow showbiz world, she manages to stick to her guns on things she finds important. She wants to be in control of her image, and she fights for her right to carve her own niche. Symbolically, she dyes her hair brown to differentiate herself more from her sister and Britney Spears. She is also a very creative young woman. Her songs seem to come from a part of herself that has some depth -- in this way she is more than a product of the media machine; she is an artist.
On the other hand, so many minutes of this show are wasted watching Ashlee do inane things like drive places in her car. We see her get lost and avoid numerous accidents. We watch her riding in the elevator; we watch her eating junk food and watch her have stupid conversations. The episodes that concentrate on her artistic process are more exciting than the ones that show how unprepared for real life she actually is. "I've never washed lettuce before," she tells a friend while they prepare tacos one night. "I've never mopped the floor."
Hang on -- she's nineteen! Who's been doing all of this for her? Her mother and father step in all of the time with the patience of saints, teaching her little quiet lessons about housekeeping and everyday nuances, but where were they before they set her loose in her own apartment? These gaps in reality make this reality show interesting, at least from a psychological standpoint. In the end, Ashlee Simpson does what most artists do -- she makes art out of what she's been given. In this case, what she's been given is a license to drive in the superficial world of pop semi-stardom.
Better celebreality shows for teens include Hogan Knows Best and Run's House.
Rate It!
| Content | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CS | adults | kids | ||
Sexual ContentFlirting, kissing, shaking her booty -- but Ashlee is more interested in being cuddled than anything. |
 |
|
|
|
Violence |
|
|
|
|
LanguageThe trailer for the show has her saying the f-word three times. Bleeped out but obvious. |
 |
 |
|
|
Message |
|
|
|
|
Social BehaviorMixed messages about body image, but Ashlee wants to be her own person. She is independent and dependent at the same time. |
 |
 |
|
|
CommercialismYou know she drives a Lexus, because she's in it for half of the show. Though Ashlee earns her own money, it feels as though it falls out of the sky. |
|
|
|
|
Drug/Alcohol/TobaccoNone. She's nineteen and her parents are almost always around. |
|
|
|
|
