The 4Kids English dub (CW program) is a complete joke
This is a review of the Original Japanese anime, Yu-Gi-Oh! 5D's. The English version dub doesn't deserve to be called an anime. The English version takes this series and cuts it in half. The series is originally a dark series. The story's protagonist is Yusei Fudo. He is a young, 18-year-old orphan who has no parents and lives with his friends in an underground hideout. His only hope is his D-Wheel and his ace monster, Stardust Dragon. His once-best friend, King of Duelists Jack Atlus, abandoned the life of a poor Satellite resident and his friends for a chance to become king two years prior to the beginning of the series. The story is about Yusei rising from the bottom of the social class and regaining his friend back. The series is much darker than its international counterpart. The English dub turns it into a Saturday morning cartoon. In its unedited form, Yu-Gi-Oh! 5D's would easily be placed in late Adult Swim-esque airing blocks. This misleads a lot of kids and parents into thinking that it is nothing worth quality. That is not the case. Many things which made this series great in Japan was removed from the dub. This series is targeted at late teens in Japan and is comparible to similar series such as Code Geass and Death Note. Before judging this series to be a kid's cartoon after watching the American ripoff, watch the Japanese version and I guarantee that one to two episodes is enough to change your mind.
I've watched all the series of Yugioh, to the original, to the GX, and now, to the 5Ds. I have to say, 5Ds are the most exciting up to date. Unlike the previous where they stood and battled, the motorcycle theme has added an extra dramatic "punch" to the series. The series is more intense, I believe, and geared toward the older viewers of the Yugioh fans. There is still a lot of the "friendship" theme going on, but there is also blood, violence, and romance in it as well (as far as I have seen in the Japanese version), and more intense than the previous Yugioh series. Although...if you don't like Yugioh in the first place, I wouldn't recommend it, but if you are a Yugioh fan, then I definitely do recommend it, and don't let the motorcycle fool you because they are actually really fascinating.
I'm talking about the English dub since I haven't seen anyone writing their review in Japanese. As a fan of the original Yu-gi-oh!, I was always confused at what there was not to like about it and/or it's associated game. The game promotes critical thinking in a variety of ways including (depending on the speed of the game) quick mathematical calculations, deductive reasoning, etc., as well as "outside of the box" thinking. Plus it's better that your child learns a game where rules need to be adhered to instead of out on the streets acting like deliquents, but I digress.
The show is indeed in fact darker and more complex than its' predecessors, the main hero has not had the best life and is not put in the best of situations but what is admirable is that he keeps to his convictions which are positive ones like standing by his friends and trying to save people. This show is a bit more realistic than the previous two series in that when I say it's more "darker and complex" I mean that it's more closer to reality than most people would like to admit as there are societal issues, connotationally ethnical issues, betrayal, etc. that has a bearing on the story rather than just clear cut black and white, good versus bad kind of plot.
My overall recommendation is that this show is a good one for teenagers. Now does this mean every teenager should watch it? No, but what it does mean is that if your child is going to watch it, then I would suggest talking to him/her about what they have seen and hear out their interpretation of things.
I play yu gi oh cards with friends at school and home. I love it. I watch yu gi oh on my birthday july 12,1989. I buy yu gi oh cake from publix so we can eat it.
I've watched the entire series (By that I mean the Japanese edition, the English edition is terribly dubbed). There are a couple of violent parts I could recall in the 1st season such as one of the character's arm being put into a container full of medicinal fluids (in the Japanese edition of course, the English one shouldn't be a problem). In the 2nd season (though I doubt this will be shown in the English dub), there are some horrific scenes of the fate of the city the main characters are living in (Some spoilers here), it turns out mankind is at war with robotic beings, and this isn't a cartoonish war, this is guns and people dying and other whatnot (I have NO IDEA how they're gonna dub this because the 2nd season revolves around this story). The 2nd season revolves around War and "Despair" of the survivors of the future war. With the English dubbed version, it would be suitable for kids (not too young though, you don't want them to be addicted to a card game that becomes a bit too complicated). However, as they watch the English dub, it's likely that new episodes will be released very slowly so they would attempt to watch the Japanese dub on the computer with Subtitles. Basically, I would recommend this show to the older viewing audience (at least 12+). If your child does not have access to internet, I would recommend it to be (8+).
As for my own personal review of this series, I may be a bit old to be watching stuff like Yu Gi Oh, however this is series I've definitely loved. Some lines are a bit cheesy but this show ultimately kept my childhood alive, the only problem is that it's over.
My Ratings:
Creativity - 4/5
Characters - 4.5/5
Story - 5/5
Production - 3.5/5
Lasting Appeal - 5/5
I've watched every episode of this series, although it leaves me wanting more, this is definitely one series I will never forget.