Whirligig (by Paul Fleischman)

common sense media says

A car crash ends one life and begins another.


parents & educators say
  • 50% say there are positive messages
  • 33% say there are positive role models

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that even without much action, this beautifully thoughtful book is enthralling to many young adults. It's a powerful, complex tale of guilt and redemption that may inspires in kids a desire to create their own whirligigs, and to explore the country. Parents need to revolve around the main character's attempt to kill himself while driving drunk, which results in the death of another person.

Positive messages: A powerful, complex tale of
guilt and redemption that may inspire in kids a desire to create their
own whirligigs, and to explore the country.
Positive role models: The main character's attempt to kill himself while driving drunk results in the death of another person.
Violence: Brent deliberately causes a car crash, in an attempted suicide.
Sex: Brent pursues a girl and is humiliated.
Language: Once, mild.
Consumerism: Not applicable.
Drinking, drugs, & smoking: Underage drinking and driving.

More on Whirligig

What to talk about

Talk to your kids
  • Families can talk about consequences. When Brent is first sentenced, does his punishment seem serious or does he seem to get off easy?
  • Can you think of something you've done impulsively that had unintended consequences affecting someone else?
  • Families can also talk about teen depression. Have you or anyone you know ever felt like Brent at the beginning of the story?
  • How could his humiliation at the party been avoided?
  • What do you think would have happened if he hadn't gone on to cause the accident?

What's the story?

What's the story?
Brent begins his second life the night he kills a girl.

Desperately chasing junior-class popularity, Brent gets drunk at a party and is humiliated in front of all his classmates. Driving home in a fog he decides to commit suicide by driving into oncoming traffic. But the ensuing accident kills a girl in the other car instead.

As a form of restitution, the girl's mother asks that Brent travel to the four corners of the United States--Maine, Washington, California, and Florida--to build and set up whirligigs that display her daughter's face. So Brent sets off to travel the country with a bus pass and a bag of tools.

In alternating chapters, Fleischman tells of Brent's odyssey of guilt and self-discovery, and of the surprising effects his creations have on others, often years later.

Is it any good?

Is it any good?
 

Paul Fleischman has long been a solid children's author, but WHIRLIGIG is a tour-de-force. Breathtakingly powerful and vividly memorable, it is also multilayered. As Brent travels alone and struggles to come to terms with what he has done, his personality, priorities, direction, and indeed nearly everything about him is irrevocably changed, mostly for the better. The appalling consequences of his self-centeredness, and the rippling impact of his actions causes readers to look at their own lives in a new way.

The format can be confusing; the chapters showing the effects of the whirligigs don't follow the same order as Brent's creation of them, so the reader is often unsure which whirligig is involved. But eventually it doesn't seem to matter; the point is the unexpected consequences of our actions. This is the kind of book that latches onto readers and doesn't let go. More than a few readers have been driven to seek out books on the making of whirligigs, which the author makes fascinating and lovely.

Book themes & details

Book Details
Author: Paul Fleischman
Publisher: Henry Holt & Company, Inc.
Publication date: January 1, 1998
Number of pages: 133
Hardcover price: $16.95

This review was written by Matt Berman
 
 

Review It

 

Review Whirligig





Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.
 

What parents & educators say

12
Based on 6 parent & educator reviews:
  • 50% say there are positive messages
  • 33% say there are positive role models
  • 33% say there's too much drinking, drugs, or smoking

Most useful reviews by all members

 
this book was the worst book ive ever read it was stupid not intresting. the chapters were a bit confusing jumping from a differnt person then back to the main chater. the book didnt talk about the person who died that mush to feel like that brent did somthing bad. the charters in the book werent insting atall they didnt want you to know more about them and when you start reading it you wonder about other things that they talked only for a second then jump to something else that they never talked about and then jump to something else.

MUACKS2uALL
teen, 15 years old
 
Whirligig
Sorry, no offense to the author, but I'm a 9th grader and we just had to read this book and...well....no one liked it. It's annoying because at the beginning this guy is completely overly dramatic and sensitive. Everyone knows high school isn't going to be perfect, especially for new kids. But because a girl embarrassed him he decides to kill himself? Sorry but that's beyond stupid.Then some wooden toys are supposed to influence people and their life choices? Really? If I saw a toy in the park, I'd think, "cool," and then forget about it forever. The book doesn't have much going for it anyway. You can tell that the author is probably good because of his writing style, but the book is awful! If I hadn't been forced to read it I would have returned it before the 2nd day, if I checked it out in the 1st place. Do yourself a favor, and don't read it unless you have to. If you are in high school, middle school, etc, then u have enough drama in your life and shouldn't have to put yourself through a story of a random guy's self-destructive course and his guilt from murder and etc.

fireman369
teen, 14 years old
 
I wonder....
My classroom plan's on reading this book but am hearing some bad things and some good things about it am going to come back and see if this is a good book.

14liz14
teen, 15 years old
 
not interesting
There no interesting plot line. my English class was force to read it, and no one liked it. it was too boring. dont waste your time looking for the book.

razzle98
parent of 13 year old
 
A Stupid Waste of My Precious Summer
This book was stupid. I had to read it for school... I read this kind of stuff when I was like, 8. This is not on my reading level at all, it was confusing because the chapters jumped around too much and it was just stupid! I spent part of my precious summer on this! I will never get that time back! I hated this book so much that when I opened the stupid thing, I cried because of how much I hated it, I'm totally serious! Seriously, don't waste your time on this book unless you want to torture yourself!

Vera Slater
teen, 15 years old
 
better for older kids. Stronger themes may not be appropriate for younger children
Whirligig is a beautiful story of redemption. A boy searching for himself and forgiveness travels across the country to build whirligigs for a young woman he accidentally killed. We see the affects the whirligigs have on him, but also the affect it has on four the lives of others in the four states.

adkesalyn
teen, 16 years old
 
During his journey Brent learns and begins to build an entire new life. Although this book is not very exciting, it's great for readers who like slow and thoughtful stories :)

Mysterious_bal ...
teen, 17 years old
 
ehh.....
Ok this book is ok we read it in class and it was boring everyone fell asleep, except in like the third chapter when these two teenage girls are talking and the one is trying to encourge the other by telling her her future in which she has a fulller figure and find a man who is sick from hypothermia (sorry if thats spelled wrong) and to save him she presses her body to his....that was an akward moment in my class funny since my teaacher said "there not doing anything....yet" lol :) I'd say teaches kids not to drink or you may kill somone and have to travel the counrty buliding things.

bobbay
teen, 16 years old
 
itas okay for a 10 year old
this boook was stupid it was waste of my time, minutes of my life i will never get back life is to short to waste on this book the author should be ashamed of what they put me through

 
Great book for reluctant readers
It is a warm, coming of age tale of taking responsibility, forgiveness, grace, and redemption.

smileybear
teen, 15 years old
 
i had to read this book for honors english and i couldn't put the book down. i would not let my little sister read it, good book for older kids.

 
Whirligig
This was a very good book.

ducttape98
teen, 15 years old
 
Don't Waste Your time
Whirligig is an interesting book as far as plot. It's a required reading book for me, so I was forced to push my way through this. All of my classmates agree on one thing: it is dreadfully boring. The writer could have done so much more detail with the unique storyline. If it had been more extensive I would have reconsidered.

hannah111
teen, 16 years old
 
Whirligig. (:
Hi, i'm 15 going into freshman year in abut two weeks and all the freshmans had to read this book over the summer so i started right away just to get it over with, it was going fine at first then I got really confused because I thought the book was going to be about brent and the two girls in chapter two then chapter four came and isn't wasn't about the girls and I got so confused. so I guess i'm just saying that you really have to pay attention and follow along and if your reading it for school like I had to I would take notes about the setting, characters, problem/conflict and how it was solved, and the theme/ message of each chapter so you won't get as confused as I did. Overall it is a good book, just hard to understand in some parts. I would not have even thought about reading it if it wasn't for class but anyone who is looking for a book with a strong message it is the perfect book. goodluck. (:

 
Worst book ever. Only for bookworms
THIS IS THE WORST BOOK EVER. IT SKIPS OVER BACK AND FORTH. AND PAUL FLEISHMAN GETS GOOD REVIEWS? IF YOU READ IT IN 7TH GRADE, IT IS SO DUMB. JUST READ IT......

 

kitty96
teen, 15 years old
 
It a grate book and i am 14 and i loved it!!!
I just trun 14 and i think that whirlilgig is a grate book now i am doing a big projet on it and i think it going to turn out grate i recommend for you to read it.

BOOKlover SMILES
teen, 15 years old
 
Very Inspiring.
A great book that will inspire many.

cyurkoski
teen, 15 years old
 
awesome lesson-teaching for teens and adults!
This is a wonderful book to have your teenage kids read! its very educational and teaches an important lesson about drinking and driving, and also responsibility and mitureity.

dallas_renea
teen, 17 years old
 
good book, bad ending.
kay, i really liked this book, my teacher even made us do a report on it (i got an A.) the ending on the other hand was absolutely terrible. i hate the ending. it preety much just left ya hangin. which really just sucked. i think this book would be apropriate for some 13 year olds and up, it was a adult book with some adult words (not cus words) just i think an adult would get it better, but what can i say im 14 and i got it perfectly.

An independent voice for families
Age-appropriate reviews
 

vote now

Will you read Whirligig?


Already read it? What do you think?

 

About our rating system
ON: Content is appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child, some content may not be right for some kids
OFF: Not age appropriate for kids this age