About our rating system
ON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
PAUSE: Know your child; some content may not be right for some kids.
OFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
Learning ratings
BEST: Really engaging, great learning approach.
GOOD: Pretty engaging, good learning approach.
FAIR: Somewhat engaging, OK learning approach.
NOT FOR LEARNING: Not recommended for learning.

A safe community is important to us.
Please observe our guidelines.

All parent reviews for Wintergirls

Age
13
Average rating based on 5 parent reviews:
  • 80% say there are positive messages
  • 60% say it's educational
  • 40% say violence is an issue
  • 40% say there are positive role models
Parent of 10 and 13 year old
February 20, 2011
 
I just finished reading this book that my 12 year old daughter brought home from her school library. I find it unsettling that this book is accessible for her age range. Although the book describes the life of an ill/anorexic 18 year old, I think it also plants ideas into kids. Cutting, laxatives, how to count calories obsessively, lie, deceive, self destruct and down right kill yourself. My daughter is impressionable and having a book like this on her library bookshelf is scary. I don't need these issues shoved down her throat. I strongly urge parents to read the books their kids bring home. The messages in them are not only thought provoking but thought providing and could actually lead more kids down this path. I did not appreciate the author using homosexuality comments either. I believe there is a place for books such as these, but not for our young impressionable tweens and teens.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
June 24, 2010
 
pretty graphic...
I thought it was a very well-written book, but it was very graphic in describing the girl's eating disorders and other things.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
January 15, 2011
 
good for teens but not for youg=nger kids
This is a really great books. But its a little to dicriptive for its own good. But it was awsome.

Flag as inappropriate 
Adult
August 15, 2011
 
One of the best books!
Despite Lia's struggle of becoming healthy- she does over come her illness and succeeds so I think it is a really positive message! But I don't think this book is appropriate for anyone under 12... It does have a few minor swears and a few things that could give someone a queasy stomach! Overall: It is an amazing book!

Flag as inappropriate 
Parent
March 4, 2012
 
Great Book and Discussion Starter For Teens
This is a great book that can lead to great conversations with teens about things that matter. Some things that may be iffy are the detailed description of self harm, and dealing with an eating disorder and mental illness

Flag as inappropriate