Shine

  • Review Date: January 27, 2011
  • PG-13
  • Genre: Drama
  • 1996
 Review

Common Sense Media says

Intense, gripping mental illness music drama.
greenON: Content is age-appropriate for kids this age.
yellowPAUSE: Know your child; some content
may not be right for some kids.
redOFF: Not age-appropriate for kids this age.
not for kidsNOT FOR KIDS: Not appropriate for kids any age.

Find out more

Quality
 
Sometimes media can be age appropriate but a real waste of time. Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

Parents say

Not yet rated

Kids say

Not yet rated

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that this award-winning drama depicts a mentally ill lead character who, as his dementia descends, behaves inappropriately with the opposite sex (groping womens' breasts impulsively) and sometimes goes out partially naked in public. In a discreetly shot scene he deliberately fouls a bathtub with human waste (inspring the script's lone swear word: "s--t"). There is frequent smoking and some drinking (and a glimpse of nearly nude go-go dancers in a London nite club).

  • Humanization of the mentally ill is the primary theme, as the script makes fully dimensional a guy who would just be dismissed by bystanders as a crazy street person. Secondary theme about toxic fatherhood and stage-parents gone bad.
  • David is a hugely talented and sincere guy despite his eccentricities. His father is driven, mean, troubled, and sometimes abusive.
  • Parental abuse is mostly psychological, but some slapping in one scene. David undergoes electro-shock therapy, non-explicitly.
  • A bare breast as David and his newlywed bride make love after the wedding. Topless dancers (with nipple pasties) in the background of a party scene. Bare-butt shots of David. The hero has a habit of impulsively groping ladies' chests.

What's the story?

We first see the adult David Helfgott (Geoffrey Rush) as a rumpled schizophrenic, living semi-assisted in a boardinghouse in modern Australia, compulsively mumbling in stream-of-consciousness fashion. Flashbacks show he's the music-prodigy son Peter Helfgott (Armin Mueller-Stahl), a Polish Jew who lost his family in the Holocaust, left coldly possessive and distrustful regarding his star son. Peter can be a nice dad to his other, less talented children, but to young David (Noah Taylor) he's a demanding tyrant, driving the boy to win high-profile piano competitions and master a notoriously difficult Rachmaninoff concerto. David disobeys his father to accept a music scholarship in faraway London, getting himself forever banished from the Helfgott household. Even away from his father David's social isolation and instability worsens, and he suffers a mental breakdown. Returning to Australia, David is in and out of mental institutions, but when he proves his virtuoso piano-playing prowess in a bar one night he gets a gig as a saloon entertainer. Marrying a warm-hearted astrologer (Lynn Redgrave), David ultimately returns to the concert stage.


Is it any good?

 

Anchored by terrific performances, especially the award-winning star turn by Rush, SHINE is not just a clinical lab-coat study of a true case of mental illness, therapy, and treatments than a positive affirmation that even "crazy street people" possess humanity, emotions, and intricate family histories beyond the surface pathologies. Even a certain lack of third-act complications -- David seems to ease from the margins back into the mainstream with the incredibly patient assistance of nurturing ladies, restaurateurs, and social workers -- doesn't detract from the uplifting message that such disadvantaged people can still have value. The real-life piano playing of Helfgott is heard on the soundtrack, and the musician has since issued recordings of the Rachmaninoff music key to the plot.


Explore, discuss, enjoy

  • Families can talk about mental illness. Did Shine change any opinions? How does the movie explain Davis' illness? Does the explanation ring true to you?

  • Is Peter Helgott just a terrible stage dad, or does his mania for controlling and restricting David have other motivations besides showbiz fame? Talk about other dysfunctional parental figures in the media.

  • How have movies generally depicted and/or stigmatized madness?

  • Look into the story of the real-life David Helfgott. Did the movie exaggerate, exploit, or whitewash?


This review of Shine was written by
Teen, 14 years old
May 3, 2012
 
my personal review
i watch this movie called shine and i say that kids starting with the age 11 limite can watch this movie, even thought i recommend it for adultes and children of the age of 13, 14 but there are some bad parts in it but if you are 12 and have a parent next to you , thats ok, but if 11 with no parente , no way , i liked the movie

Flag as inappropriate 

This review of Shine was written by
Studio:New Line
Director:Scott Hicks
Cast:Geoffrey Rush, John Gielgud, Lynn Redgrave
Genre:Drama
Run time:105 minutes
Theatrical release date:November 20, 1996
DVD release date:July 16, 1997
MPAA rating:PG-13
MPAA explanation:nudity/sensuality and intense thematic elements

This review of Shine was written by
 

Review It

Share your review with others

Hang on! You need to be a member to post your review.
A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines.

Learning Products Quick Finder

Great alternatives handpicked by our editors