Reseña de Common Sense Media
Por Darienne Stewart
,
con base en investigaciones sobre desarrollo infantil. ¿Cómo otorgamos nuestras calificaciones?
Gritty Steinbeck classic brings Great Depression to life.
Lo que las familias necesitan saber
¿Por qué para niños de 15 en adelante?
¿Algún contenido positivo?
Dónde lo puedes leer
¿De qué trata la historia?
Tom Joad, paroled after killing a man in a fight, returns to the family homestead in Oklahoma only to find his family gone, forced out as the banks seized failing farms. He and Casy, a former preacher, catch up with and join the family fleeing West to California, lured by tales of good work for good wages. At the center of the story is Ma Joad, surrounded by Pa Joad, his parents, six children, and one future in-law. Money and options are in short supply, but the family gets by with help from strangers. Their arrival in California is bitter: Fruit is left to rot as workers compete for low pay. The surviving Joads scrabble for food, shelter, and work. Even when they have nothing, they still find something to give to a starving man.
¿Vale la pena?
This visceral novel succeeds as a gripping story and a piece of history. John Steinbeck, who won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1962, alternates chapters following the Joads' saga with poetic interludes detailing the larger forces at work against the migrants.
Steinbeck, who visited migrant camps to research the book, skillfully illustrates the widening gulf between the haves and have-nots. His sympathies are obviously with the desperate families (to the point where he was accused of communist sympathies), but he treats the comfortable classes with empathy: Lack of knowledge and understanding reinforces suspicion and hatred of the migrants, who for their part can't understand why they're so vilified. It's an important lesson on perspective, and a fantastic starting point for discussing political, economic, and social issues still very relevant today.
Las familias pueden hablar sobre ...
Families can talk about the themes of economic disparity and power during the Great Depression and in the decades since. What has changed for the working classes since Steinbeck's novel? What hasn't? How does the conversation today about the haves and have-nots compare with what people were taking about the 1930s?
Steinbeck lays bare the ways prejudices take shape and are reinforced. Consider a group of people subject to discrimination in America today and explore the roots of prejudice against them.
Natural disaster and technological advances combine to cause the massive displacement of the 1930s. Families can discuss more recent disasters that have triggered internal displacement. For example, how has Hurricane Katrina in 2005 changed New Orleans and the country?
Struggling to survive, the migrants stick together. They typically help each other rather than acting in self-interest alone. But in modern survival tales, such as disaster films, survivors often act selfishly, discarding community unless it serves their needs (such as protection). Do you think one depiction is truer to human spirit than the other?
Detalles Libro
- Autor :
- Género : Historical Fiction
- Tipo de libro : De ficción
- Editorial : Penguin Classics
- Fecha de publicación : Enero 8, 2002
- Número de páginas : 464
- Última actualización : Septiembre 13, 2023
¿Nos faltó algo sobre diversidad?
Las investigaciones muestran que hay una relación entre la autoestima de los niños y las representaciones positivas en los medios de comunicación. Es por eso que hemos añadido una nueva sección de “Representaciones diversas” a nuestras reseñas, que se implementará de forma continua. Puedes apoyarnos a ayudar a los niños al
Sugiere una actualización
Los ratings imparciales de Common Sense Media son creados por críticos expertos y no están influenciados por los creadores del producto ni por ninguno de nuestros patrocinadores, afiliados o socios.
Mira cómo aplicamos los ratings