Guía para padres sobre A Different Pond

Libro Bao Phi Picture Book 2017
A Different Pond Poster Image

Reseña de Common Sense Media

Jan Carr Por Jan Carr , con base en investigaciones sobre desarrollo infantil. ¿Cómo otorgamos nuestras calificaciones?

edad 6+

Exquisitely tender family story of Vietnamese refugees.

Find family movie night faves faster. Download the app .

Lo que las familias necesitan saber

¿Por qué para niños de 6 en adelante?

¿Algún contenido positivo?

Reseñas de padres e hijos

¿De qué trata la historia?

In A DIFFERENT POND, a young, unnamed boy gets up long before dawn to go fishing with his father, to catch dinner for their Vietnamese refugee family before the dad goes off to his second job. They drive to a pond where they have to climb over a highway barrier and walk past a "No Trespassing" sign. They light a small campfire, and while fishing, the dad shares bologna sandwiches he made, and stories about the Vietnam war. When they've caught two crappies, they drive home, and the boy is left in the care of his older siblings for the day, as the dad and mom leave for work.

¿Vale la pena?

Nuestra reseña:
Los padres dicen : Aún no tiene ratings
Los niños dicen : Aún no tiene ratings

This tender, masterful family story about a hardworking refugee dad and his son focuses on a simple outing that speaks volumes about their lives and the strong ties that bind them. In A Different Pond, author Bao Phi chooses just the right sensory detail to bring the reader into the experience. As they drive before the sun comes up, "Dad turns on the heater," and when they finish fishing, they wash their hands "with a small nub of green and white soap." Phi also has a poet's ear for language. The minnows they buy for bait "swim like silver arrows in my hands." And the boy looks up "to see faint stars like freckles." Phi references Vietnam and the war, giving the reader a glimpse without weighing down the story. "Dad tells me about the war, but only sometimes. He and his brother fought side by side. One day, his brother didn't come home."

Thi Bui's evocative illustrations have a look a bit like graphic novel art. The body language of the dad and boy clearly conveys the affection they share, and Bui's midnight blue night scenes evoke the early hour. She also finds ways to show us that the neighborhood is diverse -- there's a sign in Spanish for a restaurant -- and also that it's somewhat gritty -- they pass a homeless man with his belongings piled high in a shopping cart. This tale is so artfully rendered in text and art, readers will be very glad they came along on this intimate family fishing trip.

Las familias pueden hablar sobre ...

  • Families can talk about the economic circumstances in A Different Pond. Why do you think the boy and his father get up before dawn to fish in a pond that has a "No Trespassing" sign? What indications are there that the family doesn't have much money?

  • Do you think the father and son like spending time together? How can you tell?

  • What examples of other races, nationalities, and immigrant groups in the boy's neighborhood can you find in the text and art?

Detalles Libro

¿Nos faltó algo sobre diversidad?

Las investigaciones muestran que hay una relación entre la autoestima de los niños y las representaciones positivas en los medios de comunicación. Es por eso que hemos añadido una nueva sección de “Representaciones diversas” a nuestras reseñas, que se implementará de forma continua. Puedes apoyarnos a ayudar a los niños al

A Different Pond Poster Image

Qué leer a continuación

Los ratings imparciales de Common Sense Media son creados por críticos expertos y no están influenciados por los creadores del producto ni por ninguno de nuestros patrocinadores, afiliados o socios.

Mira cómo aplicamos los ratings