June 27, 2022
A Painful but Important Part of Our History
This series may be difficult for some to watch, both because of the sensitive subject matter, as well as the uncomfortable realities that it asks us to face about our own country's actions surrounding the 9/11 attacks. The series is about 5 hours total, and it covers everything from the origins of the attack dating back as far as the 1980s, to the US' response and subsequent 'War on Terror', all the way the way up to 2021, just prior to the US withdrawal from Afghanistan. It offers viewers a comprehensive understanding of the context, historical analysis, and first-hand experience of these events as they unfolded, including testimony from key figures who were involved at every level and from all different sides/ organizations. I had gone into this series thinking that I understood a fair amount about this topic, as I lived in a neighboring state when the attacks occurred and have been following the aftermath/military action in the news for the past two decades. I was shocked by how little I actually knew, and how surface-level my understanding was. I believe this docu-series' greatest strength is the depth of analysis that it offers and its use of multiple perspectives in recounting the events that unfolded. Rather than relying on one person's viewpoint or description of events, the series blends together a variety of different testimonies, which helps to provide a more nuanced, well-rounded understanding of the situation. I believe this helped to mitigate the subjectivity of any one person's recollection of events, allowing viewers to be aware of points where perspectives slightly differed, or where certain narrators/interviewees may have a more biased viewpoint. This is different from most documentaries, which tend to rely on a singular description of events and thus can be heavily swayed by the opinions and biases of whoever is telling the story. I think it really strengthened the story and allowed for a greater depth of nuance. On that point, I would tend to disagree with the two other reviews here, which have said that this docu-series is 'politically slanted' or 'agenda driven'. I found quite the opposite to be true; despite how complex and contentious some of these events were considered to be, there was clearly a concerted effort by the directors to tell this story as authentically as possible by integrating the testimonies of a broad range of key figures involved with varying experiences and perspectives. I believe in the aftermath of 9/11, there was a really strong push for national unity and a strong desire to rally around the US military as the 'heros/good guys' getting revenge on the evil bad guys. That influenced how these events were portrayed to us by politicians and the media at the time, and it kept us in the dark about many of the policies, programs, military actions, and decisions that were implemented. As a result, we lost a lot of the accuracy, nuance, and historical/political context of how these events actually played out. I think this series offers a greater historical depiction of 9/11 and its aftermath than any other film or series that I have seen before. It is the sort of critical lens that can only be achieved well with the benefit of hindsight, and I would really recommend watching the series for yourself.
Report this review
September 7, 2021
Premature and Agenda Driven
They launched this film while the madness in Afghanistan was still unfolding. No mention of the Americans still stranded. No mention of the horror we've seen over the past month. But their timeline extends up to that point with the fall of Kabul...This happened 3 weeks ago. The producers of this film clearly seemed more concerned with a premier date than accurately documenting the subject they were covering.
Report this review
September 5, 2021
Sad, Please Don't Waste Your Time
Yet again more partisan slant. Please don't waste your precious time with this sad excuse for a documentary series . We need to work together for a better future not engag e with this type of nonsense.