A Lot or a Little?
What you will—and won't—find in this book.
The book gives insight into how the justice system works (or doesn't work) for youth offenders, including trials, incarceration, and post-jail group homes. Book details how young offenders get trapped once convicted: They can't get jobs or a good education and often have no place to go once they turn 18. Some writing referenced, including Push, The Great Gatsby, and the works of Maya Angelou. PTSD from traumatic events figures into the plot. Mary studies for the SAT, and vocabulary words are peppered throughout the book.
Learn to advocate for yourself and speak up; trust your gut. No matter how horrible your life has been, find a reason and a way to press on and work for a stable future.
Positive Role Models
Mary is a loyal person, often to her detriment. Ted, though he makes some bad life choices, cares for Mary and does what he can to help her and take care of her. Claire doesn't judge Mary and gives her advice and assistance. Cora is an excellent lawyer with high morals. She believes in Mary and works hard for her.
Violence & Scariness
Violence and brutality are major themes in the book. Many of the characters live in and have been raised in violent circumstances. They fear violence every day of their lives. The book looks at the cycle of violence and how hard it is to break. The girls in the group are vicious and cruel. They attack one another, sometimes with intent to kill. One girl throws boiling oil and water into another's face. The adults who run the home hit the girls. A cat is found killed and mutilated. Lots of verbal abuse. One character relates memories of her mother's abuse and of her mother's boyfriend repeatedly trying to molest her. Characters have memories and scars of childhood abuse. Ted is sometimes rough with Mary, and she accepts it as normal; he catches himself before it goes too far and is trying to be a better person. Memories unfold of a baby's death, which get more detailed as the story progresses. Lots of name-calling and queer- and fat-shaming.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Violence & Scariness in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
Sex, Romance & Nudity
Characters talk crudely about sex. Mary and Ted have a sexual relationship that isn't described graphically, though the feelings of enjoying sex and attraction are detailed. A character hears people having sex in the next room on more than one occasion.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Sex, Romance & Nudity in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
The book is written the way teens talk, especially tough kids, so profanity is frequent: "f--k" and variations, "s--t" and variations, "damn," "ass," "bitch," "goddamn," "piss," "c--t," "tits," "p---y," "butt," "dyke," "hell," and "nigga."
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Language in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking
Mrs. Richardson smokes and drinks, showing how she's fallen apart after her baby dies. Mary's mother's boyfriend drinks, which is related in flashback. Mary smells and sees pot smoke in a room, but no one is shown smoking.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Drinking, Drugs & Smoking in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
Parents Need to Know
Parents need to know Allegedly is a thriller about a teen girl, Mary, who was convicted at age 9 of killing a baby and has spent the past seven years in jail. The novel follows her post-jail life in the group home where she must live until she is 18. Mary tries hard to move beyond her circumstances and get ready for life after jail while also figuring out the truth behind the crime she allegedly committed. The content is gritty and realistic. It shows the difficulty youth offenders face in trying to get their lives back on track, especially when many of them have traumatic backgrounds. Life in the group home is extremely rough. Mary fears for her life on several occasions. The girls are physically and verbally brutal with one another. The story has a lot of violent scenes, name-calling, and fat- and gay-shaming. A cat is found killed and mutilated. Most of the characters are deeply troubled people, but a few are good, kind, and helpful. Sex between the characters is not described graphically but figures into the plot. The teen characters talk crudely about sex and swear constantly, including "f--k," "s--t," and "c--t." The book will spark discussions about the vicious cycle of crime and violence many troubled youths face and how the judicial system often fails them.
Is It Any Good?
While Allegedly is a gritty, gripping page-turner about convicted baby killer Mary Addison, it is about so much more. Readers will see how the juvenile justice system often fails the kids it's supposed to help. Themes of family, abuse, PTSD, teen pregnancy, mental illness, juvenile justice, and the ripple effect of loss are explored. Readers get a realistic insight into the uphill battle juvenile offenders face in trying to get their lives back on track. The book picks up with Mary living in a group home after her stint in jail. The group home is brutal, and the barrage of hatred and setbacks Mary experiences gets exhausting and repetitive at points. It's true to life, but it's hard to read.
The story is told from Mary's point of view, and the colloquial narration and teen dialogue ring true, with rough talk and swearing. Her relationship with her mother is heartbreaking. For all Mary's gone through, her childlike faith in her mother is sweet as well as maddening. The romance between Mary and Ted is tough but believable. It provides a few bright spots in the story. He has his own history and issues, but he's trying to do right by Mary and change his own life while helping her change hers. The tension in the story comes from Mary revisiting her memories of the night baby Alyssa died. She's not sure she can trust her memories, but she's not sure she can trust her mother, either. Nor can she trust a system that was anxious to put a 9-year-old girl behind bars. Documentation from her court case and media coverage is woven into the story and helps heighten the suspense. The twist toward the end throws the book offtrack. The story would have been better served by the introduction of some of the surprises sooner, but for many readers, it might entice them to read the book again to pick up the clues.
Did we miss something on diversity?
Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.
Suggest an Update
Our Editors Recommend
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.See how we rate