Bone Gap

Book review by
Mary Cosola, Common Sense Media
Bone Gap Book Poster Image
Beautiful tale of missing girl explores magic, love, loss.

Parents say

No reviews yetAdd your rating

Kids say

age 13+
Based on 2 reviews

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

Many references to mythology, especially the story of Orpheus going to the Land of the Dead. Two characters are beekeepers, and the story details interesting information about bees and beekeeping. A medical conditional called prosopagnosia, or face blindness, is explained.

Positive Messages

Love people for who they are; a person's character is more important than his or her looks. Don't give up when you know you're right. Stay true to yourself. Don't fall for people just because they tell you you're attractive.

Positive Role Models & Representations

The main character, Finn O'Sullivan, is a good, honest, caring teen boy. His older brother, Sean, is stoic but caring. He puts his life on hold to raise Finn. Priscilla "Petey" Willis is a strong, smart, independent teen girl. Her mother, Mel, has an open, loving relationship with her daughter and is willing to discuss any and all topics. Finn's and Sean's neighbor, Charlie Valentine, is kind to the boys and keeps an eye on them.

Violence

Five boys severely beat up one boy, resulting in bloodshed, a split lip and eyebrow, and bruised ribs. Girl bloodies fingernails trying to escape captivity. Girl found with injuries from escaping a kidnapper. Boy violently shakes girlfriend when she tries to break up with him. Boy menaces girl by holding her against the wall, seeming to threaten sexual violence. An implied rape, in that something happens behind closed doors and the reader is supposed to guess it's not consensual. Kidnapping. Stabbing. A character sustains a deep cut that bleeds a lot, requiring stitches, the sewing of which is described in detail. Moped and horse accident, with road rash and injuries sustained from horse hooves. Boy tries to force girl to give him oral sex. Girl punches boy in testicles. Face slashed.

Sex

Kissing, making out, and references to sex and oral sex. Sex scene between two teens. Many references to sex are vague, in a "Did they or didn't they?" way.

Language

Characters swear but not frequently, including "f--k" and its variations, "s--t," "s--thead," "a--hole," "God," "crap," "hell," "dumbass," "badass," "bitch," "balls," "whore," and "butt."

Consumerism

Lord of the Rings, Pine-Sol, Google, Batman, Froot Loops.

Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Parent smokes and is said to be smoking "more than cigarettes," but it isn't made clear what that entails. Reference to that same parent being "half baked on one thing or another." Teens drink alcohol at a party, where some get drunk and others drink in moderation.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Laura Ruby's Bone Gap is about a missing girl named Roza and the aftermath of her disappearance. Finn O'Sullivan knows she was kidnapped but can't prove it and beings to doubt himself. His brother, Sean, who was in love with Roza, thinks perhaps she's left him, given that he's been left before. The book examines love, loss, abandonment, and family duty against the backdrop of a small Illinois farming town that's a gateway to a mysterious world. The sex, drinking, and drug use in the book is not explicit. Infrequent profanity includes "s--t" and "f--k" and it's variations. The characters face many violent situations, including stabbing, beatings, a face slashing, and an implied rape. Bone Gap won the 2016 Michael J. Printz Award for excellence in literature written for young adults.

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title.

Teen, 15 years old Written byRobot2072 April 11, 2018

Absolutely magical

This book is a must-read! I didn't expect this novel to weave me in and lull me into the story, but it did and I lost track of time reading Bone Gap. No he... Continue reading
Teen, 14 years old Written bynoelleubanks19 February 20, 2018

Beautiful and Unexpected

I loved this book. It was a little bit mature but nothing 13+ can't handle.

What's the story?

On the surface, the town of Bone Gap, Illinois, doesn't seem to be all that different from other Midwestern towns, with its crops, livestock, and assortment of oddball citizens. But there are mysterious happenings and gateways in Bone Gap, some of which citizens might know about and some they can merely sense. One day, a beautiful girl with a mysterious past shows up injured and shaken in the barn of the O'Sullivan boys, Sean and Finn. They let the girl, Roza, stay in the in-law apartment in their house. Over the course of a year, she becomes a beloved member of their household and the community. One day Roza disappears, and Finn believes he saw her get kidnapped. No one in town will believe him. The town's reaction speaks volumes about their past losses and disappointments. Finn and Sean, for instance, were abandoned by their mother and left to fend for themselves. What if Roza is just another person they trusted who walked out on them? Even so, Finn refuses to believe she left on her own. His journey to solve her disappearance includes romance with a beekeeper, suffering at the hands of bullies, fights with his brother, and a gorgeous, seemingly magical horse that shows up in his barn one night.

Is it any good?

This beautifully written tale blends adventure, character study, and a touch of magical realism. All the characters in BONE GAP, including the minor ones, are well drawn and interesting. Author Laura Ruby does an excellent job of creating unusual individuals who feel like real people, and their lives and pasts strike a strong emotional chord. The book is slow to develop but not necessarily in a bad way. Ruby takes her time with the characters and the various romantic and adventurous story lines, and the narrative switches between Finn's and Roza's points of view. Because the action doesn't kick into gear until about halfway through the book, Bone Gap might not appeal to younger or less patient readers. The book's overarching themes are love and loss: What is the difference between real love and obsession or between love and possession? When someone leaves you, is there something wrong with you or with the other person? The examination of the different ways people cope with all kinds of love and abandonment -- including romance, family, and friendship -- is the best part of Bone Gap.

The story's magical realism elements draw on Greek mythology, and even though the fantasy elements are interesting, they could have been more integrated into the main story. These scenes felt too far apart from the rest of the "real" world in the book, and the story would have benefited from more information on how or why Bone Gap is an entryway to that mystical world and more explanation of the nameless bad guy's motives and who he is. He clearly is a metaphor for all the wrong ways to love a person, but more on how he came to be obsessed and how he has the powers he does would have helped the story enormously. The book examines the way we internalize our own problems and disappointments, and the biggest message is that love can take many forms.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about how we react to the ending of a relationship. Do you beat yourself up over things you could have done differently? Or can you think of ways you can learn lessons from every relationship to use as you go through life?

  • How do you feel about the way love is portrayed in movies and books? Wanting to possess another person can be portrayed as intense love or an unhealthy obsession. Can love at first glance ever be real love? Or is it just infatuation? 

  • How do you feel about the element of magical realism in books and movies? Does it serve a good storytelling purpose most of the time?

Book details

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

For kids who love mystery and romance

Our editors recommend

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality and learning potential.

Learn how we rate