Carve the Mark

Book review by
Sandie Angulo Chen, Common Sense Media
Carve the Mark Book Poster Image
Twist-filled fantasy romance is occasionally dark, violent.

Parents say

No reviews yetAdd your rating

Kids say

age 13+
Based on 8 reviews

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

Readers will learn about different fighting styles, about ritualistic responses to killing/death, and how different people who share a homeland might have linguistic, cultural, and philosophical differences despite their proximity.

Positive Messages

Carve the Mark makes clear that individuals shouldn't be judged by stereotypes about their heritage/people. The story shows how groups of people are complicated and how sharing a homeland can be incredibly difficult to navigate. The book also promotes strong, capable female characters and vulnerable, emotional male characters.

Positive Role Models & Representations

Cyra is intelligent, resourceful, and an expert fighter. Akos is intuitive, vulnerable, and empathetic. They have complementary gifts, help each other, and want to protect each other from physical and figurative pain.

Violence

Lots of violence: torture, murder, duels, poisoning, and more. Ryzek forces Cyra to touch his enemies to torture them, and the pain can sometimes kill them and even leads one to kill himself weeks later. There are Gladiator-like fights to the death and public executions. Various people are forced to kill.

Sex

A couple of passionate kisses and descriptions of attraction; desire for more touching and affection.

Language

A half dozen uses of "s--t" as an exclamation.

Consumerism
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Lots of people take medicine and teas made from iceflower; it can be medicinal or recreational. People purposely poison others with plant-derived drugs. Occasional drinking among the upper classes.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Carve the Mark is a futuristic fantasy from best-selling Divergent author Veronica Roth. The first in a two-volume series, the dual-narrative story includes fantasy violence, murder, kidnapping, imprisonment of innocents, and a planned war. The characters' unique gifts can injure, torture, even kill. There's a buildup of romantic chemistry but only a few kisses, nothing more. However, the violence is persistent throughout the story, from assassinations to drawn-out torture sessions to arena duels to the death. Language includes mild insults and a few uses of "s--t." The book offers up swapped gender roles, with the girl protagonist as the expert fighter and the boy protagonist as the vulnerable, emotional one. Some critics have pointed out problematic depictions of skin color and chronic pain, but that's open to interpretation. The story promotes the message that groups of people are more than the stereotypes about them.

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title.

Teen, 16 years old Written bycsreviewer February 11, 2017

Captivating, yet Violent

Carve The Mark is the next book by the bestselling author of the Divergent trilogy, Veronica Roth. Her lastet novel will keep you reading without putting it dow... Continue reading
Kid, 11 years old January 3, 2018

Great Fantasy Novel, but a Little bit Dark for some Readers

Carve the Mark is a great book which has the right amount of practically everything. The violence may be a bit overwhelming for some people, but it also explor... Continue reading

What's the story?

CARVE THE MARK is the first book in best-selling Divergent author Veronica Roth's new fantasy duology. Set on an icy planet ruled by violence between two neighboring but enemy peoples -- the peaceful Thuvhe and the nomadic, violent Shotet, who carve a mark on their skin after every kill -- the story is told from two points of view. There's Akos Kereseth, the youngest son of a Thuvhian oracle (everyone on the planet has an X-Men-like special gift, whether it's the power of persuasion, swapping memories, or seeing the future), and Cyra Noavek, the younger sister to Ryzek, the Shotet's tyrannical ruler. After Ryzek kidnaps a young Akos and his older brother, Eijeh, the brothers are brought up imprisoned in the Shotet kingdom. Cyra's gift is that she feels and can cause unlimited amounts of pain, while Akos' is that he can interrupt anyone else's gift. Dictatorial Ryzek gives Akos to Cyra as a present, because his touch can relieve her pain. Although at first they're reluctant to trust each other, Akos and Cyra eventually become friends. As Ryzek embarks on a mission to go to war with the Thuve, Cyra and Akos must decide how to undermine his bloody plans.

Is it any good?

Roth's latest twist-filled fantasy is sure to please readers who love epic opposites-attract romances set in war-torn faraway lands. Like An Ember and the Ashes and The Winner's Curse, this is a tale of two protagonists, one who's from a ruling family and caste and one who's practically a slave. Both Cyra and Akos are "fated" -- meaning that oracles see them carrying out the same destiny in a host of possible futures -- and their fates are linked. Cyra's voice is in first person, while Akos' is in third person, fitting their personal styles: She's passionate and rational, he's guarded and emotionally fragile. Their romance is refreshingly slow-building, even though they're forced to spend all their time together. They have to learn to trust each other first, and Roth makes sure to draw out the tension for most of the book.

Roth gets into a bit of trouble with the world-building, which is occasionally sloppy and underdeveloped. The descriptions of the two peoples are a tad stereotypical: The Shotet are multiracial but have darker-skinned rulers (reminiscent of Brazil), and their language is described as harsh (even by Cyra herself, which doesn't make all that much sense, since she loves her language), while the Thuhve are described as practically Scandinavian. With only one more book left, Roth will have a lot of questions to answer and plot holes to fill, but it's clear her finest skills are in building relationships and characters -- not necessarily fully fleshed-out fantasy worlds.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about the gender roles in Carve the Mark. Cyra is the strong one who can fight, and Akos is the vulnerable one. What other books offer unconventional gender roles?

  • What did you think of the level of violence in the book? How do these issues affect the characters? Is violence in books different from that in other media, such as movies or television? 

  • Some readers have complained that the book's description of the peaceful Thuve as fair-skinned and the "bloodthirsty" Shotet as darker-skinned is racist. A prominent disabled critic says the description of pain as a "gift" is also insensitive to those who aren't able-bodied. What do you think?

Book details

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

For kids who love fantasy

Our editors recommend

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality and learning potential.

Learn how we rate