A lot or a little?
The parents' guide to what's in this book.
What parents need to know
Parents need to know that this is the first book for tweens by the author of the popular young adult Shadowshaper series. Like the that series, this story is set in New York City and features African American and Latino characters. But here, the story is set during the Civil War era and throws in domesticated dinosaurs for a fantasy twist. The main character, African Cuban Magdalys, sees a theater and her orphanage burn during rioting, finds her adult friend lynched and burned, and hears that many other African Americans were killed or rounded up and sent back to slavery in the South. In a climactic gun-dinosaur fight, dinosaurs eat people and other dinos -- the only gore described is a dino's throat torn out and a dino's head half shot off. A fight at sea with guns and swords leaves slavers dead and loved ones kidnaped. Other mature content is mild: Adults drink beer and say "damn." Kids should check out the extensive glossary in the back to learn more about events, people, places, dinosaurs, and even old-fashioned guns mentioned.
What's the story?
In DACTYL HILL SQUAD, Magdalys and her friends from New York's Colored Orphan Asylum head to a Shakespeare play one evening on the orphanage's old triceratops. On the way, the corrupt city magistrate astride a knuckleskull threatens the group and urges them to turn around. Magdayls prays their triceratops will rear up and startle him -- and he does just that. And later when the theater begins to burn and her friend needs rescuing, the fire department's brachy understands her. And understands when Magdalys, the theater actors, and all her friends need to get somewhere safe. Rioting has broken out in New York City and African Americans are being targeted. The group heads to a safe house in Brooklyn, where they're given a place to stay and a job: to use dactyls to gather intel around the city and alert the safe house when African Americans are threatened in New York City. After the riots, many more have been kidnaped and sent South as slaves. Because of Magdalys' newfound talent to communicate with dinos, she's the best person for the job.
Is it any good?
It's a shame that a book with so fascinating a premise -- African American kids astride dinos in Civil War-era NYC -- is so poorly set up and executed. The many glossaries in the back of the book may hold more interest for readers, mostly because the writing is clear, the way it should be for middle graders. It seems like the story begins three chapters in. We know just a little about Magdalys and almost nothing about the kids that will be the Dactyl Hill Squad. And when the big rescue scene jumps hastily to "we're chimney sweep spies now" there will be more head-scratching. So much doesn't get developed. It allows for more action -- there's a whole lot of that -- but it's grounded in very little and, again, hard to follow, like a sketch instead of play-by-play.
Kids may still take a lot away from Dactyl Hill Squad, though. They'll get a new perspective on the Civil War era, a few dinosaur facts, and a great heroine who learns to embrace her talents and take pride in them like all kids should. Here's hoping the writing in the sequel gets a much finer polish.
Talk to your kids about ...
Families can talk about Magdalys and her relationship to dinosaurs in Dactyl Hill Squad. What did the captive dinosaur represent to her? What does it represent in the book as a whole?
What did you learn about the lives of African American New Yorkers during the Civil War era?
Will you read the next in the series? What do you think will happen to Magdalys and her friends?
- Author: Daniel Jose Older
- Genre: Fantasy
- Topics: Dinosaurs, Magic and Fantasy, Adventures, Brothers and Sisters, Friendship, History, Misfits and Underdogs, Pirates
- Book type: Fiction
- Publisher: Scholastic
- Publication date: September 11, 2018
- Publisher's recommended age(s): 8 - 12
- Number of pages: 272
- Available on: Paperback, Nook, Audiobook (unabridged), Hardback, iBooks, Kindle
- Last updated: June 19, 2019
Our editors recommend
Themes & Topics
Browse titles with similar subject matter.
Top advice and articles
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.