Grenade

Name: Grenade
Item: Grenade
Rating: 5
Author: Jan Carr

Book review by

Jan Carr, Common Sense Media

Common Sense says

age 11+

(i)

Tense, gripping WWII drama has powerful cost-of-war message.

Save

Rate book

Read or buy

Parents say

age 14+

Based on 1 review

Kids say

age 11+

Based on 8 reviews

Get it now

Searching for streaming and purchasing options ...

Common Sense is a nonprofit organization. Your purchase helps us remain independent and ad-free.

Get it now on

Searching for streaming and purchasing options ...

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

Information about World War II, the Pacific theater. Pearl Harbor. Map of Okinawa. History of Okinawa and relationship to Japan. Japan invaded and conquered Okinawa in 1609. Battleship Yamato. Okinawan spiritual principal of mabui. Near destruction of Okinawan Shuri Castle, royal palace of Ryukyu Kingdom. Some Japanese words. Surrender of Nazis in Europe. Suicide of Hitler. U.S. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt dies from stroke, succeeded by Harry Truman.

Positive Messages

Soldiers on both sides are human beings, with families, sweethearts, normal lives back home. They're capable of empathy and kindness but become monsters when they feel threatened and afraid. People can try to hold onto their humanity even in dire circumstances. Bravery doesn't mean not being scared; it means overcoming your fear to do what you need to.

Positive Role Models & Representations

Ray collects photographs from the bodies he comes across, both American and Japanese. Hideki does same, memorializing those who died on both sides, helping to preserve their spirits. Hideki overcomes his fears when trying to save his sister and a group of Okinawan children. In midst of war, Hideki muses on what causes killing and atrocities; he cultivates the ability to see people beyond affiliation with two warring factions. Some soldiers move beyond their roles to help or heal others.

Violence

Lots of casualties, some shockingly unexpected. Both protagonists kill. Characters get killed by sniper fire, grenades, flamethrowers, shot at point-blank range. Some who die are civilians, some children, some soldiers in their teens. Group of civilians commit suicide by jumping off cliff when trying to escape soldiers. Soldiers commit suicide to avoid capture or gunfire. One character's hit by bullets, "his body dancing like a broken puppet." Flashback to American soldier's father attacking him with knife because he has PTSD from WWI.

Sex

Language

The American soldiers call Japanese people "Japs." Book gives a heads-up that it "contains terminology that was used in World War II," and in an afterword, Gratz says, "calling someone a 'Jap' is offensive and disrespectful. I used this word in my book for historical accuracy, but it's a word you should never use."

Consumerism

Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Hideki finds cigarettes in a fallen soldier's backpack and gives them to other soldiers.

Set limits for violence and more with Plus

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Grenade is by best-selling author Alan Gratz (Refugee), who excels at writing harrowing, page-turning historical fiction for kids. It's set in World War II during the American invasion of Okinawa, a months-long battle. The book's message is strongly anti-war, with a plea for finding the humanity in others. Gratz doesn't shy away from depicting the bloody realities of war. There's much loss of life, and readers may be surprised and upset when numerous characters they've grown close to die unexpectedly. Hideki, the Okinawan protagonist, loses multiple family members. American soldiers call Japanese soldiers "Japs," though Gratz makes clear in his author's note that "calling someone a 'Jap' is offensive and disrespectful. I used this word in my book for historical accuracy, but it's a word you should never use." The publisher recommends the book for 9-12, but it's best for kids ready to consider the horrors of war.

Wondering if Grenade is OK for your kids?

Set preferences and get age-appropriate recommendations with Common Sense Media Plus. Join now

User Reviews

Parents say
Kids say

Parent of a 7, 9, and 12-year-old Written byRoss S. January 27, 2019

age 14+

The human cost of total war

Two boys on opposite sides of World War II, Ray and Hideki, live a beautiful story of suffering, pain, and redemption. We journey with them to discover what ma... Continue reading

Report this review

Teen, 14 years old Written bydragonmemeZ March 31, 2020

age 10+

Great but I have some complaints

I loved alan gratz sense I read refugee for a book club and I really enjoyed this book but so far my only complaint is how (spoiler now) ray had died when part... Continue reading

Report this review

Teen, 13 years old Written byRhymcYT February 13, 2020

age 13+

Great book! Only thing is the Language and Violence.

This book was great and fun to read! I would recommend this book to mainly middle school students. The only thing that parents may find this disturbing is the f... Continue reading

Report this review

What's the story?

GRENADE opens on the eve of young Hideki's graduation on Okinawa, just as the Americans launch their invasion. As his school is destroyed by a bomb from a battleship, the boys are enlisted in the Japanese army and each given two grenades. Ray, a young American private on the battleship, is storming the beach. When he and his fellow Marines land, they set out to take the island, encountering civilian Okinawans and Japanese soldiers. Both Hideki and Ray witness bloody battles and deaths. What will Hideki do with his two grenades? Will he and Ray stay alive? Will the Americans take the island? What will happen to the civilian Okinawans fleeing their homes? And can the young soldiers hold on to their humanity in the midst of all the killing?

Is it any good?

This expertly crafted, well-researched novel mines a historical battle for its page-turning drama while shining a light on the human cost of war and examining how war erodes our humanity. In Grenade, author Alan Gratz spotlights soldiers and civilians from all sides of the battle: Americans, Japanese, and the Okinawans enlisted to fight for the Japanese but caught in the middle. For half the novel, Gratz alternates chapters, switching between two very young soldiers, one Okinawan and one American. Both are sensitive, tenderhearted boys who struggle with the killing that they see around them and that they are called to do.

In this book, there are no good guys and bad guys. Rather than glorifying war, it demonstrates concretely how war turns humans into soldiers who do monstrous things. "They became monsters when they were afraid. It didn't excuse it, but it explained it." He also weaves in respectful details about the traditional spiritual beliefs and practices of the Okinawan people, taking the story beyond the battlefield and adding to the power of this sensitive, emotionally resonant book.

Talk to your kids about ...

Families can talk about the deaths in Grenade. Do they seem different from ones in video game battles? Were you surprised by any? Why do you think the author included some of the specific casualties he did? Do they make the book and message more powerful?
Could you follow the back-and-forth focus between the two main characters, Hideki and Ray? Why do you think the author wrote about characters from all sides of the battle?
What do you know about World War II? What did you know about the war in Europe? In the Pacific? Did you learn anything new from this book?