Lady Midnight: The Dark Artifices, Book 1

Book review by
Carrie R. Wheadon, Common Sense Media
Lady Midnight: The Dark Artifices, Book 1 Book Poster Image
Popular with kids
Shadowhunter fans will love, but the romance is nothing new.

Parents say

age 12+
Based on 3 reviews

Kids say

age 13+
Based on 17 reviews

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

The short story "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson and Edgar Allan Poe's poem "Annabelle Lee" both figure prominently in the plot, and all chapter titles are taken from Poe's poem. Uncle Arthur is a scholar of ancient Greek and Roman history and literature, with some mentions of his studies. The characters visit a number of places in LA. Check a page labeled Notes on the Text to learn which places are real and which are imagined.

Positive Messages

Loyalty and love of family and friends are key here. And as an extension of that, standing up for and protecting those who face discrimination, either because of having mixed blood (faerie and human) or for not being neurotypical (autism). Also, unjust laws are questioned and not followed often. The Clave's philosophy: The law is hard, but it is the law. The Blackthorn family philosophy: A bad law is no law.

Positive Role Models & Representations

Much is made of Julian's sacrifice, raising his four younger siblings starting at age 12. He's the steady, responsible one compared with Emma, who's more impulsive and driven mostly by revenge for her parents' deaths. Tiberius, Julian's younger brother, is autistic (though a label isn't overtly given). He's fully drawn as an individual with sensitivities as well as strengths.

Violence

With intense battles against demons and strange cult activity involving murders and spells, Lady Midnight gets gory. People are killed with hands chopped off, zombie-like creatures get their heads chopped off with swords, dead bodies show up covered in bloody graffiti, a boy watches his father ripped apart by demons. One detail in an intense demon battle describes slashing open their "bulging white eyes." A poisoned arrow nearly kills a main character, and another main character nearly drowns while being attacked by demons underwater. Characters are whipped until they pass out. A young boy is kidnapped and drugged. A whole group of people sits silently because all their necks have been broken. Mentions of a woman walled up in a tomb alive by her own family, of a main character killing his own father in a possessed state to save the rest of his family, of a mother dying of bone cancer years earlier, and of another character tortured physically and emotionally.

Sex

Characters in their late teens have sex, but only intense kissing and groping are described, and there's a mention the next day that birth control was covered (there's a special Shadowhunter Rune for that). Other couples -- straight, gay, and bisexual -- kiss passionately. A mention of syphilis.

Language

"Bitches" a few times, "bastard," "hell," and versions of "goddamn."

Consumerism

Mentions of iPhones, the movie Notting Hill, and the Avengers franchise.

Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Older teen Shadowhunters walk into bars and nightclubs where people are drinking wine and champagne, and there's one mention of a woman smoking.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Lady Midnight is Book 1 of the Dark Artifices series and part of a much larger Shadowhunters franchise. It includes six books in the Mortal Instruments series that takes place a few years before this series starts, three books in the Infernal Devices series that take place in the Victorian era, a movie (City of Bones), and a TV show (Shadowhunters). So most teens will already know quite a bit about this fantasy world full of Shadowhunters -- those with some angel blood who fight demons and sometimes faeries, warlocks, werewolves, and vampires. It helps to read the Mortal Instruments series before starting the Dark Artifices, but it isn't completely necessary. This series has always been for mature teen readers, because of both the level of violence and the sexual content. With intense battles against demons and strange cult activity involving murders and spells, Lady Midnight gets gory. People are killed with hands chopped off, zombie-like creatures get their heads chopped off with swords, dead bodies show up covered in bloody graffiti, and a boy watches his father ripped apart by demons. One detail in an intense demon battle describes slashing open their "bulging white eyes." A poisoned arrow nearly kills a main character, and another main character nearly drowns while being attacked by demons underwater. Characters are whipped until they pass out. These Shadowhunters also come with lots of baggage they must constantly sort through -- parents killed, horrors of battle witnessed at too young an age. Main characters have sex, not described beyond passionate kissing, and there's lots of that. As in the rest of the series, author Cassandra Clare offers all kinds of romance: Couples -- straight, gay, and bisexual -- kiss passionately. She also brings in a character on the autism spectrum who's well drawn, showing his sensitivities as well as his many strengths.

Wondering if Lady Midnight: The Dark Artifices, Book 1 is OK for your kids?

Set preferences and get age-appropriate recommendations with Common Sense Media Plus. Join now

Continue reading Show less

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say
Adult Written byDixie Athena November 6, 2019
Parent of a 3-year-old Written bylostintomes December 3, 2018

Best Cassandra Clare Book so far!

4.5 Stars
While I had a lot of fun reading The Infernal Devices and The Moral Instruments series, most of them stuck at around 3 Stars for me. This one broke th... Continue reading
Teen, 17 years old Written byImreallyadad12 February 7, 2020

Greatness

The book is amazing. love this author
Teen, 16 years old Written byEmmaCarstairs August 14, 2019

Awesome Book!

Love this book! It has a great storyline and a strong female lead! I highly recommend this book for someone who loves a bit of sci- fi and romance!

What's the story?

When a dead body turns up in Los Angeles, Emma Carstairs is anxious to investigate. It's soaked in seawater, burned, and covered in a demon language she can't read -- looking just like the bodies of her parents, found years before. Her parents' deaths had been considered casualties of the last big Shadowhunter war, case closed according to the Clave (Shadowhunters' governing body), but Emma always knew someone else killed them. At a secret Shadow Market, she gets a hint about where another body will be found, leading her to a secret LA cult filled with Downworlders. So much of what she's investigating is forbidden by the Clave, leading her parabatai Julian and his whole family at the L.A. Institute on a precarious path. It's a path made more dangerous when a convoy of faeries shows up, offering Julian's half-faerie brother, Mark, in exchange for them handing over the killer. While Julian wants his brother back at any cost, two problems arise: Contact with the faerie world is also forbidden after they sided with the enemy in the war, and Emma will not be handing over the killer to anyone. She's determined to have her revenge.

Is it any good?

Fans of the series who want more forbidden love with a demon-hunting backdrop will adore this start of a new series; those out for something fresh will be disappointed. LADY MIDNIGHT is part of a larger, highly successful formula where love is taboo and almost as dangerous as fighting demons. Emma and Julian make a great star-crossed pair, just like Jace and Clary and Tessa and Will, but spending thousands of pages getting those other two couples together (finally!) makes the whole Emma and Julian forbidden love tale feel a little tedious -- especially when they start keeping secrets from each other as an easy way to drag out the tension.

Lovelornness aside, there's also a big reveal about Julian's real role at the LA Institute that doesn't quite work. Most readers will suspect this big secret much earlier -- and will wonder why they put the clues together before Emma did. Cutting that part out would make Lady Midnight a more digestible length and get us all to the fantastically culty-creepy climactic action faster. That's when the book is finally full of surprises.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about the representation of LGBTQ characters and an autistic character in Lady Midnight. Is it a surprise to see these characters depicted? Why, or why not? Do you think the books you read represent most people in society?

  • What do you think about the level of gore in this series? Is it essential to the storytelling? Have you grown used to all the demon battles? Are there scenes you wouldn't want to see in a movie or on TV?

  • With a TV show and many books, this franchise is well-established. Would you like the series to go on and on? Do you think having a ready-made audience affects the way the author writes?

Book details

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

For kids who love fantasy and romance

Our editors recommend

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality.

Learn how we rate