Magic Marks the Spot: The Very Nearly Honorable League of Pirates, Book 1 Book Poster Image

Magic Marks the Spot: The Very Nearly Honorable League of Pirates, Book 1



Rollicking, magical tale of girl who joins pirate crew.

What parents need to know

Educational value

Occasional references to classic pirate literature, such as Treasure Island. Map-reading and problem-solving skills come into play.

Positive messages

Strong messages about bravery, loyalty, kindness, a spirit of adventure, and a sense of humor.

Positive role models

The intrepid Hilary, who refuses to accept limitations on her dreams and shows great determination in pursuing them, is an impressive, engaging heroine. Like Hilary, her fellow pirates, as well as her school roommate Claire, sometimes make foolish decisions, but learn from their mistakes and often come to the rescue in unlikely ways. Hilary's governess is a clever heroine.

Violence & scariness

There's a lot of talk about killing enemies, feeding them to sea monsters, etc., but very little actual harm comes to anyone, despite sword battles and the like. In one scene, Hilary fells her opponent by throwing a can of beets at his head. In the past, one of the adult characters killed the parents of one of the kids -- they were pirates and he sank their ship.

Not applicable

Parents Need to Know

Parents need to know that Magic Marks the Spot, first volume of The Very Nearly Honorable League of Pirates series, is for the most part a rollicking, lighthearted adventure, with a very appealing tween girl, would-be pirate Hilary Westfield, as its lead character. Piracy here is mostly about the quest for treasure (especially magic objects), loyalty to one's friends, and a general aversion to authority figures. In contrast to many, more boy-oriented pirate tales, there's little here in the way of gore or grossout. While there's much talk of killing foes and feeding them to sea monsters, even epic sword fights seem to end with little injury to anyone; sailors tossed overboard simply swim back to their own ship. Still, there are darker elements: The parents of one kid died when their boat was sunk by the father of another, and a character must deal with the fact that her father's an actual villain. Many characters show an unexpected side, for good and ill.

User reviews

Parents say

Not yet rated
Review this title!

Kids say

Not yet rated
Review this title!

What's the story?

In the kingdom of Augusta, young Hilary Westfield longs to be a pirate. But despite her seafaring skills, THE VERY NEARLY HONORABLE LEAGUE OF PIRATES refuses to allow her into the academy, because girls can't be pirates. Making matters worse, her father, the admiral, hates pirates and is determined to pack Hilary off to Miss Pimm's finishing school so she can be a proper young lady in high society. Undeterred, she soon joins up with a ragtag pirate crew in search of the lost treasure of The Enchantress, who centuries earlier gathered up most of the magic in the kingdom and hid it away; now they've found a mysterious map, and MAGIC MARKS THE SPOT.

Is it any good?


First-time author Caroline Carlson has a lively, humorous style that moves the story along quickly, the narrative often punctuated by letters and other documents exchanged by the characters. Amusing illustrations by Dave Phillips add to the fun. While the overall tone is light, some issues have a heavier side, such as the death of parents; the discovery that someone you love is not who they seem to be. Some of the best moments come as Hilary discovers some of the downsides to pirate life, such as being cold, wet, and seasick a lot.

Families can talk about...

  • Families can talk about why pirates are such a popular subject for stories. Do you have any favorite pirates?

  • What turns out to surprise Hilary about pirate life? How does she discover the side of it she doesn't love?

  • Do you know any adults who behave like any of the characters here? What character do they remind you of, and why? Do you like them, or prefer to avoid them?

Book details

Author:Caroline Carlson
Illustrator:Dave Phillips
Topics:Magic and fantasy, Adventures, Friendship, Misfits and underdogs, Pirates
Book type:Fiction
Publisher:HarperCollins Children's Books
Publication date:September 10, 2013
Number of pages:368
Publisher's recommended age(s):8 - 12
Available on:Nook, Audiobook (unabridged), Hardback, iBooks, Kindle

This review of Magic Marks the Spot: The Very Nearly Honorable League of Pirates, Book 1 was written by

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are conducted by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.


Our star rating assesses the media's overall quality.

Find out more

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

About Our Rating System

The age displayed for each title is the minimum one for which it's developmentally appropriate. We recently updated all of our reviews to show only this age, rather than the multi-color "slider." Get more information about our ratings.

Great handpicked alternatives

Top advice and articles

What parents and kids say

See all user reviews

Share your thoughts with other parents and kids Write a user review

A safe community is important to us. Please observe our guidelines

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title.


Did our review help you make an informed decision about this product?