Nightshade, Book 1

Book review by
Sandie Angulo Chen, Common Sense Media
Nightshade, Book 1 Book Poster Image
Gripping werewolf thriller explores lust more than love.

Parents say

age 16+
Based on 3 reviews

Kids say

age 14+
Based on 5 reviews

Did we miss something on diversity?

Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this movie.

Educational Value

Because part of the story takes place in a philosophy class, teens will be exposed to very abbreviated discussions about a few philosophers' beliefs. Like most paranormal books, the author explores legends about werewolves and witches. There is also an ongoing debate about freedom of self vs. duty to the pack, as the central character must decide between her heart and a forbidden romance and her obligation to everyone she loves and protects.

Positive Messages

There is a strong message about individualism, freedom, and the importance of being able to make your own decisions -- especially when it comes to love. 

Positive Role Models

Calla is a strong but at times morally ambiguous character. She lies when it suits her, not just to protect others, and it's sometimes difficult to discern whether she's being selfish or selfless with her actions, especially during the cliffhanger ending, when it's clear she's chosen to save one life at the possible/probable expense of several others. Shay and Ren are both brave, strong, and really do love Calla, even though they're at odds with each other. All of the young Guardians in Calla and Ren's pack are courageous and protective of each other, but they also carry out orders without necessarily questioning them.


Werewolves get involved in some bloody skirmishes with other paranormals, but humans are almost always left alone, except for one who is cursed with seizures and left unconscious for disobeying a rule. Characters are attacked, kidnapped, and nearly killed on a fairly regular basis. A few people die (secondary characters we don't know well), and the violence inherent in being a wolf is discussed. Most of the time there are no weapons used, since the characters can seamlessly shift into wolves. Since the fighting takes place between paranormal creatures, it does not seem realistic.


Lots of hormones in this story, with references to making out and romantic conquests. Calla lusts after two handsome suitors and ends up kissing them both on more than one occasion. Calla describes the difference between all-consuming physical attraction and romantic desire. There are discussions of virginity and the "duties of a mate," since Calla is betrothed to another character. Some double-standards are explored: The alpha male is allowed to have several flings (and presumably sex), but Calla is supposed to remain untouched until her mating ceremony. A grown alpha male makes suggestive advances to a married female. A character is known to be a womanizer who prefers very young girlfriends. A few characters are gay, and it's mentioned that the paranormal community can be homophobic.


The occasional PG-13 word: "bitch," "s--t," "hell," "stupid," "ass." 


Calla regularly mentions the designer brands the Keepers wear, such as Gucci, Dolce & Gabbana, and the exotic cars they drive. Product labels are mostly used to describe only the Keepers and just to highlight how posh they are compared with the Guardians. 

Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

There is some underage drinking at a nightclub. A couple of adults smoke cigarettes.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that this paranormal romance-adventure is heavy on violent action sequences and even heavier on teen hormones. The Guardian werewolves are involved in bloody skirmishes with other paranormal creatures, and there is a slight body count. Sexuality, love, and marriage are all discussed at length, because the protagonist is betrothed. There is some passionate kissing and touching, as well as the standard language you'd expect in a PG-13 movie ("s--t," "ass," "bitch," etc.). The book follows a strong, independent but emotionally fragile female protagonist who must choose between two lives and two suitors that represent different values.

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say
Adult Written bySapphireRose171 November 5, 2020

Very promising!

The first book in the Nightshade series is very thrilling. The suspense excitement in the plot makes you read the entire thing without a break. It's one of... Continue reading
Parent of a 12-year-old Written bykendrita007 November 24, 2012

Keep aware of what your children are bringing home.

This book I was shocked my just turned 12 year old daughter took out at her school library. I wish they would not have these kinds of books there.
Teen, 16 years old Written byalpha26 April 19, 2019

Tries too hard

The protagonist Calla is unrelatable and is seen as strong by herself and her companions despite being the damsel in distress in nearly every situation. She is... Continue reading
Teen, 15 years old Written bytamartin1999 January 13, 2015


Andrea Cremer has to be one of my favorite authors. I have personally read 'Nightshade' close to 9 times and I am currently in the process of re-readi... Continue reading

What's the story?

Calla Tor is no ordinary 17-year-old blond beauty; she's an alpha Guardian -- an elite werewolf who is part of a pack that protects the mysterious and powerful Keepers (witches) living in Colorado. One day Calla breaks a Guardian vow by shifting forms to save the life of a human guy. She reveals herself to him, thinking she'll never see him again, but when she returns to her elite private school, he's the new guy in town. His name is Shay, and he's only got eyes for Calla, but she's spoken for in an arranged betrothal to Ren, the sexy alpha male of a rival pack. Ren and Calla are destined to be "mated" on Halloween, unifying the two packs, but in the two months leading up to her marriage ceremony, Calla realizes Shay isn't just a normal human, and her feelings for him are too complicated to ignore. Calla must choose between her desire for Shay and the unknown and her relationship with Ren and their devoted pack.

Is it any good?

Andrea Cremer's first novel is as fast-paced and emotionally driven as you'd expect in a best-selling novel aimed at teen girls. Like many comparable heroines, Calla is a powerful protagonist who is nonetheless insecure when it comes to romance. She's inexperienced and unbelievably drawn to both her sexy alpha-male fiancé, Ren, and the sweet and passionate mystery guy, Shay. But by focusing so much on Calla's stomach-flipping feelings of infatuation, lust and (could it be?) first love, Cremer creates a heroine who somehow lacks the substance and spunk of Hex Hall's Sophie, the Mortal Instruments' Clary or Paranormalcy's Evie. 

Calla isn't particularly clever or funny or smart. She is, however, a fierce fighter, doting sister, and protective friend. Sadly, when it comes to her singular interest in Shay, she loses some of her appeal. The two guys each have their merits, and the story is obviously going to divide fans into Team Ren or Team Shay, but it's fairly obvious (at least in this first book) whom the author means Calla to be with ultimately. The cliffhanger ending may frustrate some readers, but luckily the sequel is already available, so you can immediately move on to Wolfsbane.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about the violence depicted in the book. Is reading about paranormal violence less disturbing than something more realistic, like gun violence or gang altercations?

  • Why are love triangles so prevalent in young adult literature? Which of Calla's love interests do you prefer and why? Do you think she makes the right choice?

  • How does the werewolf lore in the story compare with the werewolves in comparable teen books? Do you think there is too much backstory about the wolves and the witches? Do you understand all the mythology and philosophy discussed among the characters?

Book details

Our editors recommend

For kids who love teen fantasy romances

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality.

Learn how we rate