Orphan Island

Book review by
Mary Eisenhart, Common Sense Media
Orphan Island Book Poster Image
Wrenching emotional fable leaves many questions unanswered.

Parents say

age 10+
Based on 3 reviews

Kids say

age 10+
Based on 3 reviews

Did this review miss something on diversity?

Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive, diverse representations in books, TV shows, and movies. Want to help us help them? Suggest a diversity update

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this book.

Educational Value

Strong theme of teaching kids to read as early as possible, and of writing as a way of communicating with distant generations. Plentiful references, though not by name, to the books the kids read on the island, including The Giving Tree, The Little Prince, James and the Giant Peach, and Harry Potter.

Positive Messages

Teamwork, living up to your responsibilities, looking out for others, showing courage, trying to fix things when they go wrong, especially if it's your fault. Perhaps less positive message: If you dare to defy "the way it's always been" and try something you think is better, you'll wreak terrible harm on the world, your loved ones, and yourself.

Positive Role Models & Representations

Jinny is believably conflicted but works hard to live up to her responsibilities, especially involving Ess, her "Care." Departing older boy Deen and younger boy Ben are serious, responsible, and respectful of the rules. The younger kids shine at different moments, and mostly all work together for their little community.


Formerly friendly snakes turn deadly and bite a child. A child deliberately tears the legs off a starfish.


Puberty is the metaphorical serpent in this Eden. An older girl getting her first period, and knowing nothing about what's going on, is traumatic for her and the reader. She takes it as sure evidence she's broken the entire world, including herself, with her choices. Younger kids make jokes about her developing breasts. Vaguely phallic imagery involving snakes and their changing nature.


Lots of people and things have quirky names -- most notably, peeing and pooping are called "wishing."

Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that Orphan Island, by Laurel Snyder (Seven Stories Up), is about a magical island that's home to nine kids. Once in a while a boat arrives leaving a new, little kid and taking the eldest away to parts unknown. As her own turn to leave looms, protagonist Jinny, who's probably about 12, starts to seriously question this blind obedience to the rules and to wonder about the kids who went before them. Many questions are raised, never to be answered -- which a sequel could solve, but none's been announced. There's a lot of internal conflict (staying vs. going, holding on vs. letting go, being responsible vs. being free, etc.) and emotional turmoil, as well as traumatizing moments presented as simply inevitable, including leaving a wailing child behind forever. All of which can be a bit harrowing for sensitive readers, so we're recommending this for 10 and up rather than the publisher's 8 and up.

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say
Adult Written byJdustinl May 14, 2020

A bit slow and awkward

The book is ok, but leaves too many questions unanswered. At one point, Jonny has her first period, so if that’s something you don’t think your child is ready t... Continue reading
Adult Written bybrooklyn c. July 25, 2019

Brilliant & Moving

Like the other positive review of this book, I am also writing a review to purely combat the negative review below. Here's the thing:

1) it IS APPROPRIAT... Continue reading
Kid, 12 years old April 4, 2020
I love it! There are a few parts that younger kids shouldn't see, like when Jinny has her first period, if kids don't know about it then it could be... Continue reading
Teen, 13 years old Written byCorinneSimmons October 1, 2019

Really good!

This book is just AMAZING! It has a lot of positive roll models and it's a good story. It's doesn't have any nasty things in it like a lot of mod... Continue reading

What's the story?

On ORPHAN ISLAND, everyone knows the verse: "Nine on an island, orphans all / Any more, the sky might fall." Nine kids live a simple life on a magical isle that supplies all their needs, keeps them all safe, and puts on a spectacular light show in the sky every morning and evening. And, every now and then, there's a Changing, as a boat arrives bearing a little kid and leaves taking the eldest kid away, never to be seen again. When her best friend, Deen, leaves, like all the bigger kids before him, Jinny, now the eldest, questions why the kids have always blindly obeyed this rule, without knowing who made it or why, or what's going to happen to them. Soon, the boat will come for her. Then what?

Is it any good?

This coming-of-age fable of kids on an island has a great premise, relatable characters, and heartfelt emotions. Also a habit of raising tantalizing questions only to leave them hanging at book's end. Why do the kids come to the island? Where do they come from? Who sends them? Where do the kids who leave go? Where did the books come from, and who's Abigail? You'll wonder all these things and more, but you'll be none the wiser at story's end. Like The Giving Tree, which comes up early on, Orphan Island provokes strong feelings in readers, whether they love it and think it speaks to their innermost heart, or they can't believe they stuck it out for 288 pages for so little payoff.  

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about Orphan Island and other stories of kids living on their own in some isolated place. Why do you think this is such a popular theme for storytelling? What other examples can you think of?

  • One character in Orphan Island loves the book The Giving Tree, while another thinks it's really stupid. Have you read that book? What do you think? Can you see why someone might feel differently?

  • Have you ever been in a situation where you had to figure out what to do, and you didn't really have enough information to make a decision? What did you do? Was there anyone you could ask for help?

Book details

Our editors recommend

For kids who love fantasy and coming-of-age stories

Themes & Topics

Browse titles with similar subject matter.

Top advice and articles

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality.

Learn how we rate