A lot or a little?
The parents' guide to what's in this book.
What parents need to know
What's the story?
On Christmas Eve, Jim decorates gingerbread cookies to look like pirates and saves his favorite -- Captain Cookie -- to stay by his bedside. The rest of the pirate cookies are set aside for Santa Claus to eat. After Jim goes to sleep, Captain Cookie sets off to round up his crew and rescue them from being devoured by their mysterious enemy. But when the cookies finally encounter Santa Claus, fear is replaced by wonder and joy as the gingerbread crew receives a most magical gift.
Is it any good?
The strength of this sweet fantasy is the watercolor and gouache illustrations by Matt Tavares. He presents the story mostly from the perspective of a gingerbread cookie, exploring a nighttime setting cloaked in mystery and drama. The crumbling cookies’ frosted expressions melt to fear and dismay as they prepare to face Santa Claus in the shadows, then turn to wary trepidation as they follow Santa to learn about Christmas.
Unfortunately, the serviceable text doesn’t live up to the imaginative premise or the handsome illustrations. It feels rushed and flat, and relies heavily on the artwork to explain key plot points. But kids won’t mind, and they’ll enjoy following Captain Cookie as he step-taps about with his toothpick peg leg. The oversized pages and large print make this a good choice for reading aloud to a group.
Artwork makes great use of perspective and captures the magic of home on Christmas Eve.
Talk to your kids about ...
Families can talk about perspective. Most of the story is told from the view of the tiny gingerbread captain, who sees stairs as cliffs and a cookie jar as a prison. Kids can pretend to be a small cookie and then a giant. How would the world look different? Take a ride on a parent's shoulders and see how the view changes.
Captain Cookie knows nothing about Christmas or Christmas Eve. Ask kids to imagine being the mouse he meets. How would they explain Christmas?
For kids who love Christmas
Our editors recommend
Top advice and articles
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.