A Lot or a Little?
What you will—and won't—find in this book.
A major plot thread deals with fictional detective Sherlock Holmes -- especially the fateful consequences of Story Thieves characters landing in a Holmes story at a critical moment. Mystery fiction, its characters, problems, and story conventions, like the Locked Room Murder Mystery, are all part of the world-building.
Strong messages about perseverance, friendship, sticking together, and helping each other out -- no matter how weird things get. Do your best to do the right thing, even when you're not entirely sure what's going on or what the plan might be.
Positive Role Models
Dauntless, quick-thinking Bethany is a real star here, trying to escape a would-be murderer while not ditching her friends and keeping to her quest to find her father. And when she does the wrong thing with the best intentions, she owns up to it and tries to make things right. Also great is onetime ordinary kid Owen, confronting numerous perils, unexpected plot twists, and quick-changing realities. He's a good friend and a brave companion, as well as a good problem-solver. A parade of "fictional" characters, from EarthGirl to kid bandit Moira Gonzalez, are there to help out when other "fictional" characters are villainous.
Violence & Scariness
For much of the story, a character is trapped in a locked room with the water rising. A villain burns down the library where a character's mom works and frames him for it. Cartoonish, science-fiction-y violence, such as one fictional universe where Earth was destroyed many years ago and only one girl survived, à la Superman.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Violence & Scariness in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
In a scene where the kids are all cartoon characters, Bethany says, "Turn us back already, would you? The last thing I want to do is figure out how to go to the bathroom like this." A few references to butts and wondering aloud why fictional characters are never seen going to the bathroom.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Language in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
Parents Need to Know
Parents need to know that The Stolen Chapters is the second installment in James Riley's wacky Story Thieves series, featuring tweens jumping in and out of fictional book worlds and getting into all kinds of trouble. In this case, it's the world of mystery novels, as a descendant of Sherlock Holmes seeks revenge on our heroes, a character finds herself about to be murdered in a locked room, another is framed for burning down his mother's library, and a cop's daughter chooses a life of crime. "Fictional" and "real" worlds collide, characters spend a lot of time worrying about being products of someone else's imagination, and the narrator wonders whether the author actually exists. Several kids have lost a parent, and one's determination to find her father is important to the plot. A cliffhanger ending sets up Book 3, Secret Origins.
Is It Any Good?
This sequel's ever-surprising plot, wacky-and-a-bit-dark humor, and relatable worries of the tween characters will please Book 1's fans and recruit lots of new ones for the Story Thieves series. On any page of this wild tale you'll find alien planets, cartoon criminals, a deranged descendant of Sherlock Holmes, or an angsty discussion about being the product of someone else's imagination. And that's just the beginning, as author "James Riley" tries to stir up confusion about whether he exists, confronts kids with their fictional selves, and more. Not every reader is going to have the patience for The Stolen Chapters' sheer looniness, but those who do will be thoroughly entertained.
Did we miss something on diversity?
Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.