MLB The Show 22
By Jeff Haynes,
Common Sense Media Reviewer
Common Sense Media Reviewers
New chapter for baseball series safely gets on base.

A Lot or a Little?
What you will—and won't—find in this game.
Where to Play
Videos and Photos
MLB The Show 22
Community Reviews
Based on 1 parent review
Music can sometimes be explicit
Report this review
What’s It About?
MLB THE SHOW 22 is the latest installment in the long running baseball franchise, and this year, it's calling up another console to the major leagues by expanding to the Nintendo Switch for the first time. That now means that players that own any game console can now play Sony's baseball simulation, and thanks to the cross-play and cross-save functionality, gamers can constantly make progress wherever they go, as long as they create accounts and sync up their progress through the cloud. That means playing on a console at home, but having the opportunity to keep playing on the go, as long as your Switch has a Wi-Fi signal to upload or download your saved files to and from the cloud (and you've got subscriptions to online services for each platform). While the three overarching playstyles of Casual, Simulation, and Competitive return, they're bolstered by two additional difficulty levels, (amateur and minors) providing a wider range of challenges to fit your baseball skills. Additionally, in this year's game, the Diamond Dynasty mode has been revamped with new programs to help you build out your dream team. That includes more than 160 legends like Ken Griffey Jr., Kirk Gibson, and Mike Mussina to take the field under your control. There's also a new mode called Mini-Seasons, where you'll pit your team against a condensed league of seven fictional teams to see if you'll be able to win a championship. Past that, the mission structure has been revamped for team progress, so simply playing games will boost your progress towards unlocking packs, stadiums, and gear. User created players can be added to a Diamond Dynasty team as well as in the Road to the Show career mode, where players will try to bring their athlete from the minors to a spot on a Major League team roster. This time around, you'll have the option to create up to ten players with different positions, ranging from pitchers to position players or two-way players, with the story and commentary reflecting your choices. Road to the Show also has new in-game cutscenes with legends and MLB sports analysts responding to the progress of your player, making the story seem more tailored to your athlete's journey to the pros. Finally, this year features a new commentary team with Jon "Boog" Sciambi and Chris Singleton taking over the booth to call the on-field action. Batter up, because it's baseball season, and it's time to head to The Show.
Is It Any Good?
This year's installment may not swing for the fences, but its expansion to Nintendo Switch and refinement of gameplay lets it comfortably take extra bases. Technically, MLB The Show 22 features a few refinements to gameplay modes that previously existed in last year's play, sanding off rough edges and adding a few new items here and there. But it completes its expansion from Sony's systems by bringing in Nintendo's handheld to the fold, while allowing cross-platform play, cross-platform progression, and cross saves. It's incredible to put In work on building your squad in Diamond Dynasty or grinding through a game series for Road to the Show on a console, then transfer those files to the cloud and take them with you on the go without losing any progress. The process does have hiccups when you're setting things up to be aware of – You have to create an account on the game's website, indicate a primary system you'll play on, and sync any other device after the fact, or any substantive progress that you've made playing the game will appear to be erased. (Fortunately, it isn't, but the server confusion with the process can seem as though your work is gone until you get things straightened out). Another item that new Switch players will want to be aware of is that the Pro Controller really is the best way to play The Show, simply because Joy-Con thumbsticks aren't great. Between the precise movements required for Pinpoint Pitching, and the sharp movements for stealing bases, Joy-Con's just don't feel sturdy enough to stand up to the stress of the March to October, much less a few of the Mini-Season matchups. It's also unfortunate that Switch owners won't have access to the Stadium Creator feature, but maybe that can be added in for next year's version.
Speaking of the Mini-Seasons, this is an excellent addition to the Diamond Dynasty mode as you take your squad against seven other teams in an abbreviated 28 game (three-inning per game) season before leading into the playoffs and eventual championship. That's not to cast doubt on the Conquest or Showdown portions of this mode – they're still included and still fun, but Mini-Seasons feels like a great way of pitting your squad against rival teams, and also getting a sense of where you need to build or enhance your team. While the energy for your pitchers seems to drain at an impossibly fast rate in this mode, that's tolerable when you consider how quick the gameplay happens to be. It also factors into the refocused element of programs and progress, where virtually everything you do, from homeruns and strikeouts to simply getting on base, winds up completing goals and earning you players, packs, or credits for the in-game store. Past this, Road to the Show has chosen to not force players into selecting a two-way player (which is more of a generational rarity than a standard talent anyway). What's nice is that the video clips from Ben Gellman and other MLB connected commentators for this year don't feel as canned as last year's sessions. Instead, they feel more connected to actions you've done and progress you've made climbing from the minors to the major leagues. And while there's a new commentary crew, there's nothing fantastic or awful about the team of Sciambi and Singleton. If you're a fan of overexcited commentary, you might miss the trio of Vasgergian, DeRosa, and Plesac, but Boog and Chris do a solid job. You'll still hear repeated dialogue a bit more than you'd like, but it's a more laid back, conversational tone in their delivery. Overall, MLB The Show 22 doesn't reinvent the baseball game, but it never had to. It simply needed to refine what was there from last year and make the pastime more enjoyable, which it easily manages to accomplish with its improved play.
Talk to Your Kids About ...
Families can talk about consumerism. Do you feel pressured to spend your money on in-game packs in MLB The Show 22 to give your created baseball teams or players an advantage, or would you rather earn new players by playing multiple baseball games? Do you feel like the option to take your game progress with you for cross-platform play is worth buying the game twice?
Does playing this game make you interested in playing or watching baseball in real life? What about learning about classic moments of the sport? Do some of the modes get you interested in fantasy baseball drafts? Could it make someone who isn't a fan of baseball become a fan of the sport?
Game Details
- Platforms: Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X/S, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4
- Pricing structure: Paid ($69.99-$99.99, depending on edition)
- Available online?: Available online
- Publisher: Sony Interactive Entertainment
- Release date: April 1, 2022
- Genre: Sports
- Topics: Sports and Martial Arts
- ESRB rating: E for No Descriptions
- Last updated: April 21, 2022
Did we miss something on diversity?
Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.
Suggest an Update
Where to Play
Our Editors Recommend
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.
See how we rate