Pirates of the Burning Sea

Game review by
Jeremy Gieske, Common Sense Media
Pirates of the Burning Sea Game Poster Image
Slightly flawed, huge online RPG for pirate fans.

Parents say

age 11+
Based on 2 reviews

Kids say

age 11+
Based on 1 review

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this game.

Positive messages

Teamwork is an important part of many missions, both with non-player characters and other human characters. Some missions have a darker side to them, such as being paid to kill others for revenge.

Violence

Almost all quests involve violence of some sort -- either on land or at sea. During sword fights, blood is easily visible -- spraying from wounded opponents.

Sex

Although the player has little involvement with them, brothels can be found in some of the cities. Minor innuendo with a small number of non-player characters--particularly in the pubs.

Language

Occasional "damn," "bastard," and "hell" from bartenders, and other non-player characters. Although filters exist, other human players in the game have a knack for finding new ways of expressing themselves using vulgar/suggestive terminology.

Consumerism
Drinking, drugs & smoking

Players can purchase and ingest alcohol for themselves and their crews. Players frequently visit local pubs to get quests or talk to other players. Drunk non-player characters are shown in the pub. Some characters can be seen smoking pipes/using tobacco.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that the game has bloody swordfights, gunfights at sea, some mild cursing, and a fair amount of alcohol references. However, the biggest concern is the same as with any other online game of this genre -- it's easy to get "hooked" since the game is, in essence, designed to never be truly beaten. This in turn, keeps players paying the monthly subscription fee to play. In addition, as an online game, it is difficult for the developers to completely control the environment, so it is possible to run into more adult language or topics on the in-game message boards. Common Sense Media does not recommend online play for kids under age 12.

User Reviews

Parent of a 9 and 17 year old Written byMCOLWELL February 1, 2011

A little violent for preteens.

History lesson disguised as a game.
Parent of a 10 year old Written bySteveee March 6, 2011

It is a good game for kids to and over

It is a great game with spots where you can learn about the history of pirates. However, there is a lot of violence.
Kid, 12 years old November 30, 2011

good

good for twees

What's it about?

PIRATES OF THE BURNING SEA moves away from the traditional online role-playing fare of elves and goblins, instead letting players fight on the high seas and port towns of the Caribbean for riches and power. Players choose to be either a rascally pirate fighting for their own acclaim or as a British, Spanish, or French captain fighting for the glory of their country. As one of the nationalists, players can also choose whether to center their strategy on skillful trade as a merchant or focus on military strength as a naval captain or privateer.

Is it any good?

Overall, the game sparkles like a freshly opened treasure chest. With a huge map of the Caribbean before them, the game offers a nearly endless supply of well-designed quests. Missions are diverse, ranging from crossing swords with local pirate gangs, to running rum into a blockaded city. An overarching goal has players working together as a nation to conquer other nation's ports for control of important resources. The game really shines when players take to the sea. The game goes far beyond simply having the biggest ship/most guns to win. In fact, through the skillful use of sailing techniques and strategy, lower-level players can play and compete with higher-level players -- a unique opportunity in a game of this genre.

The game isn't all diamonds and rubies though -- a few flaws tarnish an otherwise well-done game. The sword fights are far inferior to the action at sea. Fewer options for strategy, and a lot of similarity between one battle to the next makes the land sequences far less interesting. Boarding an opponent's ship is particularly frustrating, since targeting a particular enemy such as the captain is a real challenge. Another major fault of the game is the lack of instruction for the more challenging aspects of the game. In particular, players are left to figure out the fairly complex economic system of manufacturing and trading goods after only a very brief tutorial. Players short on patience may grow tired of trying to figure out the game before they start to uncover some of its true treasures.

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about where they get their main enjoymentfrom when playing video games. Is it beating the game? Is it in growing and developing their characters? Is it finding new stories and being part of the story as it plays out? In a game as large as this one, do any of those motivations change?

Game details

Our editors recommend

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality and learning potential.

Learn how we rate