An Apology to Elephants
Common Sense Media says
What parents need to know
Parents Need to Know
Parents need to know that the graphic and upsetting images of abuse and death in An Apology to Elephants are not for the faint of heart. Viewers watch trainers coerce cooperation from the animals by pulling their limbs into place with ropes and by using tools that inflict pain, but the message really hits home when you see how those practices translate to the seemingly innocent cues given to the animals in the circus ring. There's footage of poachers shooting and butchering elephants, and another scene shows one being electrocuted. Animal -rights activists make a case for boycotting circuses and zoos in light of harmful practices, but the movie also dedicates time to celebrating two American projects that have changed their tactics and now advocate for more humane treatment of all captive elephants. This isn't a movie you want your young kids to see, but it is an eye-opening (if only one-sided) commentary on a longstanding animal-rights issue.
What's the story?
AN APOLOGY TO ELEPHANTS is a documentary that takes a hard look at the historically abusive treatment of elephants by humans through enslavement, hard labor, poaching, and painful training practices for our entertainment. Narrated by Lily Tomlin, the movie takes viewers from the serene natural habitats of the Asian and African elephants to the cement cells and chained restraints most captive animals endure in zoos and circuses around the world. Experts explore the discrepancies between traditional training programs marked by force, pain, and fear, and new efforts to relate more humanely to elephants in captivity, while simultaneously making a case for the protection of these animals now threatened by extinction.
Is it any good?
This affecting story is difficult to watch, what with painful scenes of humans beating, prodding, and otherwise coercing these gentle giants into submission. The video clips were chosen to appeal to your sense of decency, and you'll likely walk away feeling sick over abuse you may or may not have known existed. You'll learn about elephants torn from their mothers, kept in small crates, and subjected to painful practices that force them into unnatural behavior. Animal experts weigh in on the need to protect elephants in the wild, calling up their importance to their local ecologies and their vulnerability to poaching practices. Ultimately, if it makes you think twice about buying a ticket to the circus or visiting the elephant exhibit at your local zoo, then it's achieved its goal.
But the story doesn't focus solely on the bad. It also spotlights two projects -- The Oakland Zoo and the Performing Animals Welfare Society -- that are going against the tide, catering to elephants' natural instincts and needs, and reaping the benefits of the animals' improved emotional health. These segments are no less moving than are the accounts of abuse, but they do offer some hope for the future of elephants both in the wild and in captivity. The bottom line? This important story is well worth watching, but the nature of the content is too much for all but the sturdiest teens and adults.
Families can talk about...
Families can talk about this documentary's intent. What did the creators want you to know? Do they hope to change your behavior in any way? If so, did they accomplish that goal?
What is the meaning of "propaganda"? Does this movie meet the requirements for that? Do films like this one have any obligation to tell the other side of the story? Could anything be said to defend the acts you see in this film?
Watch other documentaries on issues that are important to your family, and discuss their effects on your impressions of those issues. Did they change your stance? Were their points valid? What might you have added to the information they included?