Parents' Guide to Big Mack: Gangsters and Gold

Movie NR 2023 90 minutes
Big Mack: Gangsters and Gold movie

Common Sense Media Review

Barbara Shulgasser-Parker By Barbara Shulgasser-Parker , based on child development research. How do we rate?

age 14+

Criminal is put away for the wrong crime; language, smoking.

Parents Need to Know

Why Age 14+?

Any Positive Content?

Parent and Kid Reviews

What's the Story?

In 1991, Donald Stellwag was arrested for robbing a bank. The crime was captured on cameras and the robber looked a great deal like Stellwag, both tall and "strikingly obese," in the words of one witness. As BIG MACK: GANGSTERS AND GOLD recounts, at trial, an expert witness who examined photographs declared that Stellwag's ear and the robber's were identical. That clinched the guilty verdict and a nine-year sentence. Stellwag, who is bedridden and says he has a brain tumor, from his horizontal position informs us that the story he's about to tell is "hypothetical," and that's typical of what we learn is part of his playful and possibly sociopathic personality. When the actual bank robber is caught nine years later, Stellwag spends a decade on TV talk shows riding the miscarriage of justice narrative and making money as a walking product-placement billboard for a brewery. He sues the expert witness and wins. But while this neat package of an-innocent-man-wronged holds true for the bank robbery, new accusations arise, as does a long history of wrongdoing the filmmaker fails to reveal until halfway through the film. Is Stellwag, an expert in jewelry and gold it turns out, the homebound mastermind behind a clever gold heist pulled off by a Kurdish rap star and his gangster friends? They say yes in court, but Stellwag's health rules out another prison term, so he remains free, a rascal gleeful at having bested the system. By the end, even his friends call him a liar, and everything he's said is, retrospectively, cast in a questionable light.

Is It Any Good?

Our review:
Parents say : Not yet rated
Kids say : Not yet rated

This documentary somewhat misleads viewers who aren't already familiar with this story. Important information about Stellwag's behavior and character in Big Mack: Gangsters and Gold is withheld far too long, obscuring the story's inherent dramatic irony -- a career criminal finally serves a long term in prison, but for a crime he didn't commit. By omission, early sequences of the film are misleading. Stellwag may not have committed the crime he spent nine years in prison for, but he was no innocent law-abiding citizen.

In the same confusing manner, it's a good halfway through the film before we hear anything about either the "gangsters" or "gold" of the title, and not until near the end of the film do we learn who "Big Mack" is. It's as if the film was dropped and broke apart, then put back together in the worst possible order.

Talk to Your Kids About ...

  • Families can talk about the way the film presents the central figure. Do you think withholding important information about him adds to or detracts from the success and interest of the film?

  • How do you think documentary-makers decide where to start their stories? Where would you have started this story?

  • How do the filmmakers want us to view Donald? What are some of the ways the film leads us to certain conclusions and not others?

Movie Details

  • On DVD or streaming : March 30, 2023
  • Director : Fabienne Hurst
  • Studio : Netflix
  • Genre : Documentary
  • Run time : 90 minutes
  • MPAA rating : NR
  • Last updated : May 13, 2023

Did we miss something on diversity?

Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by

Big Mack: Gangsters and Gold movie

What to Watch Next

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate