A lot or a little?
The parents' guide to what's in this movie.
What parents need to know
Parents need to know that Circus of Books, a frank 2020 documentary, traces the 30-year life of a hardcore gay pornographic book store and movie distributorship run by an unlikely duo. The owners are a middle-class Jewish couple raising three children, none of whom had a clue what their parents did for a living. The daughter, Rachel Mason, directs the film, which also investigates the irony in her older brother's coming out as a gay man, a development the dad supports but which forced the more religious mom to question her inability to accept. How she ultimately came to embrace her son and help other parents do the same is the touching secondary story of this uplifting if somewhat graphic and sexually-candid movie. Expect to see walls covered with magazines and DVD covers depicting erect penises and male couples looking aroused. Language includes "s--t," "c--k rings," "rod," "penetration," "d--ks," "t-ts," "bang," "ass," "anal lube," "bitch," "well-hung," "rimming," "blowjob," and "suck."
What's the story?
CIRCUS OF BOOKS is a family story, told by Rachel Mason, daughter of Karen and Barry, a middle-class Jewish couple that stumbled into the hardcore pornography (publications and DVDs) business and ran it for 30 years. The secret of how they made a living was kept from their three children, family, friends, and the conservative synagogue Karen attended. The store is referred to as a "gourmet purveyor of sexual material and a safe place to find other gays" during the decades long before anti-discrimination laws and legalized gay marriage, back when, as one interviewee puts it, "being a homo was unspeakable." The Masons faced federal charges for obscenity, but the change from a Republican to a Democratic administration saved them. Intercut into the bookstore's story is the tragedy of the AIDS epidemic and losses of employees, colleagues, and friends. Hustler magazine publisher Larry Flynt remembers the Masons as people everyone wanted to do business with because they were honest. Late in the film, Karen's struggle to accept that her oldest son is gay becomes the focus and the story's emotional center.
Is it any good?
Overall the film is a moving documentary, a historical tidbit about a no-longer viable business. But that story isn't half as interesting as the family drama of tolerance, and a quick re-edit would fix that problem. While the oddity of a seemingly conventional couple running an unconventional business is interesting, on its own that story offers only minimal emotional impact.
Even when Karen's failure to accept her gay son is finally addressed, Circus of Books leaves us to view her as a villain for far too long, giving no early hint of her eventual extraordinary quest to find a way to erase her prejudices. Karen Mason, the religious Jew who couldn't accept her gay son because her religion dictated that gayness was an abomination, becomes a leader in PFLAG, Parents and Friend of Lesbians and Gays. Had we been offered a hint of that at the beginning of the film, the story of the store would have been imbued with nuance and emotion otherwise absent.
Talk to your kids about ...
Families can talk about why it was difficult for Karen, owner of a gay porn bookstore, to accept her oldest son's gayness. Does her negative reaction seem surprising?
Does your view of Karen change when you learn that she became active in the gay community in order to embrace her gay son?
What does Circus of Books have to say about the importance of accepting and embracing difference?
Our editors recommend
For kids who love LGBTQ titles
Top advice and articles
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.
Streaming options powered by JustWatch