We think this movie stands out for:
A lot or a little?
The parents' guide to what's in this movie.
What parents need to know
Parents need to know that Healing from Hate: Battle for the Soul of a Nation is a documentary about the rise of the alt-right movement and Life After Hate, a group that tries to help members of White supremacy groups exit them. Many crimes and terrorist acts connected to hate groups are described, some graphically. Disturbing images include a firefighter carrying a dead, bloody child and a plane hitting one of the Twin Towers on 9/11. There's also footage of protests, with people yelling, shoving, and hitting each other; a black-and-white photo of Black people hanging from trees in a KKK lynching; and news footage about mass shootings in Wisconsin, South Carolina, New Zealand, and more. Photography shows skinheads giving Nazi salutes, many racist tattoos, Confederate flags, swastika tattoos, and graffiti. Former hate group members are honest about their past violence and crimes but don't describe the actions in detail -- though viewers will hear a repeated story about a murderer who brags about killing an Ethiopian man, Mulugeta Seraw, with a baseball bat. They're clearly remorseful and are trying to do better. The film underlines the connection between childhood trauma and the appeal of hate groups, as well as the role of drugs and alcohol (a man whose hands are damaged from injecting methamphetamine is shown). Cursing isn't frequent but includes "f--k" and "s--t," as well as some racist language. Ultimately, messages of compassion and teamwork dominate: Life After Hate works earnestly and at length to understand those who hate, and its members hope to use empathy to convince White supremacists to adopt new views.
What's the story?
HEALING FROM HATE: BATTLE FOR THE SOUL OF A NATION is a documentary directed by Peter Hutchison that turns its lens squarely on the history of White supremacy in America. It investigates why the movement has gained fresh currency during the Trump administration, as well as how former White supremacists left the movement and now help others who want to do the same, in the form of groups like the centrally featured Life After Hate. With interviews with anti-hate leaders such as Frank Meeink, the former neo-Nazi whose life was one of the inspirations behind American History X, Jason Downard of the pro-tolerance group Freefromhate, sociologist and anti-hate pundit Dr. Michael Kimmel, and others, the film explores how and why the alt-right movement has sprung up -- and how former haters are helping others to leave it behind.
Is it any good?
Thoughtful and compelling, this documentary makes a powerful case for compassion and empathy as the best tools to lead members of hate groups away from their extremist ideologies. It's a message that's easy for the soft-hearted to swallow, but it doesn't make this film a comforting watch. The combination of Albian Gagica's spiky, swastika-laden graphics, Anthony Karen's photographs of angry young White men, and Malcolm Francis' strident electronica score gives viewers a sort of creeping unease that's exacerbated by shots of modern-day headlines and protests that explicitly underline the jump that hate has taken in America during the Trump administration.
Healing from Hate's exploration of mass shootings and murders in Charlottesville, Pittsburgh, El Paso, and Christchurch, New Zealand, also serves to illustrate another serious point: The alt-right movement is one with a real body count. How did we get here? As Dr. Michael Kimmel, author of Healing from Hate: How Young Men Get Into -- and Out of -- Violent Extremism, points out, the internet has vastly escalated the spread of hateful information, while at the same time, its anonymity allows people to hatch their beliefs in safe secrecy. Then, there's the emotional pull: "They feel dispossessed, as if something's been taken from them," says Kimmel, while an ex-skinhead sums it up like this: "When you come up from nothing and you got nothing, a little bit of power feels so good." By illustrating how people can turn from hate to acceptance, Healing from Hate makes it clear that support, community, and tolerance have their own power, one that changes minds -- and lives.
Talk to your kids about ...
Families can talk about the history of hate groups in America and how they've changed over time. How are the KKK and alt-right groups similar? How are they different? Has the cycle of violence and reprisal, protests and counter-protests changed over time? If so, how? Why are groups that demonize some kind of "other" perpetually appealing to some?
Talk about the references to and images of violence in Healing from Hate. How did that affect you? What's shown and not shown? How does it compare to the kind of violence you see in action movies? Which has more impact? Why?
What role does the internet play in enabling the alt-right, according to the film? How do people find hate online?
Our editors recommend
For kids who love documentaries and making a difference
Find more movies that help kids build character.
Top advice and articles
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.
Streaming options powered by JustWatch