Race to Nowhere
What parents need to know
Parents Need to Know
Parents need to know that this documentary about the educational system -- like Waiting for "Superman" -- examines a subject that may hit very close to home: Is our culture placing too much pressure on young people to be uber-successful, pushing them to the edge of exhaustion or worse? The question is difficult because it forces us to examine our own preconceptions about parenting and education. Nevertheless, this is a worthwhile watch for both parents and older kids and could launch great family discussions about expectations and school pressure.
What's the story?
Are our high schoolers overstressed and overtaxed? In RACE TO NOWHERE, filmmakers Vicki Abeles and Jessica Congdon speak to educators, parents, tweens, and teens about the pressures they face academically and emotionally, and the physical toll these expectations exact. What results is a picture of a fractured educational system that pushes kids to become successful -- but at a cost.
Is it any good?
If feeling queasy because of what you’ve watched is a measure of how good a documentary is, then Race to Nowhere definitely succeeds. If you have a high-schooler, the film will either have you second-guessing their academic and extracurricular load or patting yourself on the back if you’ve been careful about making sure that they’re not overwhelmed. The film will certainly stir up loads of examination and debate, and rightfully so. Told in classic documentary style, it's pretty effective.
Still, there are some quibbles: Though East Coasters and Floridians are included in the mix of sources, the film is peopled heavily by Californians. Which would be fine, except the movie is questioning the nation’s obsession with academic success; a more varied sample might have made a better case. And it’s not clear whether the problems described in the movie are endemic in both public and private schools, and whether that makes a difference. Still, it’s a compelling film that will leave both teens and parents of high school students thinking.
Families can talk about...
Families can talk about what high school and college have become in this country. Is it really a “race to nowhere"? Why?
What is this movie trying to say about the current state of education? Can the damage be undone? What resources do educators need to do their jobs more effectively?
Does this documentary approach its subject matter objectively, or does it have an opinion? Is it OK for a documentary to take a specific stance on the topic it's covering?