What parents need to know
Parents Need to Know
Parents need to know that this documentary explores the challenging lives of incredibly poor people who work in an enormous bleak, smelly landfill outside of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The poverty and hopelessness of the setting are successfully countered, however, by the movie's in-depth portrayal of some of the landfill's residents and some extraordinary people who are committed to helping them. What could be depressing, disturbing, or simply sad (especially for kids not mature enough to discern the complexities of such a situation), is, in fact, uplifting, triumphant, and encourages people to look beneath the surface of victimhood to see the humanity and dignity that lives there. There are references to other options for the landfill workers, which include prostitution, drug dealing and other criminal activity.
What's the story?
Vik Muniz, a renowned artist living in New York, journeys to Brazil to "give something back" to the country of his birth and impoverished childhood. He chooses to bring his art to Jardim Gramacho, the world's largest landfill just outside of Rio de Janeiro, in which thousands of workers spend their days (and years) scavenging through Rio's trash for recyclables which they sell to eke out a meager living. Their homes are lean-tos and shacks; the air they breathe is filled with pollutants; the smell is horrific; the work is exhausting and difficult. To Vik's utter amazement, the people he meets are wiser and more resilient than he could have imagined. What began as a vague, altruistic idea becomes a meaningful, transforming life event for Vik, his team, and the residents of "The Garbage Garden."
Is it any good?
This film is heartbreaking, enlightening, and inspiring all at once. Lucy Walker, the director of this documentary, nominated for a 2010 Academy Award, must consider herself a very lucky filmmaker. Just as Vik Muniz couldn't possibly have known what he would find in his year-long journey to a trash dump, Walker's commitment to make a film about it must have been based simply on trust and instinct. What they found -- the astonishing people and community they encountered -- and what Muniz and his fellow artists were able to accomplish is miraculous.
This movie is one to be shared and will provoke thought and conversation about art, poverty, and an individual's ability to make a difference.
Families can talk about...
Families can talk about the ability of one man, in this case Vik Muniz, to make a difference in the world. What elements were included in the movie to make Muniz appear like a hero? What do you think was left out? Are there opportunities in your community to "give something back"?
What is the message this movie sends about art and creativity? Some think the arts are superfluous -- does this movie make a compelling argument otherwise?
What issues did Muniz have to consider when deciding whether or not to do this project? What do you think happened to the artist and the people after filming ended? Did Muniz make responsible decisions in regard to the pickers?
What messages does the movie send about the environment and our impact on it?