American Vandal

TV review by
Joyce Slaton, Common Sense Media
American Vandal TV Poster Image
Language, high school sex jokes in wry true-crime satire.

Parents say

age 15+
Based on 3 reviews

Kids say

age 13+
Based on 4 reviews

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this TV show.

Positive Messages

Satire is by its nature positive, as it encourages viewers to think critically about what they see and hear. This show skewers the conventions of true-crime shows and may help teens understand that there's a style such shows take on, which may make them wonder why. The show's first season also evolved into a sly critique of social media and the way teens are portrayed cinematically, themes that continue and are amplified in the second season (and may spark interesting conversations with teens). 

Positive Role Models & Representations

Main character Dylan is described repeatedly by schoolmates as an "idiot," a "f---ing idiot," a "burnout," a "loser." Even his girlfriend thinks he's too dumb to commit fraud -- and he agrees! However, other scenes show Dylan in a positive light, professing his deep love for his girlfriend, being honest even when it'll get him in trouble. Peter is on-screen less, but we see his intrepid reporting and hard work as he investigates the crime. In the show's second season, central figure Kevin is presented as a pretentious snot who is revealed to have ginned up a protective fake personality after being picked on at school. 

Violence

The "crime" in this true-crime show is a row of graffiti penises on teacher's cars in a high school parking lot. The untoward event the second season spotlights is messier: a "brownout" caused by laxative-spiked lemonade in the school cafeteria. The lo-fi visual representations of the event make them less gross, but we still see many students with brown smears and puddles around them. 

Sex

References to sex are frequent and sophomorically vulgar: images of spray-painted and drawn penises are shown frequently; a boy mimes having sex with a piñata; a boy claims he got a "hand job" from another high school girl; body parts (female) are ogled and discussed by male characters. A graphic joke involves "pooping" into someone else's body. 

Language

Cursing and off-color language includes "s--t," "f--k" and "f---ing," "bitch," "damn," "d--ks" (said frequently and repeatedly), "butthole," "pooping," "boobs," "balls," "fart."

Consumerism
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Dylan smokes a joint; his friends pass around a bong, inhale, cough. The friends seem spacey, and schoolmates call Dylan a "burnout" and a "loser." 

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that American Vandal is a comedy series that satirizes true-crime shows, social media, and the way teens use it. While most such shows are built around murders, the crime in this case is vandalism: penises are spray-painted on a row of teacher's cars (the second season focuses on school cafeteria lemonade spiked with laxatives). Graffiti'd penises (and fecal puddles) are shown over and over again and discussed at length, in silly ways, of course. There are other vulgar jokes, such as when a boy pretends to have sex with a piñata and another claims he was masturbated by a girl at school. The same boy smokes a joint, and a group of his friends -- who are called "burnouts" by kids at school -- pass a bong around a living room, smoking and coughing. Cursing and off-color language includes "s--t," "f--k," "bitch," "damn," "d--ks" (said many times). Despite the language and vulgarity, this series is pretty sharp, sending up true-crime reportage by imitating it, and spoofing teens and their social media use by using digital trails as a potent investigatory aid. Parents may want to watch along with kids to point out what's being made fun of and why. 

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say
Parent of a 15 year old Written byJordyn B. September 21, 2017
Adult Written byprincesscupcake683 September 22, 2017

Very well done- but too mature for young kids.

I will be 19 in a few weeks. I watched this show on WatchHDonline because I don't have Netflix and I really enjoyed it. I liked the realistic story line an... Continue reading
Teen, 14 years old Written byperson1111 October 7, 2017

Fun show to binge watch

good show. Engourges kids to dig deeper and not trust everyone. Good pardody of true crime shows. A few sex jokes and swearing.
Teen, 16 years old Written byUnexpectedVirtue January 8, 2018

Good for high schoolers

American Vandal is extremely well-done and thought provoking, and high schoolers especially will benefit from the witty and relatable dialogue of the teenagers.... Continue reading

What's the story?

A heinous crime has rocked the quiet California high school of Hanover: Who stole into the parking lot and spray-painted a row of teacher's cars with phallic symbols, causing $100,000 worth of damage? AMERICAN VANDAL digs into whodunit. Was it high school senior Dylan (Jimmy Tatro), the ne'er-do-well known for drawing penises around the school, and who's already been expelled for the crime? Was it Alex Trimbolo (Calum Worthy), the honor student who says he witnessed Dylan in the act? As Dylan's Hanover High Morning Show colleague Peter Maldonado (Tyler Alvarez) follows the case, the more he learns, the less he's sure of. In its second season, American Vandal's key sleuths Peter and Sam (Griffin Gluck) focus on a new school -- a private Catholic academy -- and takes on a new misdemeanor (the "brownout" caused by laxative-spiked school cafeteria lemonade) and possibly unfairly accused miscreant, Kevin McClain (Travis Tope). 

Is it any good?

Clever, deadpan, and instantly quotable, this mockumentary pries some knowing laughter from a genre that typically takes itself very seriously: true crime. American Vandal starts in on the ironic imitation right in the credits, with (school paper!) headlines about the graffiti crime dissolving into grimly lit photos of the crime scene and portentous yearbook photos. There are talking-head interviews and close-ups of ominous-looking official paperwork; there are cork boards with string connecting photos and clues. And there is always the fact that the crime in question is a row of spray-painted penises.

Dylan, too, makes an appealing lead, his oafishness lightened a bit by scenes in which he talks about how much he loves his girlfriend and how disappointed he is that his life-goal plans (going to college with his girlfriend, opening up a surf shop) are disrupted by his expulsion. Before long, the boy we hear repeatedly described as a "f--king idiot" and "the stupidest kid I ever met" emerges as something of a henpecked hero: He might have spray-painted the penises, because it's a laugh. But he didn't. And so we, along with Dylan, and Peter, and everyone else, slowly pick through the clues to find out who did. And why. Or maybe not. Because what does it matter what the answer is, when the search for it is so much fun? Update: In the show's second season, Peter and Sam investigate a new, more bodily function-related crime at a different school after the mockumentary the duo supposedly made in the first season became a viral sensation. This adds another layer of satire and complexity to the surprisingly clever comedy, which makes plenty of points about gossip, digital life, the reputation one makes for oneself -- and the one that others pin on you. 

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about satire. What type of series is American Vandal making fun of? Would this show be as funny if it, like typical true-crime shows, centered on murder? 

  • Why is it so difficult to figure out who committed crimes, both in this silly satire and in real life? What do you think about the process traditionally used to convict people?

TV details

For kids who love satire

Our editors recommend

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality and learning potential.

Learn how we rate