The Alienist

TV review by
Joyce Slaton, Common Sense Media
The Alienist TV Poster Image
Dark, very bloody murder mystery based on best-seller.
Parents recommend

Parents say

age 17+
Based on 8 reviews

Kids say

No reviews yetAdd your rating

A lot or a little?

The parents' guide to what's in this TV show.

Positive Messages

Dark drama revolves around murders of young male prostitutes; investigation involves political figures, the clergy, and law enforcement. A young murder victim is described as a "degenerate who dresses himself as a girl for the pleasure of men" and is called "it" by a man clearly painted as a villain. But our sympathies are with the group of investigators trying to stop the murderer; they're depicted as mostly noble and intrepid. 

Positive Role Models & Representations

John is a heroic character with sympathy for victims, yet he has a long-standing relationship with a sex worker he pays for companionship. Laszlo is socially awkward and blunt, but is kind and helpful to the disturbed children and adults he works with. Sarah is perhaps the most heroic of the main characters, a strong-minded and brave woman who's the first woman working for the New York police. 

 

Violence

Intense and bloody: The body of a (10-year-old?) boy is shown repeatedly and at length. We see patches of missing flesh with bone protruding, a slashed throat, a severed hand; camera zooms in on two dark eyeless sockets. The killer cooking that eye, along with the kidneys; he lets his pet cat lap at a bit of bloody tissue. Murder victim's injuries described at length: genitals removed, chest and abdomen "ripped open." A man with advanced syphilis has large disfiguring chancres on his face, is shown beating his head against a brick wall until blood pours down his face. Drama revolves around young male prostitutes -- expect to see customers looking them over, picking them up, touching them in a sexually threatening manner (and much worse for murder victims). 

Sex

A main character has a relationship with a sex worker in a bordello; we see him undressing her, her naked backside visible in a mirror, and then her on top of him having sex with moaning and thrusting. She is visible fully nude from the side, but her breasts are obscured; her male partner is completely dressed. Afterward, he drops a coin into her hand. Scenes are set at brothels with male and female sex workers; expect to hear language connected with sex work, including vintage phrases: a "boy whore," a "molly house full of rich pansies." 

 

Language

Cursing is period-correct, with the occasional "hell" or "damn" and lots of insulting language leveled at ethnic and racial minorities and sex workers. A murder victim is referred to as a "boy whore," a "degenerate," and a "little piece of dago trash." Other language may send users scrambling to look up vintage slang: "panderer," "lush," "billy noodle," "mutton shunter." 

Consumerism
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking

Characters drink alcohol at parties and dinners; Sarah smokes cigarettes.

What parents need to know

Parents need to know that The Alienist is a dark, violent drama based on Caleb Carr's best-selling 1994 novel. Set in 19th-century New York, it revolves around a series of gruesome child murders. Viewers see the body of a bloody, mutilated young boy at length; it's said that his genitals were severed, and his killer is shown cooking the victim's body parts. Young male prostitutes are shown looking for customers; men talk to them and push them in a sexually aggressive manner. A trip through the infamous Bellevue asylum shows mentally disturbed people screaming, fighting, being held down/restrained by chains, and cowering in jail cells. A main character has a relationship with a prostitute at a brothel. They have sex; moaning and thrusting are heard, and she's shown fully nude from the side (her breasts are covered). Cursing is generally period-mild ("damn," "hell"), but there's lots of insulting language about sex workers and racial/ethnic/sexual minorities: "whore," "dago," "degenerate," "pansies." Adults drink at parties and dinners; a main character smokes cigarettes. Daniel Bruhl, Luke Evans, and Dakota Fanning co-star.

User Reviews

  • Parents say
  • Kids say
Adult Written bySara C. January 29, 2018

Filthy

Please don’t subject you or your children to this garbage. There are scenes o f dead, bloody boys, full nudity etc.. If there was an option to advise no one to... Continue reading
Parent Written byAnu A. February 17, 2018

A good thriller but strictly adults only

This show has lots of nudity, Gore, blood, severed parts and totally unsuitable for family watch. But this show is a quality murder mystery series set in late 1... Continue reading

There aren't any reviews yet. Be the first to review this title.

What's the story?

Based on Caleb Carr's same-named 1994 book of the same name, THE ALIENIST picks up in New York's Gilded Age, as the body of a young murdered, mutilated boy is found -- which brilliant doctor and investigator Laszlo Kreizler (Daniel Bruhl) connects to an earlier murder of two young children. Knowing that Kreizler is an "alienist" (he treats mentally disturbed patients who are "alienated" from their "true natures"), newly appointed police commissioner Theodore Roosevelt (Brian Geraghty) taps Kreizler and his friend and newspaper illustrator John Moore (Luke Evans) to investigate what he fears may be a mad repeat killer. Also joining them is Sarah Howard (Dakota Fanning), Roosevelt's secretary, who's vowed to become New York's first woman police detective. Using cutting-edge police techniques of the day, this band of outsiders sets out to solve a crime that grows to involve some of the city's most menacing power figures -- and may lead our heroes to see, hear, and do things they never imagined. 

Is it any good?

Menacing, bloody, and as pitch-black as TV dramas get, this period piece might veer over the line into exploitative and trashy if it weren't so artfully done. Murder mysteries about young dead sex workers are a staple on network TV police procedurals, of course, and though they're usually female, flipping the gender doesn't remove the staleness from the premise. But setting the action in 19th-century NYC? Now, that has promise, and clearly some money's been spent re-creating a Gangs of New York-era Manhattan. There are puffed sleeves and high collars, corsets and horse-drawn carriages, fires in ash barrels and clacky old typewriters and chamber pots. The horribly mutilated body discovered in the show's first episode is found on "the new bridge": The Williamsburg.

But most of all, there are cops and investigators prising apart a particularly juicy mystery using really old-school police methods (fingerprinting is state of the art), and giving us fascinating peeks at a long-gone world. It helps, too, and the band of sleuths who come together to solve The Alienist's murders include strong proto-feminist Sarah and a pair of Jewish detectives who get short shrift on the mighty-Irish police force. These characters have a modern "other" status that presents an easier access point to viewers who might be turned off by seeing a whole bunch of smug white guys solving a murder. This show isn't for kids, and it isn't a comfort TV watch -- but for lovers of vintage crime and dramas about very bad things, The Alienist will cast a spell. 

Talk to your kids about ...

  • Families can talk about why murder mysteries are such an enduring staple of television drama. Think about some modern murder mysteries such as Law & Order and The Killing. How is The Alienist alike? How is it different?

  • Period dramas have to find ways to convey to the viewer where and when they're set. How does this drama tell the viewer where you are in space and time? Would you know without the opening titles? How?

  • If you've read the book this series is based on, how does it compare? What's the same? What was changed? Many people say "the book is always better." Is it true in this case? 

  • What does this show say about women's roles at the time? 

TV details

For kids who love historical drama

Our editors recommend

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate

About these links

Common Sense Media, a nonprofit organization, earns a small affiliate fee from Amazon or iTunes when you use our links to make a purchase. Thank you for your support.

Read more

Our ratings are based on child development best practices. We display the minimum age for which content is developmentally appropriate. The star rating reflects overall quality and learning potential.

Learn how we rate