A lot or a little?
The parents' guide to what's in this book.
What parents need to know
Parents need to know that Ingrid is a plucky, brave Sherlock Holmes fan who decides to solve a crime on her own. Parents and readers may be freaked out by some of her choices -- she is impulsive and dishonest, repeatedly putting herself in danger. She lies to her parents, the police chief, and friends; she sneaks out in the middle of the night and cuts class during the day -- and even copies homework. Mystery fans who are sophisticated enough not to take this dangerous behavior too literally will think her a modern-day Nancy Drew and be pleased to know that they can follow Ingrid into other books -- or be inspired to check out some other detective heroes.
- Parents say
- Kids say
What's the story?
One day when Ingrid is late for soccer practice she decides to run there, rather than wait for her mother to pick her up. She soon gets lost, and meets Cracked-up Katie, a local eccentric, who calls her a cab. The next day she finds out that Katie has been murdered, and realizes that she left her cleats at Katie's house. Worried that she will be implicated, she sneaks into Katie's house and takes back her shoes. But while there she discovers several clues that the police don't know about. When she finds out that the police have arrested two suspects who are probably innocent, she decides that, like her hero Sherlock Holmes, she must solve the murder herself.
Is it any good?
Fans who don't take all the drama too literally will be pleased to know this is the first of a series and can follow intrepid Ingrid into other mysteries. This is the first children's book by Peter Abrahams, a popular writer of adult mysteries, and it follows the teen-girl-detective formula pretty closely: plucky girl stumbles into mystery, decides to solve it herself rather than confide in adults, juggles mystery with school life, avoids being noticed by clueless parents, gets into mortal danger, solves mystery, explains it to police. It's basically Nancy Drew updated for the 21st century. Some parents may find it troubling that Ingrid is impulsive and dishonest, and repeatedly puts herself in danger by lying and sneaking around -- and some readers may be bothered by the tacked-on dramatic denouement.
Talk to your kids about ...
Families can talk Ingrid's character. She often puts herself in danger and lies to people -- but she does ultimately solve a crime. Is she a hero in your eyes? In reviews of this book, Publishers Weekly called Ingrid "charming" and Kirkus says her "behavior will have readers both rooting and worrying for her simultaneously." Do you agree with either of these descriptions? What words would you use to describe her?
Also, the Common Sense Media review calls Ingrid a "Nancy Drew updated for the 21st century." If you've read those books, do you agree? What other detective teen books have you read? What's appealing about the idea of a teen spy or a teen detective?
Our editors recommend
For kids who love mysteries
Top advice and articles
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.