A Lot or a Little?
What you will—and won't—find in this book.
Much about fighting in a Roman Colosseum, how gladiators entered the ring, how they sometimes flooded the arena to stage mock sea battles, what weapons and armor were used, how gladiators trained and lived in schools called ludus. Stories of real people who have disappeared or were thought dead throughout history such as Julius Caesar's son Caesarian, Sir Frances Drake, and female Japanese warrior Ohori Tsuruhime. Different dinosaurs and prehistoric sea creatures are described as they are encountered, down to when they lived and when they went extinct. Descriptions of a crannog -- a defensive Gaelic island. A lecture on the major arteries and vulnerable points in the human body.
Survival isn't possible in this series without teamwork, ingenuity, resilience, bravery, trusting in your friends. Freedom and control over one's own destiny is the ultimate goal.
Positive Role Models
Cade continues to be the brave leader in this story. He makes compassionate decisions when he can, befriending and helping an orphan boy and a mini-dino with a broken wing. He's also a quick, strategic thinker. He builds stronger bonds with his friends in this book and with his trainer, an old Japanese woman who is savvier than she looks. Characters are diverse: Cade is half-Indian, his friends are Black and Asian.
Violence & Scariness
Roman Colosseum-style battles where teens are forced to kill with swords, arrows, spears. Some teens are eaten by dinosaurs in the ring; some brief graphic descriptions of carnage. Main character is beaten unconscious, ending up with two black eyes, is almost fed to sea monster. He fights another giant monster with many injuries. Graphic description of weapon removed from gut and the hole stitched up. Main characters are taken hostage and sold. Enslaved people are whipped on a ship, with stories of their torturous lives (one had his eyes plucked out, others their tongues removed) and the terrible smell below decks as they sit in their own filth. Mention that a young boy had his tongue cut out.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Violence & Scariness in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
Sex, Romance & Nudity
Some kissing. A teen boy and girl modestly bathe together.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Sex, Romance & Nudity in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
"S--t" is said rarely, same with "damn," "bastard," "bloody hell," and "ass."
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Language in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking
Underage Cade drinks as little gross hard alcohol as he can with a pirate while he watches that pirate get drunk and pass out.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Drinking, Drugs & Smoking in your kid's entertainment guide.Get started
Parents Need to Know
Parents need to know that The Challenger is the second book in a sci-fi survival series by Taran Matharu, author of the Summoner series. Teens stranded on an alien planet that fuses many time periods on Earth fight for their lives again, this time after being captured by enslavers and sent to an island that replicates the Roman empire. They're forced into coliseum-style gladiator battles where they kill other teens with swords, arrows, and spears. Some of these teens are eaten by dinosaurs in the ring, with some brief graphic descriptions of the carnage. Other violence includes beatings by pirates, a fight against a giant monster that yields many injuries, and a graphic description of a weapon removed from a gut and the hole stitched up. Other mature content includes a bit of swearing (not beyond "s--t"), some reluctant underage drinking to get a pirate talking, some kissing, and a teen boy and girl modestly bathing together. The cast in this series is diverse. Cade, the main character, is half-Indian, and his friends are Black and Asian. Cade continues to be the brave leader in this story. He makes compassionate decisions when he can, befriending and helping an orphan boy and a mini-dino with a broken wing. He's also a quick and strategic thinker and builds strong bonds with his friends.
Is It Any Good?
If the idea of scrawny teens training to become gladiators and fighting dinosaurs excites you, then this sci-fi sequel is exactly what you've been looking for. There's a bit of Maze Runner here, plus The Hunger Games, plus the Edge of Extinction series by Laura Martin -- most of this mash-up trilogy has a precedent or three -- but The Challenger and the first book, The Chosen, weave in some fascinating history. If you didn't know that they used to flood the Roman Colosseum for sea battles, now you do. (There's a great NOVA special on this, incidentally.)
The action is at the forefront of the story, especially the teens' tough training regime. But there are a few standout characters, like their savvier-than-she-looks trainer Tsuru and Cade's Roman friend Quintus. Things look pretty grim for the finale, with more challenges ahead and a cruel alien overlord that seems impossible to outsmart. But if they can manage to not get eaten by dinosaurs at the Colosseum, maybe a happy ending and a return to Earth is possible.
Did we miss something on diversity?
Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by suggesting a diversity update.