Parents' Guide to The Rose Field: The Book of Dust, Book 3

The Rose Field book cover: Two faraway people on camelback trudge through a desert at dusk surrounded by hues of gold and pink

Common Sense Media Review

Carrie R. Wheadon By Carrie R. Wheadon , based on child development research. How do we rate?

age 15+

Profound finale bursting with storylines, Lyra's curiosity.

Find family movie night faves faster. Download the app .

Parents Need to Know

Why Age 15+?

Any Positive Content?

Parent and Kid Reviews

What's the Story?

In THE ROSE FIELD, Lyra's hunt for her daemon, Pan, continues, first taking her to the City of the Moon, where lost daemons congregate. A girl missing her daemon tells her that Pan just left, and was headed for the red building in the desert of Karamakan, the place of magic rose oil and possibly the opening into another world where Pan hopes to search for Lyra's imagination. Before Lyra moves on, she sacrifices her precious alethiometer to rescue the girl's daemon from a thief. Without the alethiometer to guide her to Pan—who faces unseen dangers in the desert alone—she must rely on a mysterious mathematician named Abdel Ionides; an esteemed trader in Aleppo; Malcom, her longtime friend and spy; witches; and even gryphons on the long road to the red building. Always on her tail is Marcel Delamare, the president of the New High Council of the Magisterium, who aims to wage war against every opening to another world and with anyone who advocates for free thought and religious liberty.

Is It Any Good?

Our review:
Parents say : Not yet rated
Kids say : Not yet rated

It's hard to judge this epic on the same star scale as other children's books because of its philosophical depth and because there's no hero who compares to Lyra, nor will there ever be. She shares the stage in The Rose Field with so many characters and so many complementary storylines, and yet this intrepid, inquisitive young woman always stands out. She sheds some of her depression from Book 2 and replaces it with determination and grit, and with a clear purpose in a murky world where so many deep questions need answers. She must find Pan, who is a part of herself, so she must face herself. There are many near-reunions earlier in the story between Lyra and Pan and between Lyra and the resourceful Malcolm. It's almost maddening, but obviously on purpose for the tension. It's odd to say that a book of almost 700 pages ends too soon, but more wrapping up of the minor storylines and a clearer sense of what's to come for Lyra's changing world would have been welcome. Also, all the mounting dread about what's really in the red building in the desert didn't pay off as expected. Still, it's a journey philosophically minded readers will no doubt embark upon again and again just for more time with Lyra Silvertongue and the imaginative greatness of the incomparable Philip Pullman.

Talk to Your Kids About ...

  • Families can talk about Lyra's personality in The Rose Field. How does her curiosity help her find the answers she seeks about the imagination and Dust? How does it help her find what's missing in herself?

  • How did the witches and gryphons use teamwork against a common enemy? What was their enemy after? How would it have affected the whole secret commonwealth?

  • There are many storylines intersecting at once in this story. Outside of the main story about Lyra and Pan, what other characters did you enjoy following? Which storylines held the most surprises? What did each storyline reveal about the story as a whole, or were some of them less important?

Book Details

Did we miss something on diversity?

Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by

The Rose Field book cover: Two faraway people on camelback trudge through a desert at dusk surrounded by hues of gold and pink

What to Read Next

Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.

See how we rate